Zoning Board of Appeals Meeting
Thank you, Debbie. good evening, everyone. Welcome to the November seventeenth, twenty twenty six meeting of the village of Croton on Hudson. Zoning Board of Appeals. Where we start, there's two exits in case of emergency. One in the back, one in the front. And we have one item tonight on the agenda. And I assume you're Mr. Green? Yes. And you've already taken the seat of honor? No. Dennis Green of 48 Big Win. Yes. Okay, so why don't you Discuss with us what you're asking for.
Yeah sure. So I have two sheds on my property. They're larger than 20 by 20. And I was going through a records request for my property, and I found a note in my file from I think 2021 that I have unpermitted sheds. so I wanted to Comply and seek a permit. And because the sheds are within five feet of the property line, I'm here for zoning consider variance consideration, please. so everything is documented there in the pack. There are several pictures, there's a fresh survey, and happy to discuss that with you.
And are they the same distance away or is it And where are they in relation to each other? Because I I can't really tell. I don't know if you guys can can tell. I see Yeah
Looks like the the the big one is facing the house from the streets on the left side right behind the fence.
Right. And then what is Okay, so the variance doesn't really show on the survey. You're going on this your Right? Does it show? Yeah, on the
It does. It should be marked on the survey and it's minimal. So it's within a foot, especially one of the sheds. even though there's greater distance
Shown by the measurement, that's what the what this how the survey is marked. So it's very c it is close to the property line. And that neighbor has submitted a letter in approval of any variants.
Yeah so I I forget exactly I'm gonna say within five years and it was probably 2021 and the smaller one in the front 2023. They're vinyl plastic sheds, these are things you can get off Amazon.
The the the big one not no, I would say no. It can be easily deconstructed, but it's not movable.
Isn't there a minimum size under which you don't need to comply with the setback?
So I'm curious whether the little one is larger than that. Sorry to interrupt you. Sorry.
People put small garbage sheds like right next to the house, right next to the fence. Right. Right.
Right, and and just by eyeball looking at it by scale. Looks like at least six foot wide and better than four foot deep, so right there. You say twenty feet is the Is the maximum of
Square footage. Okay. And there's no height like qualification for for what a shed is.
So the only variance is the side yard, not a total side yard that's crossed out on the application. Correct.
Two side yard variants. The larger shed is right up on the property line. It says corner shed online. And the smaller
Of the one of the statements is this it wouldn't be practical for you to move them elsewhere in the property, is that way you located them?
Yes. There's it would be, you know, it might be within the variance tolerance somewhere else, but it'll be unsightly. They they can't be in the front yard, in the back, there's not much room far from the variance. So yeah, those are the only areas and they seem tucked away and appropriate for for those kinds of sheds. So that's why I chose that area. Okay.
And I guess the obvious question was talking about before, could the other one be rotated? So it's 90 degrees, so it's farther away.
So the what I thought would be an issue is that there's electrical and plumbing in that area. So I tried by having the shed
Face that way the long way. It's away from the gas line. It's farther away from the gas line.
You're saying the gas line is next to the house. Yes. And so you kind of you located the shed. I I can
Yeah, and there's also a water spigot there, so that it would the turning it rotates
And the the last two photographs show dimensions. What are they? One's the the front shed and one's the back shed.
Yeah, so that's the actual distance from the fence. It's the neighbor's fence. And so I thought I would measure that as well for you. So you could see that distance. It's a it's slightly deviant from the prop how the surveyor defined
The property line. Right. Is that your fence or your neighbor's? It's hers. It's yours? It's hers. It's hers. Okay.
Right. Which is I guess this one, right? Is this it? Second photo is the closer one. This one is
I'd have to come up. Which I can you want me to come up? Yeah, sure.
It's the bigger ship.
You can see that it was papers or something. Other questions for the applicant? No. I don't know. I don't have any more. Okay, thank you very much. We'll open the public hearing. It doesn't look like anyone's here. Okay, I guess we'll close the public hearing. Okay. discussion with the board.
I guess I'll start. My initial thoughts are I don't think that this would be approved. I think that this would very likely
Yes. because it's so close to the property line. But I'm kind of on the fence. Ha ha. I don't don't don't mean to be funny. I'm on the fence because you know we have the neighbors in agreement with this. the picture that I see from the from the street. the you know it's it certainly looks you know kind of integral to that fence line and you know it doesn't doesn't immediately strike me as a visual problem and in fact it it I think I don't I think it it doesn't create an undesirable change in the neighborhood and it probably and it doesn't have an imp impact on the Environmental conditions and the neighbors approved it. So I'm kind of on the fence. I don't I just don't think it would be approved in the in in the first instance.
I would agree with that. I'm also just wondering with the movable shed is how fully it is for us because that can Like that's not you can just pick that up and move it. Not a permanent structure. So if someone put
That you would. I just feel like giving a permanent approval to put a like the kind of plastic trunk that you can get at a target. would be surprised to me on that one. The other the other shed is much more, you know, I I I understand that it's got a havers and it's fully you know it's a it's a shed. so I think we should you know definitely think about something that's within our
Get that we wouldn't normally approve one with right up on the lot line. but the movable shed I I just We say sure you can have a moveable shed there. I feel like that's not something we normally statue.
This is something that we've seen before quite a bit, because it seems like that's when people come to us is when they want to legalize something that they built without a permit.
Yeah, I mean I look at it two things. One one that movable shed. I'm not sure why that can't be moved. And number two, the other shed.
I agree with you guys, Doug. But I would think if we gave a variance, I would like
It's ever removed, it wouldn't have to come back. To reconstruct it'd have to come back for for bearance. Yes. We can do that. You know, because people change, you move, your neighbors move, you get a neighbor that's you know and
It you know It's not something that is great. But I mean that's the way that's the only way I I think I would be able to support branding experience. And I don't know what to do about the front shed
I would say in terms of, you know, putting the shed in the rear, this lot does have a really you can see in one of the pictures a really steep backyard. like past that retaining wall line. So it is not as generous as it looks on the survey in terms of actually locating a shed and still having usable space for for recreation. Yeah,
No you know that's a a good point. That's a a mitigating circumstance and also I think a mitigating circumstance is is is is the width of the lot. It's a very narrow lot. And you're limited to where you could put a shed. Right, because it can't go any closer to the street than the house. That would
I don't even know if on the other side, yeah, I guess it would be pretty close on the other side. And the reason you don't want it on the other side?
I don't I think that's it would be worse. I don't see how that could fit. And that that would be in front of the fence parallel to the street, so then that larger shed would be very visible to passerby. If I if I understand you correctly.
Yeah. Yeah. Like putting the movable shed on the twelve foot side. And rotating it maybe ninety degrees against the wall.
It just seemed that this was was better because it's more like a nook. that that fence that it's up against,
That's new. She put that in in the past year or so. So initially it was more open in that area.
What does it what does it say on the application under required setbacks? There's really fine print. I'm usually pretty good at reading a little stuff, but I'm
Okay. Thank you. So are you talking about the front yard? Yeah. It says not ex
I was just wondering what the rule was for a front yard shed. And if it's cl it's not closer to the to the street from then in front of the house and I guess it doesn't apply.
Not exposed house from perimeter. Not exposed house front perimeter. Okay. But it's we it's it's no variance for for that. Okay. Thank you. Okay, I don't know what you guys want to do. Does someone someone want to minute make a motion? We don't have some more discussion.
I have a question about to dig a little bit further into Doug's comment about we've seen a lot of these curing applications before. is this something that the board you know has Yeah in terms of it are a precedent is have we generally been favored providing variances on existing ships. Yeah I mean generally or is it mixed or
I think they would generally improve them but typically it was done by someone else. L long ago.
And the context and what the neighbors think. And and the lot. I mean there's a lot of factors that go in you know. And also the age. I mean this is the the the the the issue with this one is it's it's Very self-created. Yeah, it's very self-created and and it's fairly new. And I you know, and I I I think that's that's that's more the issue, I think. If this was fifty years old like some of the other ones we had that
I don't know.
Like I said, I'm on the fence. I I think what would what puts me over toward ranting the variants is that it it just I mean after
A site visit, just looking at the pictures, it looks you know it it it looks like it fits within the general design, even though it doesn't comply with the setback. I mean if you look at it from the street, you know, you see this the peak of the shed and it kind of looks integrated with the whole fence system. So I d I don't know putting aside the the fact that the two neighbors on each side approve it. I also think take into account the general people in the neighborhood driving by and you know they are they gonna look at something and say, Who approve that? And I don't think that this falls into that category. I think it looks appropriate. so that kind of even though I'm on the fence I am kind of leaning toward Approval. Possibly with restriction you mentioned.
I think between the the steep backyard and the approval from the neighbor and the fence already providing that like visual blockage, the the more permanent vinyl shed. approving that particular shed. I understand the the reasoning. The movable shed, I still feel weird approving a shed that can easily removy move in that location if you know, if the house goes to someone else saying, Oh, you know, you can have a sh a shed in front of the fence facing the street. feels a little strange because if it was a if it was more of a shed. If it had if it looked like the the vinyl shed and it was facing the street we would probably have a much more negative Yes. reaction towards it. Yes.
Yes. So could so given Ethan's concerns, could we put a stipulation on variants that it no taller than sorry if yeah.
Or that it can't be. Well we can't we can't replace it. Can't replace it with it with with anything else.
We can do. I agree with you that that I think when you look at this photo, someone driving by, they're not gonna even notice it. Just that it doesn't comply with with the letter of code, but as I said, you talk about the steep slope in the back and also you know the the With a lot, I I would think that this would be you'd rather have it on this side than the other side. But anyway. So I'm I'm with with the conditions we talked about, I think I'm okay. Okay, does someone want to make a motion? I can remember the whole thing. Okay. Stephanie will help us. Okay. Okay. Motion to allow for two existing structures less than five feet from property line. With with proposed setbacks a five foot variance and a 4.62 variance. With the stipulation that these sheds This is only for these specific sheds, any new sheds, any replacement sheds. Would have to come back
That work stephanie a second all in favor aye aye motions carried okay thank you okay thank you appreciate it yeah no things thanks for doing this a lot of people don't
It you know if you ever go to sell your house, that's when it starts to matter to the
We have a lot of those. Okay. okay, so it's through the five factors. Number one, no no undersirable change in the character of the neighborhood, nor detriment to nearby properties will be reduced by the granting of the variants.
I agree. The benefits by the applicant can cannot be achieved by method other than the requested variants.
The proposed variance will will not have an adverse effect or impact on the physical or environmental conditions in the neighborhood or district. They will not.
I agree. I agree. I agree. I agree. You know, looking at the the total of it. I'm not happy with this, but Yeah,
Yeah. yeah, and people will sometimes kind of vaguely know that there might be some rules and say yeah, just gonna build it and see what happens. Which is unfortunate. It's unfortunate something that the village We need to think about it.
Know it's like one one thing we have to think about is when when grant variants like this, what happens when other people hear about it and decide they want to. So every every
I think because of I think I I disagree with I think because of the yard because of where we're going to be able to
Like a garbage. I would have thought that a shed would have to be something that, you know,
Even if you even if it's just doors that you can open that are your your head height, you know not like access by lifting up the top. Yeah,
There's so many garbage sheds in the village. I think from I think that looks like a I've seen that model somewhere. I think it looks like a bicycle shed. You slide back the top. And you can put a bike in there.
Maybe. But yeah, it's the similar size of a garbage shed or a garden tool shed. Lawnmower shed, that kind of thing.
Anyway, last thing we have to do is the minutes from the last meeting. Bill was here, Doug was here, and I was here. So I read through them. That was the legalization of or not legalization. approval the variance for the 98 Hastings