Mandeville, James, 1760-1848
John M. McDonald interview — 1845-09-23
James Mandeville (1760-1848) participated in an expedition that ventured south from Peekskill into present-day Bronx County on January 24, 1783, with the intention of capturing Loyalist Colonel James DeLancey. Although the party did not capture DeLancey, it did take prisoners and plunder, and fought a small skirmish at Dobbs Ferry as it withdrew northward through Westchester County. The men then stopped to rest at the Orser farm in north Ossining on the Hudson River. Here, they were attacked by Refugees, to whom Mandeville and a number of other men surrendered. Mandeville describes the escape of John Odell, a Westchester Guide, who was pursued by Samuel Kipp and Gilbert Totten on the ice of the frozen Hudson River. He describes his experience as a prisoner of war, noting that his uniform and boots were stolen by Shubael Merritt. He also states that John Paulding, a captor of British Major John André and a member of the expedition, received special treatment “in consequence of the celebrity he had acquired.” Mandeville concludes the interview by describing the death of George McChain, the only member of the expedition who was killed, and the refusal of the Refugees to grant him quarter.
Manuscript page facsimiles
High-resolution images served from the Westchester County Historical Society's IIIF endpoint. Click any page to view full size.
Transcription
164 1845. Sept. 23. James Mandeville. On Friday morning January 24th 1783. we started from Peekskill hamlet or village (a village of five or eight houses at this time) being about or upwards of fifty in number, that is, thirty three from near Peekskill, (and the rest about twenty from the east part of Courtlandt’s Manor. (Sprinks and Salem) It was an enterprise planned by Colonel Samuel Drake and Mr. Peter Van Tessel to carry off Colonel Delancey, because he had been a public disturber and his men plunderers, and to guard against treachery the point of attack was to be kept secret from us till we reached West Farms, that is, we did not know prewhere, precisely, we were going to strike. We went down the North River road to Dobbs Ferry, then turning east got upon the Tuckahoe road, and crossing Nint’s Bridge entered West Farms by way of East Chester about midnight [page break] 165 1845. (Ten or twelve of us were left near the Bridge with the horses, of which guard I was one.) Notwithstanding every precaution and although we pushed forward and rapidly, there seemed to be a general alarm the moment we appeared. bells ringing and bugles blowing. We crossed the bridge and surrounded the house, but the Colonel was not to be found, having gone out as the inmates told us to a cock fight, but we afterwards learnt he concealed himself in an out-house on the first alarm of our approach and so escaped. We took the Colonel’s house two prisoners fifteen horses and a variety of plunder, - and then retreated by the North River road with as much expedition as our jaded horses could bear. We feared a pursuit and before we reached Yonkers a party overtook us. It being night, however, and their number at first probably small we kept them at bay until we reached the new Livingston villa [page break] 166 1845. near Dobbs Ferry when daylight appeared and they seemed preparing for a charge. Here we halted and prepared to resist but they contented themselves with discharging their carbines and rifles at us and we returned the fire. The enemy now halted and we passed through Carrytown and Sing Sing without molestation being no longer pursued. The party from Salem and Stephentown wishing to take the nearest road home were anxious to leave us when we reached (approached) the Croton and we agreed to go to Orser’s house on the banks of the North River, refresh ourselves and our horses and divide our plunder. It was now about 9 o’clock. Am. Our horses were put in the barn, stable, and barn yard and fed, and we proceeded to see our spoils at auction – While these events were going on the enemy were probably reinforced at Dobbs Ferry and renewed the [page break] 167 1845. pursuit, but not overtaking us had pulled up between Tarrytown and Sing Sing and wheeled about to return, when they were overtaken by a man named Curry who had passed us when we halted near Orsers and who informed them where we were. They now once more pushed forward and when they approached Orsers sent one party of about forty or fifty around through a lane who got in our rear and lay in ambush to cut off our retreat. This party by a circuitous march occupied the ground north of Orsers while the other party (of about fifteen or twenty) advanced upon us to the attack under cover of the orchard which extended down the banks of the North River South of the house. Captain Williams had been a verse to our halting here, urging us to cross the Croton and join a guard of about twenty five or thirty men posted at Courtlands [page break] 168 1845. House before stopping, and he was at the very time on the look out, but Kipp who commanded the Refugees took his measures so well that the enemy’s approach was not discovered till they (fired upon the barn) this lower party of fifteen or twenty, discharged their carbines and rifles. The horses alarmed and wounded kicked, plunged, and broke from their fastening in great confusion, and, running north for home were (many of them) captured by the party which advanced and cut off our retreat when they heard the firing. We lost here about eighteen or twenty horses of our own, and likewise the fifteen we had taken at West Farms, and the two prisoners. Rivington’s account is correct in the main, though, I think, the Refugees made more than seven prisoners. [ Fifteen of us were taken prisoners. – We were three months prisoners, that is, till the 28th of April.] When the alarm was first [margin: # See Original top of page 17.] [page break] 169 1845 given we were engaged in selling our spoils. Considering ourselves secure we had posted no sentinels. We ran on the instant for our horses but most of them had escaped, mine among the rest, and not being able to make any resistance I surrendered. I was then a boy of sixteen only and wore my brothers uniform and arms, he being a captain of the West Chester troop of horse, and at the time sick. Williams escaped by the fleetness of his horse. Odell seized the first horse he could find, mounted and tried to escape but was overtaken by Kipp and Totten and pursued on the ice for half a mile or three quarters more. Kipp and Totten were ahead of their men, being probably having probably better mounted. They both struck at Odell, and Totten striking with a drill sword at last hit his cocked hat first and then the bridge of his nose, part of the hat being between, uncut, and intercepting the edge
[margin: 1845.] of the sword. The bony part of the nose being broken Odell carried the mark of this wound with him through life. He escaped by pulling up his horse suddenly and striking at the same time a moment at one of his pursuers a blow which stunned him. He then made for Teiller's Point and escaped before they could recover and overtake. The Officer (a Lieutenant) who commanded the squad at Van Cortland's made no effort to assist us, for which he was afterwards tried by a Court Martial. He might have saved us. He was broken. Kipp's party when he attacked us at Orser's was sixty or seventy in number. One of Kipp's men, the notorious Shube Merritt stripped me of my boots and uniform. We, the prisoners were taken first to Morrisania, then, on Saturday night to the Island (Randall's) opposite Randall's, and put in the log Provost there where we were confined, in want [page break] [margin: 1845.] Jail, and then on Sunday morning to Newyork where, one or two of us who were badly wounded were sent to the hospital, and the rest, Paulding excepted, to the Provost, that is, to the Old Jail. Paulding, in consequence of the celebrity he had acquired as one of the captors of André, was not confined but was entertained by the British officers, messing and living with the Captains and Lieutenants. We were detained prisoners till the 27th or 28th of April, that is, three months. Odell rode during most of the war a very fine grey horse presented to him by Governor Van Courtland, which he lost in the surprise at Orsers but afterwards recovered, the animal returning to the farm where he was raised.
George McChain was the only man killed, and was with me on the banks of the Hudson river when the Refugees came up to us. They gave me quarter, but refused [page break] [margin: 1845.] him of it tho he begged hard. They shot him and cut his body in pieces. The reason assigned for his barbarity was that he had burnt the dwellings and barns belonging to some of the Refugees, and had attempted to set fire to Colonel DeLancey's."
September 23. Samuel Lyon of Yonkers: "When we pursued the Cowboys (September 4. 1781) we first discovered them from the hill near the Old Dutch Church. They were then passing (on the road by) near André's great white wood tree. We held a Council of war and determined to attack them, on the level ground just below Tarrytown, but they got near where Irving now stands before we could attack them."
Capt. Isaac Martling was killed at Tarrytown (on 30th of January 1770 probably) by Nathaniel Underhill.