📐 Planning Board
Planning Board Waives Cost-Prohibitive ADU Fees
The Croton Planning Board unanimously approved two accessory dwelling unit applications at 43 Riverview Trail (750 sq. ft., 5-0) and 284 Grand Street (499 sq. ft., 5-0), waiving parkland recreation fees on both after board members called the mandatory fee potentially cost-prohibitive. The board also granted final signage approval for Mirage Mirror & Glass at 425 South Riverside Avenue and learned a 49-unit building proposal for that same address is expected soon.
◆ Key Actions & Decisions
- **Resolutions Passed**
- Accessory Cottage approval for 43 Riverview Trail (Roseanne MacDonald, Tax Map 68.17-2-11): 750 sq. ft. modular cottage replacing a dilapidated structure; vote 5-0. Parkland recreation fee waived.
- Accessory Cottage approval for 284 Grand Street (James Corbett, Tax Map 68.17-3-54): 499 sq. ft. conversion of existing garage; vote 5-0. Parkland recreation fee waived.
- Final Signage Approval for Mirage Mirror & Glass at 425 South Riverside Avenue (Sign Permit #20250002); vote 5-0.
- Approval of December 9, 2025 draft minutes, as amended; vote 5-0.
- **Resolutions Failed**
- None.
- **Applications Reviewed**
- *43 Riverview Trail (MacDonald):* Applicant received prior ZBA variances for street proximity, 3'3" height, and front door visibility. Modular home to be crane-delivered in two sections; all-electric with existing water/sewer; new gravel parking area; no tree removal; land disturbance under 5,000 sq. ft. Three-year build clock applies.
- *284 Grand Street (Corbett):* Garage-to-ADU conversion for in-laws' summer use; same footprint; one bedroom plus small office; colors to match main house. Three-year build clock applies.
- *425 South Riverside Avenue (Mirage Mirror & Glass):* Housekeeping item — ABVE review and sign permit had been issued in February 2025, but applicant missed returning to the Planning Board for final approval.
- **Public Comments**
- Constancia Warren and Bruce Dollar (1 Young Avenue): Asked about redevelopment plans for 425 South Riverside Avenue. Board clarified this agenda item was signage only and that neighbors would receive mailed notice when a redevelopment application triggers a public hearing.
- Barry Donaldson (14 King Street): Asked whether the Village has a master plan addressing commercial/residential growth areas, natural landscape, and Main Street. Chairman Luntz directed him to the Village's Comprehensive Plan, available online.
- **Reports**
- *Village Engineer Vincent Salanitro:* Expects the owner of 425 South Riverside Avenue to submit an application for a 49-unit building. Regarding 1360 Albany Post Road, the applicant reported being in contact with the Department of Transportation, which is expected to reach out to the Engineering Office.
- *Steve Krisky:* Reported that the Conservation Advisory Council is developing a "Dark Sky" code for the Village and will issue a comprehensive recommendation.
- *Village Attorney Joshua Subin (arrived late):* Advised that board members cannot discuss a specific property without the applicant present.
Croton's Planning Board unanimously signed off on two new accessory dwelling units Monday night, but not before putting the Village Board of Trustees on notice: the state-mandated parkland recreation fee attached to ADU approvals may be undermining the very housing type the village says it wants to encourage.
Both applications — a 750-square-foot modular cottage at 43 Riverview Trail and a 499-square-foot garage conversion at 284 Grand Street — carried draft resolutions requiring applicants to pay a fee in lieu of parkland under Village Code §230-73. In both cases, the board voted 5-0 to strike that condition.
"The fee could represent a large part of the overall cost for the applicant," board member Geoff Haynes said during the Riverview Trail discussion. Steve Krisky agreed to waive the fee to avoid disturbing precedent set by recent ADU approvals, but added pointedly that he hoped the Village Board would either give the Planning Board flexibility on the matter or restructure the fee itself.
At 43 Riverview Trail, owner Roseanne MacDonald plans to demolish a dilapidated cottage and replace it with a two-section modular home delivered by crane. The property already secured ZBA variances for street proximity, height, and front-door visibility. At 284 Grand Street, James Corbett will convert an existing garage into a one-bedroom cottage for his in-laws' summer visits, keeping the same footprint and matching the main house's exterior.
Both approvals carry standard conditions: a three-year clock to commence work, as-built surveys, visible street addresses for emergency vehicles, and a requirement that new owners notify the Building Department within 90 days if they wish to continue the ADU use. Krisky also requested that exterior floodlights at the Riverview Trail property use downward-throwing shades.
In other business, the board granted final signage approval for Mirage Mirror & Glass at 425 South Riverside Avenue — a housekeeping item that drew two neighboring residents concerned about broader redevelopment. Village Engineer Vincent Salanitro confirmed that a 49-unit building proposal for that property is expected to come before the board.
Residents with questions about the Village Comprehensive Plan can find it on the municipal website. The next Planning Board meeting agenda and materials are posted at croton-ny.gov.
◆ Meeting Index
Topics Discussed
accessory dwelling unitsparkland recreation feesignage approvalDark Sky code425 South Riverside Avenue redevelopmentComprehensive Plan
People
Rob Luntz — Planning Board Chairman
John Ghegan — Planning Board Member
Geoffrey Haynes — Planning Board Member
Steve Krisky — Planning Board Member
Eva Thaddeus — Planning Board Member
Vincent Salanitro — Village Engineer
Stacey Nachtaler — Village Board Trustee & Planning Board Liaison
Len Simon — Village Board Trustee & Planning Board Liaison
Joshua Subin — Village Attorney
Roseanne MacDonald — Property Owner, 43 Riverview Trail
Dean Borelli — Westchester Modular Home
James Corbett — Property Owner, 284 Grand Street
Bob Small — Builder, 284 Grand Street
Constancia Warren — Resident, 1 Young Avenue
Bruce Dollar — Resident, 1 Young Avenue
Barry Donaldson — Resident, 14 King Street
Karen Stapleton — Secretary to the Planning Board
Locations
43 Riverview Trail284 Grand Street425 South Riverside Avenue1 Young Avenue14 King Street1360 Albany Post RoadMain Street
Upcoming Dates
2029-01-27 — Deadline to commence work on 43 Riverview Trail accessory cottage (3-year clock)
2029-01-27 — Deadline to commence work on 284 Grand Street accessory cottage (3-year clock)