Interview with Anderson, Jeremiah
After dinner was over he opened the bundle and approached mother who alarmed ran for protection behind my father, fearing he intended some injury. He [then] said, "these things are yours". She said, "they are not. Keep them away! _ I'll have none of your things!" He then said to my father, "don't you remember the soldier that was shot through the body, and was all night in your house? I am he. Your wife, I think, saved me, and I feel towards her as though she were my mother"! He He then showed the scar in his breast, and my father said "Betsey, these must be your things", and she then recognized and took them. He said he had come 200 miles to restore
them. He was, I think, a New Hampshire man, belonging to Sheldon's horse." When he first spoke my mother was fearful he was laying a trap for her."
Shubal Reynolds told me that his brother.... Reynolds informed him that he was once taken by Shube Merritt, and after his surrender Shubal Merritt told him to stand still, then retired back a few paces and said: "Now if my gun goes off you're a dead man, but if it misses you shall have quarter. Shube then pulled the trigger, the gun missed fire, and quarter was given. Reynolds after this declared if he ever met Shube he would kill him, peace or no peace. When Shube Merritt was entrapped at New Rochelle he ran to the head of the stairs, pistol cocked in hand, and pointing it at the whale boatmen exclaimed: "The first man that steps upon these stairs, I'll