Village Attorney Agreement - Croton on Hudson - 11-22-24 1 003
agreement
4 pages
Meeting: portal event 1001 (no meeting page on file)
Agenda item: Authorization to Execute Contracts for Professional Services
Agreement / contract, 4 pages. Attached to agenda item: “Authorization to Execute Contracts for Professional Services”
Retrieved 2026-04-15 from the village's meeting portal.
View the original PDF ↗
Also attached to this agenda item:
December 2nd Resolution 239-2024 Authorization to...
On-Call Planning and Environmental Consulting Services...
Retainer Engagement Letter
Extracted text
4867-5801-8558, v. 1
Village of Croton-On-Hudson
1 Van Wyck Street
Croton-on-Hudson, NY 10520
Village Attorney Retainer Agreement
The Village of Croton-on-Hudson (the “Village”) hereby retains the law offices
McCarthy Fingar, LLP (the “McCarthy Fingar”), 711 Westchester Avenue, Suite 405, White
Plains, NY 10604 to act in the role of Village Attorney in accordance with the following terms:
1.
Personnel
Joshua Subin shall be responsible for the scope of services provided by McCarthy Fingar
hereunder. Mr. Subin will attend all regular meetings of the Board of Trustees, and all special
meetings and work sessions on an as needed basis. In the event of his unavailability (ie. illness,
emergency, vacation and the like), we expect that Daniel Pozin will attend such meetings on
Mr. Subin’s behalf. McCarthy Fingar will provide counsel to attend Planning Board meetings
on a regular basis, and Water Control Commission and Zoning Board of Appeals meetings on
an as needed basis.
2.
General Scope of Services
The General Scope of Services provided to the Village shall cover customary and routine
municipal matters including the following: (a) attending or otherwise participating in regular
and special meetings of the Village Board and Planning Board including work sessions,
executive sessions and advice of counsel sessions; (b) attending or otherwise participating in
other meetings (e.g. with staff) on an as needed basis; (c) providing counsel to the Mayor and
Trustees, Village Manager, Village Clerk, Village Treasurer, Engineering Department,
Department of Public Works, and Police Department, and legal support on an as needed basis
to other departments and professional staff; (d) drafting legislation, resolutions and notices
when requested; (e) drafting and reviewing business documents, including but not limited to,
agreements, licenses, easements, contracts and leases; (f) assist and advise Village personnel
in matters involving response to FOIL requests and Open Meetings Law compliance, although
primary responsibility will remain with Village Personnel; (g) providing legal advice, written
opinions and memoranda as needed to assist the Village Board and/or the Village Manager,
including general advice on possible litigation prior to commencement of a proceeding or
receipt of a notice of claim; (h) upon request, providing educational-type programs to assist
with the review of land use matters; and (i) monitoring and responding to e-mail
correspondence and telephone communications between and among McCarthy Fingar, the
Village, Village officials, Village staff and persons with matters pending with the Village.
McCarthy Fingar shall be paid a General Retainer covering the General Scope of Services of
Seven Thousand ($7,000) Dollars per month through May 31, 2025, and commencing on June
1, 2025, monthly payments of Nine Thousand ($9,000) Dollars.
3.
Land Use Applications
For each land use application that may come before the Board of Trustees or the Planning
Board, McCarthy Fingar shall charge the Village (a) a blended hourly rate of $275.00 per hour
regardless of the attorney working on the matter, for the first two hours of work, and thereafter
(b) its Regular Hourly Rates on a straight hourly basis. Regular Hourly Rates range from
$300.00 to $500.00 depending on the attorney. Work on land use applications includes review
of project documents including SEQRA documents, communications with applicants, and their
attorneys and consultants as needed, and attendance at Village Board and Planning Board
meetings, as determined by the Village Manager and/or Village Engineer. This rate structure
will apply regardless of the Board having jurisdiction for approval of the application. The
Village has authority to require land use applicants to reimburse the Village’s legal fees under
Village Code Chapter 178. McCarthy Fingar shall invoice separately and the Village shall pay
directly for any charges which may become subject to billing by the Village for reimbursement
by others including from funds held by the Village in escrow pursuant to Chapter 178 of the
Village Code. It remains entirely within the purview of the Village whether it will charge
others, such as land use applicants, for the services provided to the Village by McCarthy
Fingar. Payment of such separately billed invoices by the Village shall not be contingent upon
collection by the Village under any reimbursement or escrow policy.
4.
Litigation
Litigation consists of any matter that is commenced by a formal court or arbitration paper, such
as a summons, complaint, petition for review, notice of claim, or violation, and includes (a)
defense of the Village in litigation, including small claims actions and Article 78 proceedings,
(b) litigation or other actions or proceedings brought by or on behalf of the Village, including
in rem tax foreclosure proceedings; (c) appeals, arbitrations, mediations and any other
litigation-related matters assigned by the Village Board of Trustees, including non-party
subpoenas and depositions. McCarthy Fingar will not prosecute Vehicle & Traffic offenses
or simple Village Code violations, unless specifically requested by the Village Manager. Work
4867-5801-8558, v. 1
on litigation matters will be billed at the blended rate of $275.00 per hour regardless of the
attorney working on the matter.
5.
Special Projects
Special Projects include major Village endeavors which are not typically done, such as land
acquisition, disposition, or development, and the preparation of broad-scale or complex
legislation. Work on Special Projects will be billed at the blended rate of $275.00 per hour
regardless of the attorney working on the matter. Considering that some Special Project work
may be difficult to categorize in advance, the final decision on what is or is not a special project
shall be made by the Village Manager.
6.
Outside Counsel
It is acknowledged that the Village engages separate Labor Counsel for all labor relations and
employment matters and General Liability Counsel (as may be assigned under insurance
policies) for Constitutional or other Federal claims, property damage and personal injury
matters, and that McCarthy Fingar shall not be responsible for same, although McCarthy
Fingar shall communicate and coordinate efforts with such separate counsels as may be
necessary. In addition, with respect to Certiorari Proceedings, the Village of Croton-on-
Hudson Assessor will be primarily responsible for negotiating resolutions for such matters and
McCarthy Fingar will assist in negotiations where necessary and review stipulations of
settlement.
7.
Disbursements:
The Village will be responsible to McCarthy Fingar for any disbursements and expenses as
may be included on a regular invoice or submitted separately. Such disbursements and
expenses include filing fees, expert fees, electronic research charges and messenger charges,
and could also include reports prepared by outside experts (such as appraisers etc.), prepared at
the direction of counsel, although such expenditures must have prior Village approval. We do not,
however, seek reimbursement for mileage or travel time, ordinary postage expenses or in-house
reproduction.
8.
Billings:
McCarthy Fingar will bill for work performed each month, provide separate details invoices of
work performed on each matter including reasonable and necessary disbursements, and include
the Village’s standard voucher for payment. Our billing records are maintained at intervals of one-
tenth (1/10th) of an hour.
9.
Term:
McCarthy Fingar shall serve at the pleasure of the Village Board of Trustees in accordance
with terms of this Agreement. Terms may be amended upon agreement of the parties and shall
be set forth in a subsequent written agreement. The Village Board of Trustees may conduct
an annual review of compensation, goal-setting and evaluation of performance.
10.
Records:
McCarthy Fingar shall maintain legal records and files on any matter in which they have
rendered services to the Village. All such records compiled by McCarthy Fingar pursuant to
this Agreement shall revert to the Village upon termination of the Agreement.
11.
Other Clients:
During the term of this Agreement, McCarthy Fingar shall not represent any other client before
any department, board or commission of the Village.
12.
Village Rights:
McCarthy Fingar is obligated to inform you that the Village has a right to arbitration of any
fee dispute under Part 137 of Rules of the Chief Administrator of the Courts.
Dated: December ___, 2024
Village of Croton-on-Hudson
McCarthy Fingar, LLP
By: _____________________
By: _____________________
Name: Bryan T. Healy
Name: Daniel Pozin
Title: Village Manager
Title: Co-Administrative Partner
Machine-extracted for search and reference — the original PDF is the authoritative version.