1-Murphy-Croton PB-118 Scenic Drive-Amended Site Plan Submission-20231031
site plan
2 pages
Meeting: portal event 897 (no meeting page on file)
Agenda item: New Business — Murphy, Andrew - 118 Scenic Drive West (67.10-2-5.2) - Amended Site Plan & Amended Tree Removal Plan
Site plan, 2 pages. Attached to agenda item: “New Business — Murphy, Andrew - 118 Scenic Drive West (67.10-2-5.2) - Amended Site Plan & Amended Tree Removal Plan”
Retrieved 2026-07-31 from the village's meeting portal.
View the original PDF ↗
Also attached to this agenda item:
3-Murphy-Trees to be Removed-20231019-Non fillable
4-Murphy-Magram-118 Scenic Drive SP 20231027 -ALL SHEETS
Extracted text
October 31, 2023
Mr. Robert Luntz, Chairman
Village of Croton-on-Hudson Planning Board
Municipal Building
1 Van Wyck Street
Croton-on-Hudson, New York 10520
Re:
Amended Minor Site Plan
118 Scenic Drive West
Dear Chairman. Luntz and Members of the Planning Board,
Enclosed please find the following materials in support of the amended minor site plan application for
118 Scenic Drive West:
1. Eight (8) copies of this cover letter.
2. Eight (8) copies of Amended Site Plan.
3. Eight (8) copies of tree photos.
4. Amended Minor Site Plan Application Fee in the amount of $275.00.
5. Two (2) copies of the Planning Board Application.
This project received Minor Site Plan approval on January 17, 2023 for the construction of a single-family
residence on an existing 25,055 square foot vacant parcel at 118 Scenic Drive West to be served by
municipal water and private sewer. The property is zoned RA-25 and is Lot 36A of the previous Murphy
/ Magram Subdivision.
The approval envisioned that there would not be any tree removal, specifically along the eastern portion
of the property facing the Scenic Ridge development. The architecture for the house was revised to be
narrower in an attempt to save several trees along the side of the new house. However, after having
the house staked out by the surveyor, we met on site with the contractor to go over the tree situation. It
was determined that seven trees should be removed and a new planting plan should be prepared.
The concern is that the tree root zones will be damaged which may kill the trees and since the trees are
very tall, the potential for trees falling is greatly increased. Also, the trees provide very little screening,
and the screening is from the tree trunks only. Please see tree photos submitted herein.
There is a total of seven trees to be removed and include 1 maple, 1 locust and 5 pine trees. We are
proposing to plant 6 white pines, 2 white spruce and 3 blue spruce in their place. These trees will
provide more screening than currently exists. See amended Site Plan.
Should you have any questions or require additional information, please contact me at the above
number. Thank you for your time and consideration with this matter.
Keith Staudohar
Project Engineer
enclosures
cc: Andrew Murphy and Jeanne Magram, Applicant/Owner via email
Murphy-Croton PB-118Scenic Drive-amended site plan submission-20231031
Machine-extracted for search and reference — the original PDF is the authoritative version.