MINUTES JULY 17 2024
minutes
21 pages
Meeting: portal event 973 (no meeting page on file)
Agenda item: Approval of Minutes — Regular Meeting Minutes - July 17, 2024
Minutes, 21 pages. Attached to agenda item: “Approval of Minutes — Regular Meeting Minutes - July 17, 2024”
Retrieved 2026-04-15 from the village's meeting portal.
View the original PDF ↗
Extracted text
Meeting of the Board of Trustees of the Village of Croton-on-Hudson, NY, held on
Wednesday, July 17, 2024, in the Georgianna Grant Meeting Room at the Stanley
Kellerhouse Municipal Building, Van Wyck Street, Croton-on-Hudson, NY 10520.
1. Mayor Pugh called the meeting to order at 7:00pm and led everyone in the
pledge of allegiance.
Trustee Simon made a motion to approve the following Fiscal Year Vouchers,
claims numbered 24000042-24000299, 24250302-24250339. The Motion
was seconded by Trustee Politi and approved with a 5-0 Vote.
$1,121,136.08
Water Fund
$214,398.03
Sewer Fund
$56,145.19
Capital Fund
$119,567.10
Trust Fund
1,975.00
3. RESPONSE TO QUESTIONS SUBMITTED BY EMAIL - None
4. CORRESPONDENCE
a. Letter from John Sullivan, Esq. representing Neil and Nicole Graham,
requesting that the Village of Croton-on-Hudson formally dedicate a
rectangular piece of property at 33 Mount Green Road, which serves as an
extension of Jasper Road, to resolve access issues for neighboring
parcels.
07/d11fe53a6ab315946a2751d8e44a423877c7dada.pdf
b. Memo from Village Manager Bryan Healy on the Alexander Lane Optimum
Outage
https://play.champds.com/ATT/crotononhudsonny/2024-
07/6c49514890345798a0fe3a3e3e330188840624eb.pdf
Mayor Pugh
Trustee Murtaugh
Village Manager Bryan Healy
Trustee Nicholson
Village Attorney Linda Whitehead
Trustee Politi
Village Treasurer Daniel Tucker
Trustee Simon
Assistant to the Village Manager Emily Mancini
Village Board of Trustees
July 17, 2024
c. Letter from the Hudson Valley Gateway Chamber of Commerce requesting
approval to conduct a Scarecrow Contest in the Village of Croton-on-
Hudson during the month of October.
07/8fa884390dc0d1dd4543135c75b238f83e64b0b1.pdf
Resolution:
On motion by Trustee Simon and seconded by Trustee Politi the Board of
Trustees approved the request from the Hudson Valley Gateway Chamber
of Commerce to conduct a Scarecrow Contest during the month of
October. Motion was approved with a 5-0 vote.
d. Memo from Village Manager Bryan Healy on a request to use the Croton-
Harmon Train Station Parking lot on August 25, 2024, for a music festival.
07/c189c6caf0ed145f6a1ec5bfd0e7ed2825c3bd87.pdf
Village Manager Healy stated that he met with Franki Leon along with the
Police Chief and the Superintendent of Public Works to discuss a number
of issues related to the event. Village Manager Healy advised that he is
recommending that the event end by 7:00pm, alcohol sales conclude one
hour before the end of the event, that they have an appropriate number
of bathrooms, and that private security be hired.
Trustee Simon stated that the organizers are also responsible for
compensating the Village for Police and DPW staff overtime and he is glad
that we are putting safeguards in place.
Trustee Murtaugh asked how we get assurances that everything will be
put in place.
Village Manager Healy stated that we will make sure that we receive the
confirmation from the Porta-Potty company that they will be delivered
before the event, they will also need to provide information regarding the
private security to the Police Chief to make sure they are registered and
licensed. Village Manager Healy added that our Parking Enforcement
Officers will be working that day to help direct people to the proper
parking areas and those attendees will also have to pay for parking.
July 17, 2024
Trustee Nicholson stated that she has some reservations since last year
was a real debacle, information was not presented in the most up-front
way to the Village and asked if they will be charging admission, how many
attendees are they estimating, how many parking spaces will be available
for participants, and are they interested in allowing local businesses to
participate in the event. Trustee Nicholson stated that at this time she
does not see an upside for the Village.
Trustee Politi seconded the vendor question.
Village Manager Healy stated that they expect around 1,000 people, there
is a fee to attend the event which he does not know at this time and
between Sections I, G, A, C and F, there should be around 1,000 parking
spaces.
Mayor Pugh stated that he believes we can make a condition that local
vendors will be given a reasonable opportunity to participate.
After some further discussion, the Board did not approve the request
pending further discussion with the event organizer.
e. Letter from Toni Senecal, Chair of the Croton Business Council, requesting
approval to host Oktoberfest 2024 in the Upper Village on October 5,
2024, from noon to 6pm,
https://play.champds.com/ATT/crotononhudsonny/2024-
07/b327e2ebbd37b9f6d325bd7482e2381f49e7fe52.pdf
Resolution:
On motion by Trustee Simon and seconded by Trustee Nicholson the
Board of Trustees approved the request to hold an Oktoberfest in the
Upper Village on October 5, 2024, from noon to 6pm, (rain date to be
determined). Motion was approved with a 5-0 vote.
f. Press release from the Office of New York State Governor Kathy Hochul
regarding the start of resurfacing projects in Westchester County
https://play.champds.com/ATT/crotononhudsonny/2024-
07/5f04991918f7ff83b917e5978533b0c2ab728ba7.pdf
5. PUBLIC COMMENTS ON AGENDA ITEMS:
July 17, 2024
Tony Granger, 217 Half Moon Bay, Croton on Hudson, stated that he
understands the Village is getting a fee of $1,120 for use of the train station
parking lot for the music festival, but is the Village also getting a cut on the
entrance fees, the application that was submitted last year for the event was
not Franki Leon but rather a Peekskill Entertainment Agency, last year the
music was very loud, and believes that 1000 people is an understatement.
Village Manager Healy stated that the applicants will also be responsible for
overtime costs which the Village approximates to be $15,000 which must be
paid in full before the event. Village Manager Healy explained that the
reason that an admission charge is allowed is that the train station is not a
park and does not fall under those regulations and we allow admission fees
for other events at the train station.
Susan Skrelja, 56 Truesdale Drive, Croton on Hudson, asked the Village to
slow down all of the building and housing initiatives until we know what the
impacts will be from our current developments. Ms. Skrelja stated that she
recently learned that Croton is a “Pro Housing Community” and according to
the “Home and Community Renewal” website, of the eleven mid-Hudson
communities under that program, only two are villages, one being Croton on
Hudson, the others are cities and we as a village of just over 8,000 residents
should not feel that we must be the saviors for affordable housing.
Lauren Davis, 14 Hamilton Avenue, Croton on Hudson, stated that she
opposes six story buildings in Croton and does not want to see zoning
changed to accommodate these types of buildings.
Alex Skrelja, 56 Truesdale Drive, Croton on Hudson, stated that he is not
against development, but asked that we slow down to see how things work
out before we move forward with more development. Mr. Skrelja shared an
email communication where Mayor Pugh where he states: “that the 41-51
development would likely be the last of this kind for the foreseeable future
of Croton, and that the thirty-three units of affordable housing are an
important downpayment on closing our deficit for affordable housing and
any new affordable housing in the coming decade will be smaller
developments”. Mr. Skrelja and asked what percentage of units would be
affordable for the proposed LOT A development.
Mayor Pugh stated that under the AHOP Program, (Affordable Home
Ownership Opportunity Program) there is the potential for the LOT A
development to be 100% affordable, but the exact composition has not been
Village Board of Trustees
July 17, 2024
determined at this time and while the RFP (Request for Proposal) indicated
that we were looking at a 20% affordable rental option, the developer is also
seeking the opportunity for affordable ownership which is distinguishable
from the 41-51 Maple Street development which is all rental. Mayor Pugh
stated that this would be a chance for people to build generational wealth,
build a future in the Village and have the security of ownership.
Naureen Shabid, 1608 Half Moon Bay, Croton on Hudson, stated that both
the 1 Half Moon Bay and the LOT A properties, if developed, are going to be
a nightmare when it comes to traffic and school enrollment and believes that
these projects should be on the ballot.
Trustee Politi stated that she believes there is a lot of fear that is not going
to come to fruition and does not believe that the few children that may
come into the school district is going to be an issue for the school district.
Village Attorney Whitehead explained that there are no provisions in the law
that would allow something like this to be put on the ballot, under the law,
there is a limited list of things that can go up for a Referendum and the
Board does not have the option to put anything they want on the ballot.
Village Attorney Whitehead also stressed that the impact on traffic and
schools will all be studied as part of the review process.
Michael Mamone, 19 Young Avenue, Croton on Hudson, stated that he
believes the recent developments are disastrous, and is concerned that if we
add more developments and stores people will not have any place to park
and asked the Board to reconsider the Residential Parking System in his
neighborhood.
Sanjeeb Shabid, 1608 Half Moon Bay, Croton on Hudson, stated that Croton
Point Avenue gets very crowded at 4:00pm when the Metro North worker’s
shift ends and feels that adding a housing development will only add to the
congestion, concerned with adding more children to the school system and
where is the money coming from if the LOT A development is going to be
affordable ownership.
Mayor Pugh explained that the source of funding for affordability housing if
below 20% comes out of the pocket of the developer or the other tenants
because there will be some cost subsidy between the market rate tenants
and the affordable units, if it is 100% affordable the funding would come
from State programs like AHOP.
July 17, 2024
Lisa Stenson Desamours, 1400 Half Moon Bay Drive, Croton on Hudson,
stated that while it has been helpful to have a traffic light at the train station
it can also be very challenging and believes this development will add more
congestion, the project should not have any adverse impact on current
homeowners and is concerned that we will be losing daily parking spaces
and asked if the developer will receive any tax abatements.
Mayor Pugh stated that there will be no tax abatements, the development
will be taxed in the usual manner of an apartment building.
Village Manager Healy explained that when the DPW facility was demolished
at the train station the Village gained approximately 200 parking spaces and
those spaces are more than enough to cover the spaces that will be lost
when LOT A is sold, we also have an additional 50 spaces along South
Riverside Avenue which are only used occasionally if there is a need for
overflow parking.
Trustee Simon reminded everyone that the Village has seen a reduction in
parking at the train station in the post Covid era.
Village Manager Healy stated that we are at 70% of where we were before
the pandemic.
Marilyn Grantner, 115 Cleveland Drive, Croton on Hudson, stated that there
are residents in our community who are looking to downsize and would love
to continue to live in Croton and directed residents to the 2019 Housing
Needs Assessment Study which can be found on the Village’s website.
Cathy Connelly, 80 Young Avenue, Croton on Hudson, stated that she
objects to more development in Croton, people moved to Croton to live in a
small Village and asked the Board to slow down to give us time to see what
effects our current development has on the community as well as our
schools and traffic.
6. PROPOSED RESOLUTIONS:
Resolution #145 of 2024
On motion of TRUSTEE SIMON, seconded by TRUSTEE NICHOLSON, the following
resolution was adopted by the Board of Trustees of the Village of Croton- on- Hudson, New
York with a 5-0 vote.
July 17, 2024
WHEREAS the Village of Croton-on-Hudson has been awarded a grant under the New
York State Energy Research and Development Authority (NYSERDA) Clean Energy
Communities (CEC) Program, and
WHEREAS the grant, Agreement Number 222436, provides funding in the amount of
$17,500 to support the installation of 12 Networked Level 2 Electric Vehicle Charging
Ports at the Croton-Harmon Train Station Parking Lot, and
WHEREAS the project will contribute to the reduction of greenhouse gas emissions and
support the Village’s clean energy goals,
NOW THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that the Village Board of the Village of Croton-on-
Hudson hereby authorizes the Village Manager to sign the NYSERDA Agreement,
including all necessary documents and exhibits, and to undertake any actions necessary
to fulfill the requirements of the grant.
Resolution #146 of 2024
On motion of TRUSTEE MURTAUGH, seconded by TRUSTEE SIMON, the following
resolution was adopted by the Board of Trustees of the Village of Croton- on- Hudson, New
York with a 5-0 vote.
WHEREAS the Village Board of Trustees has received a special permit application from
Sprocket Power of Bedford Hills, New York, proposing the installation of an integrated
energy system at Croton Auto Park, located at 1 Municipal Place, comprising of a battery
energy storage system with a 280 kWh output, and
WHEREAS a Site Development Plan has been submitted with the application, and
WHEREAS Tier 2 Battery Energy Storage Systems are permitted through the issuance of
a special permit by the Village Board of Trustees within the C- 2 zoning district, and
WHEREAS this action is a Type II action under the New York State Environmental Quality
Review Act, which does not require an environmental review,
NOW THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED that the Village Board of Trustees hereby refers the
special permit application to the Planning Board for a recommendation back to the Village
Board of Trustees, and
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that the Village Board hereby directs the Village Clerk to
notify the Westchester County Planning Department of this application in accordance with
law.
July 17, 2024
DISCUSSION:
Trustee Murtaugh stated that the main reason this has come into play is that the parent
company of Dodge/Chrysler/Jeep/Stellantis has insisted upon electrification capabilities at
all of their dealerships nationwide and they are taking advantage of Croton’s embrace of
modern technology.
Village Manager Healy explained that when the Board amended the Solar Law, we
removed the requirement for a Special Permit and it now just requires a Building Permit,
the only aspect of their plan that the Board is required to review is the battery storage
system.
Trustee Simon stated that it is a commitment on the part of Croton Auto Park to make a
long-term investment in Croton since it involves a significant amount of dollars to do this
project.
Mayor Pugh asked if this information has been shared with the Fire Department.
Village Manager Healy advised that he did share this with the Fire Department, they have
provided their comments with the Village Engineer and those comments have been given
to Sprocket Power and incorporated into the agreement.
Resolution #147 of 2024
On motion of TRUSTEE SIMON, seconded by TRUSTEE NICHOLSON, the following
resolution was adopted by the Board of Trustees of the Village of Croton- on- Hudson, New
York with a 5-0 vote.
WHEREAS the Village of Croton-on-Hudson, New York, solicited bids for Two (2) License
Plate Reader (LPR) Systems in Bid No. 5-2024, and
WHEREAS the bids were publicly opened and read aloud on July 5, 2024, and
WHEREAS the Village Manager has reviewed the bids and recommended that the award
be made to the lowest responsible bidder,
NOW THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED that the Board of Trustees of the Village of Croton-
on-Hudson hereby awards Bid 5-2024 for Two (2) License Plate Reader (LPR) Systems to
Integrated Technical Systems, Inc. of Wallingford, CT in the amount of $39,810.
Resolution #148 of 2024
Village Board of Trustees
July 17, 2024
On motion of TRUSTEE SIMON, seconded by TRUSTEE POLTI, the following resolution was
adopted by the Board of Trustees of the Village of Croton- on- Hudson, New York with a 5-0
vote.
WHEREAS in May 2024, the Department of Public Works listed various materials and
pieces of equipment for auction, and
WHEREAS on May 22, 2024, all bids for the auction were closed, resulting in a total bid
amount of $20,865; and
WHEREAS, the Superintendent of Public Works has requested that $10,165 be
transferred into the Capital Equipment account H5110.2010.24467, and
WHEREAS the Chief of Police has requested $10,700 be transferred into the Police –
Vehicles account A3120.2010, and
WHEREAS these funds will be used to purchase newer vehicles and equipment, aiding the
fleet maintenance program by reducing future funding requests and enabling mid-fiscal
year purchases,
NOW THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED that the Village Treasurer is authorized to make the
following budget amendment to the 2024-2025 General Fund and Capital Fund budgets
as follows:
GENERAL FUND REVENUES
Increase
A1000.2665
Sales of Equipment
$20,865
GENERAL FUND EXPESNES
Increase
A3120.2010
Police – Vehicles
$10,700
CAPITAL FUND EXPESNES
Increase
H5110.2010.24467
Capital Equipment
$10,165
Resolution #149 of 2024
Village Board of Trustees
July 17, 2024
On motion of TRUSTEE SIMON, seconded by TRUSTEE NICHOLSON, the following
resolution was adopted by the Board of Trustees of the Village of Croton- on- Hudson, New
York with a 5-0 vote.
WHEREAS the onsite audit has been scheduled for the 2023-2024 fiscal year end, and
WHEREAS the following budget transfers are required as detailed in the attached
schedules,
NOW THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED that the Board of Trustees authorizes the Village
Treasurer to make the following budget transfers to the 2023-2024 General, Water, and
Sewer Fund budgets as follows:
Increase Expenses
Dept
Item
Description
A1010
BOT-PERSONNEL SRVCS PT
A1010
BOT-PERSONNEL SRVCS TAPE MEETI
A1110
JUSTICE COURT-PERSONNEL SRVCS
A1110
JUSTICE COURT-PERS SRVCS OT
A1210
MAYOR-PERSONNEL SRVCS
A1230
MANAGER-PERSONNEL SRVCS
A1230
MANAGER-PERSONNEL SRVCS OT
A1230
MANAGER-CONTRACTUAL
A1230
MANAGER-TELEPHONE
A1320
AUDITOR-CONTRACTUAL
A1325
TREASURER-PERSONNEL SRVCS
A1325
TREASURER-PERSONNEL SRVCS OT
A1325
TREASURER-SUPPLIES
A1355
ASSESSOR-PERSONNEL SRVCS PT
A1410
CLERK-PERSONNEL SRVCS PT
A1410
CLERK-PERSONNEL SRVCS OT
A1410
CLERK- SUPPLIES
A1410
VILLAGE CLERK-TELEPHONE
A1420
LAW-PERSONNEL SRVCS PT
A1420
LAW-SUPPLIES
A1440
ENGINEER-TELEPHONE
A1620
BUILDINGS-PERSONNEL SRVCS
A1620
BUILDINGS-NATURAL GAS
A1640
GARAGE-PERSONNEL SRVCS OT
A1640
GARAGE-CONTRACTUAL
Village Board of Trustees
July 17, 2024
A1640
GARAGE-VEHICLE MAINT SUPPLIES
A1650
COMM-TELEPHONE
A1680
DATA PROCESSING-SUPPLIES
A1950
TAXES & ASSESSMENTS-CONTRACTUA
A1960
REFUNDS ON REAL PROP-CONTRACTU
A1980
MCTM TAX PAYROLL-CONTRACTUAL
A3120
POLICE-PERSONNEL SRVCS OT
A3120
POLICE-PERS SRVCS OT INVESTIG
A3120
POLICE-TELEPHONE
A3189
TELEPHONE
A3410
FIRE-EQUIPMENT
A3410
TOWER LADDER 44 REPLACEMENT
A3410
FIRE-CONTRACTUAL
A3410
FIRE-SUPPLIES ADMINISTRATION
A3410
FIRE-FIRE HOSE
A3410
FIRE-EQUIPMENT SUPPLIES
A3410
FIRE-FIRST AID SUPPLIES
A3410
FIRE-ENERGY ELECTRICITY
A3410
FIRE-COPIER MAINT/LEASING
A3410
FIRE-TELEPHONE
A3410
FIRE-BLDGS & GROUNDS MAINT
A3410
FIRE-VEHICLE REPAIRS
A3410
FIRE-PHYSICALS/INNOCULATIONS
A4540
AMBULANCE-CONTRACTUAL
A4540
AMBULANCE-TRAINING
A5110
ST MAINT-PERSONNEL SRVCS
A5110
ST MAINT-PERSONNEL SRVCS OT
A5110
ST MAINT-PERSONNEL SRVCS COMP
A5110
ST MAINT-EQUIPMENT REPAIRS
A5140
BRUSH-PERSONNEL SRVCS
A5142
SNOW-CONTRACTUAL
A5183
PUBLIC WRKS-PERSONNEL SRVCS
A5650
PARKING-PERSONNEL SRVCS PT
A5650
PARKING-PERSONNEL SRVCS OT
A5650
PERSONAL SERVICES COMP
A7020
REC-PERSONNEL SRVCS
A7110
PARKS-PERSONNEL SRVCS
A7110
PARKS-PERSONNEL SVRCS OT
A7140
COM REC-PERSONNEL SRVCS
A7140
COM REC-PERSONNEL SRVCS PT
Village Board of Trustees
July 17, 2024
GENERAL FUND
Increase Exp (Cont.)
Dept
Item
Description
A7140
COM REC-PERSONNEL SRVCS OT
A7140
COM REC-CONTRACTUAL
A7180
SPEC REC-PERSONNEL SRVCS PT
A7310
YOUTH-PERSONNEL SRVCS PT
A7550
CELEBRATIONS-PERS SRVCS PT
A7550
CELEBRATIONS-PERS SRVCS OT
A8090
RECYCLING-PERSONNEL SRVCS
A8090
RECYCLING-CONTRACTUAL
A8090
RECYCLING-DISPOSAL FEES
A8160
REFUSE-PERSONNEL SRVCS
A8160
REFUSE-CONTRACTUAL
A8170
ST CLEAN-PERSONNEL SRVCS
A8510
BEAUTIFICATION-PERS SRVCS PT
A8560
SHADE TREES-PERSONNEL SRVCS
A8790
NAT RESOURCES-PERS SRVCS PT
A9030
SOCIAL SECURITY-UNDISTRIBUTED
A9031
MEDICARE-UNDISTRIBUTED
A9050
UNEMPLOYMENT-UNDISTRIBUTED
A9060
INSURANCE-DENTAL INSURANCE
Total Increase
Decrease Expenses
Item
Description
A1110
JUSTICE COURT-PERS SRVCS PT
A1420
LAW-CONTRACTUAL
A1440
ENGINEER-PERSONNEL SRVCS
A1440
ENGINEER-PERSONNEL SRVCS OT
A1230
MANAGER-PERSONNEL SRVCS PT
A1640
GARAGE-PERSONNEL SRVCS
A1640
GARAGE-FUEL GAS &DIESEL
A1650
COMM-ENERGY ELECTRICITY
A1910
INSURANCE-CONTRACTUAL
A1920
MUNICIPAL DUES-CONTRACTUAL
A1990
CONTINGENCY
A3120
POLICE-PERSONNEL SRVCS
A3120
POLICE-PERS SRV OT YOUTH OUTRE
A3120
POLICE-PERS SRV OT PATROL BOAT
A3120
POLICE-PERS SRV OT BICYCLE PAT
Village Board of Trustees
July 17, 2024
A3120
POLICE-EQUIPMENT
A3120
POLICE-VEHICLES
A3120
POLICE-TRAINING
A3189
AUXILIARY POLICE-PERSONNEL SRV
A3189
AUXILARY-PERSONNEL SRVCS PT
A3310
TRAFFIC-CONTRACTUAL
A3410
FIRE-PERS SRVCS OT-PROJECTS
A3410
FIRE-HOUSE SUPPLIES
A4540
AMBULANCE-EQUIPMENT
A4540
AMBULANCE-INSPECTION
A5010
DPW ADM-PERSONNEL SRVCS
A5140
BRUSH-PERSONNEL SRVCS PT
A5142
SNOW-SUPPLIES
A5650
PARKING-CONTRACTUAL
A8560
SHADE TREES-CONTRACTUAL
A9060
INSURANCE-MEDICARE REIMBURSE
A9060
INSURANCE-HOSPITAL/MEDICAL INS
Total Decrease
Increase Revenues
Dept
Item
Description
A1000
INTEREST & EARNINGS
Total Increase
WATER FUND
Increase Expenses
Dept
Item
Description
F1320
AUDITOR-CONTRACTUAL
F1650
COMM -CONTRACTUAL
F1650
COMM-POSTAGE
F1650
COMM-TELEPHONE
F8320
SUPPLY-CONTRACTUAL
F8340
DISTRIB-PERSONNEL SRVCS
F8340
DISTRIB-PERSONNEL SRVCS OT
F8340
DISTRIB-PERSONNEL SRVCS COMP
F8340
DISTRIB-SUPPLIES
F9060
INSURANCE-HOSPITAL/MEDICAL INS
F8397
WTR CAPITAL PROJECTS-EQUIPMENT
Village Board of Trustees
July 17, 2024
Total Increase
Decrease Expenses
Dept
Item
Description
F1990
Contingency
Total Decrease
SEWER FUND
Increase Expenses
Dept
Item
Description
G1320
AUDITOR-CONTRACTUAL
G1650
CENTRAL COMM-CONTRACTUAL
G1650
ENERGY-ELECTRICITY
G1650
CENTRAL COMM-TELEPHONE
G8120
SEWER-SUPPLIES
G8997
HOME &COMM SERV-EQUIPMENT
Total Increase
Decrease Expenses
Dept
Item
Description
G1990
CONTINGENCY-CONTRACTUAL
Total Decrease
Resolution #150 of 2024
On motion of TRUSTEE SIMON, seconded by TRUSTEE MURTAUGH, the following
resolution was adopted by the Board of Trustees of the Village of Croton- on- Hudson, New
York with a 5-0 vote.
WHEREAS the Village of Croton-on-Hudson has owned a parcel located at Croton Point
Avenue, also known as Tax Map Parcel 79.17-1-5 (“Lot A”) since the 1960s, and
WHEREAS Lot A was utilized as overflow parking for the Croton-Harmon Train Station for
many years, and
Village Board of Trustees
July 17, 2024
WHEREAS since the COVID-19 pandemic reduced the demand for commuter parking, the
Village Board of Trustees has determined Lot A is not needed for municipal purposes and
issued an RFP for the development of Lot A, and
WHEREAS on April 24, 2024, the Village Board adopted Resolution 86-2024 to move
forward with WBP Development LLC (“the Applicant”) of Chappaqua, New York, as the
proposed purchaser and developer of Lot A, and
WHEREAS the Applicant has also entered into a contract for the purchase of the adjacent
parcel owned by Croton Point Realty Inc. located at 1 Croton Point Avenue and also
known as Tax Map Parcel 79.17-1-4 (“the CPR Parcel”), and
WHEREAS as the Applicant will be purchasing the CPR Parcel, the Village Board has
indicated it will also include an additional adjacent Village owned parcel currently leased
to Croton Point Realty Inc. for use in conjunction with the CPR Parcel, which additional
parcel is known as Tax Map Parcel 79.17-1-3 (“the Additional Village Parcel”) (Lot A, the
CPR Parcel and the Additional Village Parcel are collectively referred to as “the Property”),
and
WHEREAS the Property is located in the LI Zoning District and within 1500 feet of the
Croton-Harmon Train Station, allowing for a variety of light industrial and multi-family
residential use, and
WHEREAS the Village Board is in receipt of a special permit application for a multi-unit
residential building on the Property and the requisite $5,000 application fee from the
Applicant, and
WHEREAS the special permit application stipulates that the project will now consist of 46
one-bedroom and 54 two-bedroom condominiums, and
WHEREAS the Applicant has submitted Part 1 of an Environmental Assessment Form and
a Coastal Assessment Form,
NOW THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED that the Village Board hereby determines that the
Proposed Action is an unlisted action under SEQRA, and
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that the Village Board hereby declares its intent to be the
Lead Agency for SEQRA purposes in connection with the Proposed Action and authorizes
the circulation of its intent to all involved and interested agencies, and
Village Board of Trustees
July 17, 2024
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that the Village Board hereby refers the special permit
application and associated documents to the Village Planning Board in accordance with
Village law, and
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that the Village Board hereby directs the Village Clerk to
notify the Westchester County Planning Board of this application in accordance with law,
and
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that the Village Board hereby directs the Applicant to
establish an initial escrow fund of $50,000 for consultant review fees in connection with
the review of this application by the various Village Boards.
Trustee Simon stated that this action begins the process and looks forward to hearing
back from the Planning Board; the $50,000 that is being put in the Escrow Fund will allow
the Village to hire an independent consultant to look at all the impacts.
Trustee Murtaugh stated that when LOT A was an active train station parking lot there
were hundreds of cars parked there that contributed to traffic on a daily basis and he
believes we have to put some trust in those that study traffic. Trustee Murtaugh stated
that we expect occupancy at the Maple Commons development to start very soon so we
will have plenty of time to review those impacts while we review the LOT A proposal.
John Bainlardi, Vice president of WBP Development LLC advised that a lot of the
concerns that have been expressed will be specifically addressed as they go through the
review process. Mr. Bainlardi stated that they believe that this development will attract
people who currently work in Croton, those that are looking to downsize yet want to stay
in the Croton and those who have moved away and want to come back to be close to
family. Mr. Bainlardi stated that they are proposing a combination of one- and two-
bedroom apartments which do not generate many school children and to the extent that
school children are generated, those children would be across the full spectrum from
kindergarten to high school. Mr. Bainlardi explained that affordable housing is affordable
relative to the community in which you live and is based on the area’s medium incomes.
Trustee Simon stated that if this project moves forward and the applicant gets the AHOP
funding, the applicants will still have to demonstrate they have sufficient income to be
able to obtain a mortgage.
Mayor Pugh asked if they have a sense for funding at this time.
July 17, 2024
Mr. Bainlardi stated that they are optimistic, in their cover letter they alluded to two
developments and that they have already been successful in receiving the necessary
funding. Mr. Bainlardi stated that AHOP is a new program which provides for the
opportunity of home ownership and our intent is to make that a reality and emphasized
that no funds will come from the taxpayers of the Village.
To hear Mr. Bainlardi’s and the Board’s comments you may log onto the following:
https://play.champds.com/crotononhudsonny/event/968 (section 1.32.40).
7. PUBLIC COMMENTS ON NON-AGENDA ITEMS
Petra Vatne, 217 Half Moon Bay, Croton on Hudson, stated that the Board of
Trustees are here to serve the people, and implored the Board to listen to the
community.
Michael Mamone, 19 Young Avenue, stated that he does not want people
parking on his street and encouraged the board to put in a residential
parking system and also asked that that dog laws be enforced.
Lisa Stenson Desamours, 1400 Half Moon Bay Drive, Croton on Hudson,
stated that the developments proposed for LOT A and 1 Half Moon Bay Drive
will have an adverse impact on the residents of Half Moon Bay making it
difficult for residents to exit and enter and asked that the traffic consultant
install monitoring devices 24 hours a day, 7 days a week.
Marilyn Grantner, 115 Cleveland Drive, Croton on Hudson, thanked the
Trustees for putting the shuttle bus in service and suggested that a break be
built into the schedule for the bus driver and adjust the bus route so that it
stops at Senasqua on its way to Croton Landing where people are parked
since it is a long walk from Senasqua.
Gary Eisinger, 210 Cleveland Drive, Croton on Hudson, asked the Board to
wait three years before considering any zoning changes for the 1 Half Moon
Bay project until we have an assessment of the effects from our current
developments.
Susan Sjkrelja, 56 Truesdale Drive, Croton On Hudson, stated that she feels
like we do not have a voice, and while the LOT A project is not something
that can be on the ballot, she encouraged the Board to involve the public.
Michael Balter, 148 Old Post Road South, Croton on Hudson, and editor of
the Croton Chronicle stated that the ownership of the Maple Commons
Village Board of Trustees
July 17, 2024
development appears to be a dual ownership between Regan Development,
HDFC, and the Croton Housing Network and asked the Board to explain the
ownership.
Tony Granger, 217 Half Moon Bay, Croton on Hudson, stated that from 2010-
2023, 60 housing units were added to the Village, in 2024 the Village added
106 housing units and if we include the 100 units proposed for LOT A and the
280 units for the 1 Half Moon Bay property we would essentially have added
486 units, an 810% increase. Mr. Granger referred to the 2003 Master Plan
Study that recognized “the essential character of Croton as a community of
individual homeowners residing in single family dwellings on separate lots
and that the essential character should be preserved. To view the entire
document, you may log onto the following:
https://ecode360.com/CR0035/document/532987063.pdf
WRITTEN COMMENTS
E-Mail from Sarah Lawson Gruttadaro, 32 Wells Avenue, Croton on Hudson
dated July 17, 2024, states that she would like the Village to remain a small
community and asked that the Board not move forward with both the LOT A
proposal as well as the 1 Half Moon Bay proposal.
E-Mail from Jessica Dieckman, 58 Thompson Avenue, Croton on Hudson
dated July 16, 2024, states that she is against the development at 1 Half
Moon Bay and would like the Village to remain a small community.
E-Mail from Erica Corwin, 68 Young Avenue, Croton on Hudson dated July 15,
2024, states that she is concerned about the development at 1 Half Moon
Bay and asked the Board to cap the development at four stories to preserve
the riverfront.
8. APPROVAL OF MINUTES
Motion to approve the minutes as amended of the Regular Meeting held on
June 26, 2024, was made by Trustee Nicholson. The motion was seconded by
Trustee Simon and approved with a 5-0 vote.
9. REPORTS:
July 17, 2024
Trustee Nicholson thanked the Sustainability Committee for running a
successful Repair Café this past Saturday and reminded everyone that the
Shuttle Bus will be running this Friday evening for the Senasqua concert.
Trustee Simon advised that on July 3rd Congressman Mike Lawler held a
Town Hall at the Croton Municipal building, on July 4th a very successful re-
enactment was held at Van Cortlandt Manor and thanked everyone involved,
on July 10th he attended the Maple Commons walk-through, on July 23rd
Croton 100 will be hosting a Senasqua Park Plastic Clean Up Day, the Rotary
Club will be holding their annual car show September 29th.
Trustee Simon explained the history of how Croton became a Pro Housing
Community, two years ago Governor Hochul developed a Legislative package
that required mandatory metrics for municipalities to meet in terms of
housing and if a municipality did not grant what a developer wanted, then
the developer had the right to go to the State and the State could take over
the Zoning of that particular municipality, that proposal was defeated in
Albany, but the message that was sent to the Governor, that if the State
wants more housing, the way to do it, is with incentives and out of that
discussion the Pro Housing Communities Program was created. Trustee
Simon stated that this program simply recognizes communities that are
committed to incremental growth over an extended period of time, and under
the leadership of Village Manager Healy we submitted the proper forms and
received the Pro Housing Community designation. Trustee Simon stated that
this designation gets us in the HOV lane for some helpful grant programs
that deal with infrastructure programs that benefit the entire community.
Trustee Murtaugh stated that there has been a lot of fear about the rapid
growth in Croton, and reminded everyone that there was a lot of fear when
we were purchasing the train station parking lot, there were fears about the
Harmon re-zoning, and people thought we were crazy to allow the Half Moon
Bay development, yet all of these things have turned out to be positive for
the Village. Trustee Murtaugh stated that whether or not LOT A comes to
fruition, there will still be hundreds of Metro North employees leaving work
and agrees that the traffic lights need to be improved and we should pursue
this discussion with the State. Trustee Murtaugh stated that we cannot
remain static, and the Board needs to do a better job sharing as much
information as possible with the community.
July 17, 2024
Trustee Politi stated that many of the speakers began their comments telling
us how many years they have lived in Croton and believes that these same
conversations were had when they moved to Croton, and reminded everyone
that these same new residents will also feel lucky that they got to Croton
when they did, and we are better off when there are people in our
community that are different from us.
Mayor Pugh stated that he was born and raised in Croton, and during his
lifetime in the Village 800 units of housing were added and he is very glad
during those decades his family did not say no more and looks at all the
people who have come to live here and who have made tremendous
contributions to Croton. Mayor Pugh stated that the Village’s population in
1900 was approximately 1,500, we are now over 8,000, growth is part of our
story and when you talk about small town character, it is important to keep
things into perspective, the reality is that Croton is one of the most thinly
settled communities in Westchester even with all the current projects, we are
not anywhere close to the density of a lot of communities in the Hudson
Valley.
Village Manager Healy thanked the Department of Public Works for cleaning
up numerous downed trees from the recent rainstorm, and as a result of the
storm he has received requests to provide an exemption to the Leaf Blower
Ban which is permitted in serious storm events. Village Manager Healy stated
that even though the new census data indicates that the Village no longer
has census blocks to qualify for CDBG funding, we will move forward with the
hearing and complete the application process and see what happens, the
Repair Café was a great event and thanked the Conservation Advisory
Council and all the volunteers for making this happen, explained that the
traffic lights on Croton Point Avenue do not communicate with each other
because the lights at the exit ramps are owned by the State, and the lights
at LOT A and Veterans Plaza are owned by the Village and while we’ve had
numerous discussions with the State, we will continue to pursue this issue to
try to come up with a better solution. Village Manager Healy advised that he
met with representatives from the Town of Cortlandt and the County and
talked about the parking problems along Route 129, the Town is going to
petition NYS DOT to put no parking signs along their section of Route 129,
County Police Department will continue to write tickets when appropriate and
the County Parks Department is going to enhance the messaging that they
put out on their social media about the limited parking and encourage people
to park at Croton Point Park.
July 17, 2024
There being no further business to come before the Board a motion to close
the meeting and enter into an executive session to discuss matters of
personnel involving specific individuals was made by Trustee Murtaugh. The
motion was seconded by Trustee Simon and approved with a 5-0 vote. The
meeting was adjourned at 10:02pm.
Machine-extracted for search and reference — the original PDF is the authoritative version.