The Croton-on-Hudson Board of Trustees meeting on March 11 opened with a celebration of local environmental stewardship, but the board unanimously rejected funding for a proposed review of the village’s justice court. The meeting featured the unveiling of a collaborative quilt by the group Croton 100, which documents the village's grassroots climate action. However, the procedural highlight was the Board's decision to vote down a resolution that would have funded a study to explore the operations of the Village Justice Court. A Fabric of Community Action The board room was crowded with residents eager to see the unveiling of the third quilt created by Croton 100, a local climate action group. Mayor Brian Pugh invited the members to the front of the room to reveal the artwork.
Officials at the dais during the March 11 Sustainability Quilt presentation.
Officials at the dais during the March 11 Sustainability Quilt presentation. Watch this moment
Mayor Brian Pugh described the quilt as an artistic demonstration of grassroots climate action. Patti Buchanan of Croton 100 explained that the quilt chronicles sustainability efforts across four "pillars" of the community: municipal government, businesses, public facilities, and households. Notably, the quilt highlights the school district's installation of solar panels and electric school buses. Buchanan explained that the quilt’s four corners illustrate the district’s school buildings and their rooftop solar installations. The quilt also features contributions from local businesses and specific squares representing 12 different household actions, such as composting and switching to electric heat pumps. Buchanan said the legend explains the household actions represented on the quilt, including electric vehicles, heat pumps and clean electricity. In an emotional moment, Buchanan revealed that the border fabric was made from silk saris that belonged to her late mother-in-law, repurposed to symbolize global connections. Court Study Proposal Voted Down Following the quilt presentation, the meeting shifted to a more divisive topic: the future of the Village Justice Court. The Board was set to consider a resolution to hire a consultant for $19,750 to review the court's operations, a move many residents viewed as a prelude to consolidation with the Town of Cortlandt. In a unanimous rejection, all five members of the Board voted against the resolution. The vote was 5-0 against, with Trustee Simon, Trustee Nicholson, Trustee Nachtaler, Trustee Slippen, and Mayor Pugh all voting Nay. The written minutes record: “Trustee Simon Nay, Trustee Nicholson Nay, Trustee Nachtaler Nay, Trustee Slippen Nay, Mayor Pugh Nay. MOTION FAILED.” Trustee Simon stated that the board intended to set the matter aside and that none of the proposals for studying court operations had the support of all five members at that time. He said all organizations should be subject to periodic review. Trustee Nora Nicholson said she had not favored court consolidation but had a duty to examine whether village departments operate as efficiently as possible. She said she was proud that the board had listened to residents and one another. The recording transcript attributes these remarks to Nicholson; the written minutes attribute the passage to Nachtaler, the conflict described in the earlier correction above. The minutes summarize Mayor Pugh’s position: “since the preference of the community is not for consolidation of our court, he does not foresee proposing any study in the future.” Residents Sound Off During the public comment period, residents criticized the lack of transparency surrounding the study and the potential closure of the court. Joel Gingold argued that a village cost study would not adequately account for residents’ travel and waiting time at the Town of Cortlandt court, and urged the board not to spend money on the study. Casey Raskob, the Village Prosecutor, emphasized that state regulations dictate court operations regardless of location, questioning the validity of a study meant to find cost savings. “No consultant is gonna be able to do something about this and fashion a different result,”Read 36:06▶ Raskob said. He argued that state requirements constrain how local courts operate and defended the Village Court’s work. Village Justice Sam Watkins, who said he had served for almost twenty years, stated he does not believe moving the court to the Town of Cortlandt will save money and does not believe the Town court would show the same compassion as the local Village Court. Resident Montana opposed moving the court and warned that it could be a slippery slope toward removing more of Croton's essential services. Paul Doyle suggested that if the Board insists on moving forward, the study should be subject to a Permissive Referendum. Financials In other business, the Board approved the payment of bills: $216,684.13 from the general fund, $10,301.07 from the water fund, $5,437.69 from the sewer fund, and $33,712.27 from the capital fund. The Board also authorized the purchase of a new Seagrave Marauder pumper to replace Engine 119 at a cost of $1,789,929, approved an $8,000 upgrade to the Village website through CivicPlus, and declared the proposed rehabilitation of the Half Moon Bay Bridge consistent with the Village's Local Waterfront Revitalization Program. The quilt will be displayed in the Municipal Building for the public to view. The future of the court study remains uncertain, with Mayor Pugh indicating he does not foresee proposing any study in the future.