croton.news
Croton-on-Hudson, NY · Sunday, November 22, 2026· Nov 22, 2026 Independent, AI-assisted local reporting from public records Source-linked·Corrections welcomed
Full Transcript

Work Session

Nov 18, 2026 — 13,073 words
· Automated meeting transcript · Watch Video ↗
Automatically transcribed from the meeting video and formatted for reading. Speaker names are identified where possible; "(sp)" marks a spelling not yet verified against official records. Click any timestamp to link to that moment.
Speaker 0 0:07 🎥

All right. Good evening and welcome to the November 18 work session of the Cortlandt and Hudson Board of Trustees. I'm Mayor Brian Pugh, and we will be taking on our first agenda item of the evening, discussions of a proposed amendment to chapter two zero six regarding telecommunications towers.

Speaker 1 0:23 🎥

Manager, do want give some background on Sure. Thank you, mayor. So at our... I think it was our last work session. We had the Cohen Law Group, which was our special counsel, present the local law to amend chapter two zero six of telecommunication towers in the village code. This was last... This law was last updated about thirty years ago, and there's been some significant changes in technology since that time as everyone's probably aware. And so we went through the law, members of the board asked questions, and we wanted to bring this back for a further discussion. You know, there are a couple of spots in the law that require some board input specifically about, you know, potential areas that you would want to allow towers to be sited. And then also, we have the design guidelines for the small cell technology, which is part of the backup here. And then as part of the regular agenda tonight, you're gonna be referring those to the VEB for their review.

Speaker 0 1:41 🎥

Excellent. Yep. And I think to provide some useful context in... On this issue is just, you the legislative history if you will is... Would you be able to go into that actually, manager, discuss the study, discuss the test? Oh, sure. Yeah.

Speaker 1 1:56 🎥

Yep. We can go back go back a little further in time. So, you know, a couple of years ago, I think it was 2023. Yep. The village board at the time constituted a telecommunications task force, and we retained the services of a consultant called Televate. And they came... Televate came to the village and did a drive through basically of all the different streets to create a service reliability map that showed where service was good, service was fair, service was poor, and they did that for all the major carriers. They did... They had one map for Verizon, one map for AT and T, one map for T Mobile. And using that information, they were able to speak to the existing carriers and see if there would be any interest in improving service in the village. And, unfortunately, we didn't really get a a super great response to that. And then the next step in that process was to do a public study... A public survey, sorry. And we put together a a survey document that was put out through the website and we got a good number of responses. I don't remember what the exact number was, but it was somewhere around four or 500. Pretty high for us. Yeah. It was pretty it was pretty high for us electronic survey. And, you know, there were a lot of passionate answers in there about how, you know, people, especially now that people work from home and, you know, people have cut their landlines, you know, how important self-service was to people. And so... All... And all of this information is available on our website for anyone that wants to that wants to look at it. And then thirdly, one of the... One of their tasks was to assist

with the drafting of a new law. And so they, you know, they are not lawyers. They did not draft the law, but they identified things that they thought we should, you know, look for in any in any changes based on what new federal guidance has come out. So, you know, so the telecommunications task force works, you know, with Televate and myself and trustee Simon throughout this process. And then once Televate's contract was up, the telecommunications task force was sunset, and we worked with... You you know, first, we worked with our existing law firm to... Our law firm, not attorney. Thank you. And...

Speaker 2 4:51 🎥

I think it's the former firm too. Right? Well, we

Speaker 1 4:54 🎥

we originally originally worked with our former law firm to draft a local law. Right. And then we worked with our current law firm to draft a second local law. And then we worked with special counsel to draft the third version of the law, which is what you have in front of you. So I think that covers the history. Yeah.

Speaker 0 5:19 🎥

And we have the chief here today to discuss just basically the the relevance, you know, of improving telecommunications, not just as a matter of, convenience, but one of public safety. Chief, would you like to speak to that briefly? I would. Thank you.

Speaker 3 5:37 🎥

So, I mean, as, you know, manager Healy said, the the service throughout the village is very spotty. I, myself, as you mentioned, still need to keep a landline at my house because cell service does not work there. It's very spotty. My family has, two different carriers, and neither one of them work great. So there are a lot of parks, Silver Lake one, very busy in the summer where there's no cell service down there. I mean, I think for public safety, it's very important for us to try and, rectify the situation and get a little better service throughout the community. I'm not advertising for any service, but in my opinion, Verizon probably works about the best here, right at the moment. You know, maybe when everything goes online here, I think it has already. Maybe it'll pick up a little bit for other carriers, but the service throughout the village is very poor. I think for public safety, it is extremely important for us to try and do something. And that includes with maybe the tower up on Hessian Hills because that's where our radio system goes through, and that's very spotty for the PD. You you all know that because I requested, funding to get a new radio system, which hopefully will increase that. It's gonna be digital. So I am... I'm confident that that's gonna increase it. But, you know, if we can get a different tower or somewhere within the village, that may also help us with the communications for public safety. So I think it's very important for us to try and move forward on something.

You know, I mean, do you have any questions of me about anything that you're interested in? Or... Chief,

Speaker 0 7:21 🎥

when you talk about this as a matter of public safety, do you not mean primarily as people, residents, members of the public calling for help, as a matter of interagency communication or intraagency

Speaker 3 7:33 🎥

communication? It's it's pretty much a lot of everything. I mean, as I mentioned, like Silver Lake, if there's an incident down there, I do believe the village keeps a landline down there, but it's also takes a little while for, you know, people to realize what's going on and, call us. You know, when it comes to a life threatening situation, you know, every minute makes a difference a lot of times. I mean, mean, we've all seen in the past year... I think it's two years now where where, you know, we help the person down at Croton Landing who had a a heart issue. You know? We we were able to get there quick... Quickly enough and save that man. So it's very important for public safety that we can communicate throughout the village, Whether it be landline, cell phone, radio, it's just extremely important. You know, and a lot of our... We have a big commuter station here. We got a lot of outside people that drive through. You know, public safety is is a major issue when it comes to cell towers and communication.

Speaker 4 8:30 🎥

Chief, could you, just describe what your existing tower in the Hessian Hills area is doing, what service that that provides? The one up at Hessian Hills? Yep. That's the fire tower for,

Speaker 3 8:42 🎥

that's a radio tower for both, the fire department and the and the police department. As I said, you know, we have a pretty spotty service within the village, which, obviously I said, you know, I've complained about it, and we're we're trying to improve on it. But the height of the cell tower there, if it were able to go up a little bit, may also help with that communication system. Right. I know a couple years ago, you did a balloon test or something up there. So I think it's able to go in up there a little higher if need be.

Speaker 4 9:18 🎥

So the the new radio system will will interact with, hopefully, possibly an improved

Speaker 3 9:24 🎥

Well, the new radio system is gonna be a digital system. So, basically, what we have here in the village is we have different sites. We we have the main tower up at Hessian Hills. We have a, repeater or similar device up at Skyview. We also just put one down by the, Wellfields because the service out there was so bad. Basically, the system we have, there are antennas that point to each other. And, you know, whichever one picks up the strongest signal sends it out on a different frequency, and then that radio is transmitted. So, you know, height is important, You know, being able to, you know, see the sig... You know, direct the signals without tree foliage and everything else also will help. I'm told. I'm no radio person. Okay. Yeah. For sure. Okay? So...

Speaker 4 10:22 🎥

You know, helpful. Thanks.

Speaker 5 10:24 🎥

I have a question. Yes, sir. I'm not sure exactly how your systems work, but in the interim, for you... For the police department's connectivity to be improved, is there any possibility of adding like a satellite system to each police car?

Speaker 3 10:42 🎥

There are sat... There are companies that make satellites for cars to improve like... I mean, I honestly have never looked into that. I don't know if it would help. I... I'm sure it probably would, but I don't know the cost of that, and I don't know how we'd how we'd even do that. Matt, without endorsing a specific brand name, are you talking about... No. No. But I'm gonna use one. I... There's only one. Yeah. Because it's Starlink. Yeah. Okay.

Speaker 0 11:05 🎥

That's fine.

Speaker 5 11:08 🎥

They work... And they work really well. I don't have it, but At the moment. I know a lot of contractors have them on their cars, and they can work on their computers. Yeah. I'm just saying, like, in terms of between now and when the next time we boost connectivity. Mean, we we we do have,

Speaker 3 11:26 🎥

I don't know if they call them air cards now or or... I think they're air cards in most of the cars so that they can work on their computers in the cars and Oh, yeah. And do things. But we have that... No. But that service is also spotty because it depends what carrier you have and where they are. So this this might be something that might help in the interim.

Speaker 5 11:45 🎥

Maybe try it out. You know? Listen.

Speaker 3 11:47 🎥

We'll we'll take any suggestion to try and help us out.

Speaker 6 11:55 🎥

Chief, the radio towers that you mentioned, those are not... They're not wireless towers. They're radio towers. Right? Or... Well, everything is wired into a radio system that is dispersed through the antennas.

Speaker 3 12:08 🎥

So, so they are wireless. You know, the the frequencies are wireless once they go out.

Speaker 6 12:14 🎥

Okay? But in order to improve the service, you think adding... Would we need to add another wireless tower to, you know, what... Well, I I think

Speaker 0 12:28 🎥

what we're talking about tonight... Yeah. I mean, yes. Is the idea that presumably a tower somewhere will improve service. I think that that the Televate... I mean, they... That's what they say. Yes.... That... Televate did come to that conclusion. I don't think that we need to ask the chief the technical specifics, but Mhmm. You know, what we're doing here this evening is paving the way for moving forward with the search for a new tower. I mean, the consensus, I think, of the task force was we should update our law, but that doesn't build the tower. It just regulates how towers might be built. And in fact, it's important to emphasize right now that there are a lot of challenges with the existing code that the attorney can go into. But, you know, in some ways, you know, it's not per se a barrier to new private applications. Correct. So... Mhmm. But nonetheless, I think it's important that we put... Resolve the law and then move forward with request for proposals. Mhmm. Any other questions for the chief? No. Thank you, chief. Alright. You're welcome. Thank you so much. Thank you. Bye. Alright.

Speaker 3 13:32 🎥

I do have another meeting to go to, so I'm going to leave. Thank you very much. Have a nice evening. Manager, can you share the, information

Speaker 6 13:40 🎥

about the locations that... The, you know, the the priority locations that have the least amount or no service in the village? What what zones... Are they by zone? Or,

Speaker 4 13:54 🎥

you know trying to I'm trying to remember. The study? Yeah. I'd have to I'd have to go back and look at it. And just, you know, one clarification on that. You know, one of the benefits of of of the Televate work was that they they helped us understand that the weak spots are actually gonna be dependent on carrier. So there are some weak spots for AT and T, some weak spots for T Mobile, and some weak spots for Verizon, and and not all of the weak spots Line up. Line up. So it's... I mean, I do... I I... This

Speaker 1 14:27 🎥

area, Grand Street near, like, the Grand Street Firehouse. Right? I think that's an area that has some limited service depending on your carrier. Going out towards the dam is is bad for for people. There's a stretch of Route 9 that's basically, like, near where Govea is if you were, like, looking to your looking to your east where everybody's calls get dropped. I don't think it matters which carrier you have. Mhmm. So it it... There's a there's a lot of different areas in the village. But I can I can go back and and share the maps or, you know, look at the maps and and let everyone know specifically what the areas are? Yeah. The maps showed...

Speaker 2 15:10 🎥

There were maps... A map for each carrier.

Speaker 4 15:13 🎥

Yep. So there was no map that combined them all to... We need one that combines them all. Oh, alright. Yeah. But we can... Mean, we... That's something that we can do. Yeah. Yeah. You've got the two You have the data. You've got the existing tower at the train station, and you've you've got, you know, the the soon to be finished tower on this roof. And then presumably, a new tower would have all three carriers there. And so hopefully, three working together fills fills the gap Mhmm. That comes close to it, theoretically.

Speaker 7 15:44 🎥

As the person who just arrived late to this, but also has... You this work has been going on for a long time, but this is really only, I think, in the... You'll correct me if I'm wrong. The second time in the last two years this has been on a work session. Have we have we talked about it? We haven't talked about it a lot. So I just feel like this is a tremendous amount for us to get our arms around, in terms of like where the maps are, where the coverage gaps are, what was found in the past. I think that every time this comes up, like this could be a whole work session in itself. Is, you know...

Speaker 0 16:22 🎥

For for sure. But, you know, what I am... Would say is that's... Those kind of... Call them logistical aspects of it, I think are most relevant for the RFP.

Speaker 7 16:32 🎥

Right. I'm just saying this is a this is a huge topic Yeah. And I think that there are some pretty... I at least have some pretty elementary questions that may be frustrating to hear, but in general, as we move forward with it, it's a huge topic. And as we get closer to figuring out where things are gonna go, there will be... There are... We know there are big opinions in the community about what that Yeah. What the answers to those are gonna be.

Speaker 1 17:02 🎥

Just to keep in mind, right, they're... It's... They're connected, but they're also separate. Right? Because you're adopting a law that would allow zoning. Right? But then there's also, as the mayor was saying, the potential to do an RFP for village property, right, which would not be

Speaker 6 17:21 🎥

regulated by the...... Subject to the law.

Speaker 1 17:24 🎥

Right? Is what... Well, the law the law is drafted, but not subject

Speaker 0 17:28 🎥

the village Well... Property. What I would... What I think you would say is the village is... Can develop cell towers on its own sites. Yeah. Right. I'd like to talk about the law when we're done with the zoning because I do have a question about that. I think we should go to the law. I don't know if the attorney or the manager wanna present it briefly and then... What exactly are we what exactly are we presenting? Because we did this already. Fair enough. Let's... Yeah. I mean, with that, the preliminaries out of the way, perhaps, then we get to the outstanding policy issue, which... Oh. So what are what are the questions for members of the board? I think... So... I I can't... I I... It's a 27 page law. Yeah. I... We only... And we only have... I had... I I had these questions when we met. Yeah. Because this was sent out and I read it again,

Speaker 6 18:13 🎥

I didn't see anything addressed. So I just... I don't I don't think we fully discussed it or I didn't understand what the reasoning was behind it. Okay. So...... The law? The law. Okay. So this... I can give you a broad overview of that. Given the age... Not that. No. No. It's a specific provisions in the law. Thank you. But I understand given the age why we're doing this. That was really clear. There's been a tremendous amount of FCC regulations

Speaker 2 18:40 🎥

since you... Your laws took care.... Understand

Speaker 6 18:43 🎥

that. So this is related to, there are broad exemptions that states the village properties are not subject to the same restrictions as privately owned properties. Does this mean that village owned property is exempt from the 500 foot residential setback, height restrictions and other protections? And I just want to understand why we would provide fewer protections

Speaker 0 19:12 🎥

to residents living adjacent to the village owned parcels. You know, what is the thinking behind that? Sure. Think that if you had that policy in place, we'd have to knock down the tower on our building and destroy coverage in the village. I mean, I'm being a little facetious here, but the point is that the village... You know, for the village owned parcels, right, as the special counsel explained in our last workshop session on us, there's kind of like the general regulatory authority to... For zoning, and then there's... Which is what we're applying to the private parcels. And then for the public parcels, it's our proprietary right. So we have the opportunity to manage the whole thing soup to nuts in the public interest. And if the board doesn't think a particular proposal makes sense, we have an absolute right to say no. It's totally discretionary. Whereas on the private parcel, you know, if something's zoning compliant, they have the right to proceed, you know, provided that they check all the boxes.

Speaker 6 20:12 🎥

And how... So, again, so it comes... The parcel being... The

Speaker 1 20:19 🎥

lease the lease would come to you first before it it went anywhere else.

Speaker 6 20:24 🎥

Before you send out an RFP?

Speaker 1 20:27 🎥

No. No. No. I mean, obviously I know. Somebody has... They have

Speaker 2 20:31 🎥

to they have to say that RFP to to gauge the interest in the various In response. Carrier companies or or Right. Tower companies. You have to gauge their interest in whether they would be interested any of... In any of your public properties. In other words, does it fill a gap in coverage? Does it increase the likelihood that it won't drop from volume calls? They would have to do business analysis first and then they would have to come here, and you'd have a discussion about all the responses and make a determination in terms of what's in the best public interest in the health and safety. As your chief had indicated tonight there is health and safety concerns with the gaps in coverage that you experience here. So in the interest of public health and safety, the village could could certainly act in the... What... What's best in the public interest.

Speaker 6 21:34 🎥

And there would be a public hearing for...

Speaker 1 21:37 🎥

Not for not for Elise, but, I mean, all your meetings allow public comment. So people... It would be on the agenda, and people would be able to comment. But a public hearing, right, is a specific thing under the law. And and whoever

Speaker 2 21:52 🎥

was accepted as a partner in this effort to close these gaps and to help the public health and safety would have to go through the process of the general approvals and it wouldn't be then they just walk away and build it. I mean... I think it would be helpful because

Speaker 6 22:12 🎥

not many people attend these meetings or listen, but they read the contracts. And so residents will just notice that we have, you know, no restrictions to the village, you know, municipal, but residents do. So I I think it would be helpful to put in somewhere in the contract. I don't know if it's up in the in the intent section or in the right section, but just to say that for village owned property, the process is this, that, you know, that it would come before the board of trustees for discussion and approval, you know, or or not. I think it I think it would be helpful just to to include that. You don't agree?

Speaker 1 23:12 🎥

I I just don't know where exactly we would put it, but I'll have to talk... I'll talk to the attorney and see where it could go. Yeah.

Speaker 5 23:20 🎥

I have a question about that too, the 500 foot rule. Yeah. Is that because of, like... I think I think someone had already answered this. And that's for residence. Is that... So does is that... Does that have something to do with if it were to fall, or is that just more of a buffer

Speaker 1 23:35 🎥

in terms of, like I think it was I think it was a buffer. I think the fall zone is separate. Okay. Yeah. I think I think the towers... Like, prior years ago, I think towers were designed that they would fall like a tree, so they needed a wider. And now they're designed to collapse onto themselves, so they need a smaller

Speaker 4 23:57 🎥

fall zone. We actually... And and I think probably the earliest version of our legislation three years ago, we actually had a fall zone. Yeah. And and I think we've learned since that it's more appropriate to do it this way. Yep.

Speaker 2 24:11 🎥

And and the the the buffer to residential zoning is really to to address potential impacts that are not related to fall. You know, the... It would... You know, there's an enclosure. There's... You know, so you'd have screening. You'd you'd have all of those things in place, but the distance is is a way to mitigate potential impacts to nearby

Speaker 4 24:41 🎥

residential zones. You know, and, you know, just as a way of illustrating it, 500 feet is 1.33 of a football field. One... So it's one and one third of football fields, so it's a big distance.

Speaker 5 24:58 🎥

One one other question. What did... I'm not sure if anyone can answer this. When a tower goes up, does it just affect the neighborhood around it, or does it improve everything in one connected

Speaker 2 25:12 🎥

sphere? Well, it's line of sight, so they would have to prove that a tower in this location is to the most advantage and the most beneficial in terms of, closing a gap in coverage or increasing the increasing the drop,

Speaker 4 25:31 🎥

you know. Isn't there like a no no better alternative standard?

Speaker 2 25:35 🎥

Sure. I mean, yeah, it would be certainly reviewed carefully and... Yeah. Are you... You couldn't... It it wouldn't... It would be imprudent for a tower company to come in to duplicate coverage. So really the interest... You're gauging interest in terms of, whether they would come in and they could find an appropriate... Maybe there are no public properties that would fill a gap. So a tower company wouldn't put a tower up unless they had commitments from at least three or maybe four, all four of the carriers. Yeah. Like,

Speaker 1 26:16 🎥

to that end, there's a tower on the Dane... On the former Danish home, right, that does provide some coverage to the village, but it's only... It only has Verizon. Or at least at the time, it only had Verizon on it. I'm not sure if they've added since since we did the study. So that's in... Our building is an example too. Right? We only had T Mobile for many, many years. And then around 2020, we got Verizon on this building. And now 2026, we're hopefully getting AT and T powered up. So it does... Eventually, you can get all the carriers, but it takes it takes some persuasion and, you know, a long a long time to do that.

Speaker 6 26:57 🎥

So the... Okay. The other question I have is that waivers and exceptions

Speaker 2 27:07 🎥

Where are you?

Speaker 6 27:13 🎥

Right now are just made in writing to the village engineer and subject to the village engineer's discretion. So if a What section, please? So it's section two zero six-four.

Speaker 0 27:30 🎥

Looks like it's on page 10 in the PDF. Thank you. Okay. Number

Speaker 6 27:39 🎥

three. Yeah. Page 10. That's right, mayor. Number three. So a modification to an existing WCF shall be required to obtain a permit from the village engineer. But if you go to page 14, waivers... Request for waivers from any requirement shall be made in writing to the village engineer, and the engineer may grant or deny a request for a waiver.

Speaker 2 28:20 🎥

So

Speaker 6 28:23 🎥

the concern that I have or the the question is, what, you know, what role does the public play? I... You know, there there are a lot of... I think this this law is generally, like, very well written, and it puts a lot of good constraints and, you know, on the on the telco. But I think if if we're letting the engineer make... Just agree to exceptions to... I don't know how many of these rules, you know. Sure.

Speaker 0 29:02 🎥

Manager, if I'm reading this correctly, think this is kind of a procedural question rather than a substantive waiver. It's about the Administrative. The engineer making a determination of the completeness of the application. Is that correct, attorney? It does look like that. It's... They're they're talking about,

Speaker 2 29:21 🎥

during the submission process and the timing and the... So, specifically, if you're doing a, for example, a like kind exchange, which a lot of the carriers are doing these days as the technology goes in a positive direction. They're taking these old ugly, and they're make... You know, they're getting smaller and smaller, so they're doing like kind. So the submission in that case would not necessarily have to go through all of this in terms of the completeness of the application. A like kind would be, a very much simple process, and that is in the discretion as long as he makes that finding and that they're approved on a case by case basis and narrowly tailored to minimize deviation. So it is discretionary, and, it's it's after careful consideration and to...

Speaker 6 30:20 🎥

You see the standard in there. So I guess what I'm concerned about is we go through the effort to, you know, a lot of effort to write a great law, to discuss a law, and then to give an engineer the discretionary power to waive and have exceptions, that we are not gonna be aware of at all, concerns me. Well, I mean, you do that... And I don't see that written in here as, you know, it... As an application.

Speaker 1 30:52 🎥

So... It says waivers from any requirement of this section. So it's talking about things like insurance and having a performance bond and timing of your application. And...

Speaker 6 31:05 🎥

Why would we want the engineer to waive those things and not be aware of those things?...

Speaker 2 31:11 🎥

The attorney said. If if it were a mere amendment, I... It doesn't appear that it would meet the requirements if it were a wholesale brand new installation. You know what I mean? Like, in certain circumstances when an application comes in, it's for something much simpler than starting from scratch. If if, for example

Speaker 1 31:33 🎥

A colocation.

Speaker 2 31:34 🎥

The structure really appears. The structure at the Dutch house had one carrier. If a second carrier comes in, you wouldn't necessarily need to to include...

Speaker 1 31:47 🎥

Because all the hard work is done already because the tower's there. So this carrier is just coming and adding themselves onto the tower. They're gonna prove the structural integrity. They're gonna prove all of the things the engineer would want before

Speaker 2 31:59 🎥

he would make a waiver for this. It... It's the simpler applications that they're trying to address address.

Speaker 4 32:11 🎥

I wouldn't wanna call this boilerplate, but doesn't this language like this often appear in in in laws which which include construction

Speaker 2 32:27 🎥

Yes. Installation. Yes. I mean, it's a law firm, a lawyer drafted this. So, I mean, he's being mindful that a strict black and white application of this isn't always appropriate much like you have... You're required to have a zoning board. There has to be the ability to tailor what you're asking for to the needs

Speaker 6 32:48 🎥

of the community and you. In this case, though, it doesn't go to a planning board or zoning board. I mean, that section, you know, it's just in manager's office and... I'm using that as an example.... In the manager's office. It's a village engineer. Yeah. It's a Sorry. The village engineer's office. It's sort of a due process. You you provide this outlet

Speaker 2 33:09 🎥

because it would be ridiculous to require certain things if the application didn't lend itself to needing those. So I'm just... It's... The zoning board analysis was to show that that's a requirement because of due process. So it's almost like, constitutional right. There has to be sort of a a... An a steam valve outlet.

Speaker 4 33:38 🎥

And also to to an extent, you you would wanna ensure that you have confidence both in your engineer's capabilities, but also in in his or her wisdom to consult widely before... Within within the government before issuing the... Any kind of waiver. Yeah. And, certainly,

Speaker 2 33:57 🎥

your village engineer wouldn't be necessarily expert in an RF analysis. So the village engineer would seek confirmation that the RF analysis meets minimum standard under the... So so there there is an ability to to thoroughly review as with any application that comes in the door and a determination made based upon fact.

Speaker 1 34:33 🎥

I would think that we would have third party reviewer for sure with any Of course. Any application. I mean, we... We're talking about a structural engineer,

Speaker 2 34:42 🎥

not civil engineer. We're talking about an RF frequency, RF engineer, not, you know, a civil engineer. So, yes, we would certainly engage other experts to assist the engineer with, you know, making a determination that the application is sufficient, complete before any waiver would be even, entertained.

Speaker 6 35:10 🎥

And how would the board be aware of that? Is that something manager you would update us in a report?

Speaker 1 35:18 🎥

Yeah. I would I would imagine so. I mean, there's no... It's not built into the process. It's, you know, it's... It it would be an an application to the engineering department. You get a monthly report from the engineer's office that details all their all their activity for the month. So...

Speaker 6 35:38 🎥

And the wireless permit that's mentioned is... And the permit required on page five. That's not a special permit that goes to the planning board. It's just a permit that... Right. Are you are you talking about

Speaker 1 35:55 🎥

for a tower or for... Wireless communication

Speaker 6 35:58 🎥

facilities. It says...

Speaker 2 35:59 🎥

Wireless permit... Wireless permit.

Speaker 1 36:02 🎥

Well, there's a couple different permits that are in the law. Right? There's a permit for a tower, which goes to the planning board. And then there's permits for the small cell technology, are just issued through the The engineer's office.

Speaker 2 36:17 🎥

Okay. Yeah. Because they're attached to existing poles Right. Right. In the public right of way. Okay. And and the village is Okay. Taking into consideration the shot clocks, which have come over the top of a lot of the older laws. So this is a way you can ensure that you're not gonna you're not gonna, get to the point where a default approval is. You're going through this process very systematically.

Speaker 3 36:49 🎥

Mhmm.

Speaker 6 36:53 🎥

Okay. Thank you. Yeah, I think just if you can think about where we can integrate

Speaker 1 37:05 🎥

some language that just We'll take we'll take a look. Yeah.

Speaker 2 37:09 🎥

Yeah. We can, you know, maybe even expand it to explain the proprietary and the... Yeah. And the public health and safety and the interest, what's in the public interest. And that all of that will happen at a public meeting. Right. Thank you. Yeah.

Speaker 6 37:29 🎥

And then as far as going back to the zones, if I'm just curious if one of the areas where there's outage is in that Hessian Hills area. Has anybody reached out or would consider reaching out to Hudson Hills to see if Hudson National to see if they would consider putting a tower on the golf course?

Speaker 1 38:01 🎥

I'm try... I'm trying to remember if we spoke to them. I mean, we've spoken to other people up there. We, you know, we spoke to the... We've spoken to other people up there who are not interested in doing it. Don't wanna I don't wanna necessarily say who it is because I don't wanna get you know, I don't wanna get them in trouble. But, yeah, I I don't remember if specifically if they were one of the ones that we spoke to. Because there are there are some things that come along with having a a tower on your property that you have to deal with. Right? I mean, we have people that come to this building regularly because they need to check on things, do maintenance, you know, update software. It's just... So there are people that come to visit them regularly. So some people don't wanna be bothered with that. So... But, yeah, that... I don't mind. Might be worth having I don't mind having that conversation. They have a water tower and it's up high

Speaker 6 38:57 🎥

Yeah. And also property adjacent to.

Speaker 4 39:01 🎥

As well as, you know, in in light of what's going on on this roof, other roofs in in the village that might be applicable. I presume private, but maybe we're missing public roof here and there. I don't think so. No. But unless it's on some facility that that may may or may not be adaptable, you know, facilities, but definitely roofs. Yep. You know, a lot of this discussion's about towers. That's great. But then there's there's roofs, and then there's small cell or roof... Roofs, water towers, clocks. Mhmm. I'm not recommending the clocks. Right. But... As peoples? The clock is a tower, so so lots lots of options. But we'll never find out until we actually, a, do the law, and then Mhmm. And c Pick up the what the marketplace is interested in doing.

Speaker 0 39:58 🎥

Yeah. Sure.

Speaker 6 39:59 🎥

So what is it you wanted to achieve

Speaker 0 40:02 🎥

as far as... Well, I think we do have some unresolved policy questions, and I think the biggest would be the location, the the specific zones

Speaker 1 40:11 🎥

where towers could be built. Manager, are there any other policy questions that remain unresolved? I don't believe so. I mean, just looking... Let me just pull up the log. But we really we really only have a couple more minutes to spend on this because we do... We did invite Valerie to come. So we need to we need to spend some time on the other item on the agenda. So we're we're really talking about page 13,

Speaker 4 40:35 🎥

location standards Correct. Yeah. Number one where it says TBD.

Speaker 2 40:41 🎥

Now I guess that was... Yeah. That was I mean, I'll just... I'll... Right. And in in council's memo too, he points out the considerations. The village should be looking at these issues for village consideration. I think it's on page four of of council's memo too. So...

Speaker 1 40:58 🎥

So I... I'll just point out by saying that you... Right. We have one tower that's currently in the village that's in a parcel that's zoned light industrial. The tower that is co... We have a a co location on this building here, right, that that were zoned o one office. So as far as I'm aware, that's the only... Those are the only two

Speaker 4 41:28 🎥

towers or tower equipment in the village. Yeah. So... What I what I was thinking, manager, working... Just working backwards and and not in any way meaning to compare telecom to cannabis. But I think we did good work a couple of weeks ago in in defining those those zones for for cannabis, which would be the least impact in terms of in in terms of residents. And we... I think we could maybe work off of that list and and just see which which are the ones that that provide the same same benefit in terms of telecommunications, trying to keep it out of the out of the residential zones as much as can or completely. Yes.

Speaker 0 42:10 🎥

But I would say that the cannabis list is probably less inclusive than we would like. I mean, I think a good starting point is just to say all non residential zones, not non RA, non RB. Yep. Same same effect as far as I'm concerned. But by the way, that would also... Speaking of Hudson National, if we adopted, you know, something that included prohibitions for the residential zones, includes That's the National's all RA 60. Right? Correct. Yeah. And so it would be out except for colocation. Correct? Yeah. Yeah. So, I mean, it wouldn't be impossible, but the water tower that you mentioned, Nachtaler, would be very important.

Speaker 2 42:50 🎥

I I just need to point out. I I do have a client with a water tower at Wingfoot, which is a highly prized golf club, and it has four carriers No. It's very popular. With with, you know, an enclosure at the base of the water tower. All of all of the facilities, you know, are inside there, and it it causes very little impact, especially to the golfers. Inside? Yeah. They're skirting. They put skirting down, and everything is inside a door inside. So, you you know, it's it's one of those

Speaker 4 43:28 🎥

areas of least resistance that certainly you could you could explore. You know, maybe we could craft some accept language or some some window would would allow consideration of that, you know, based on a number of factors. So what would... What... What's the minimalist list that we could we could we could have in there? Mayor mayors start Oh, what? The non nonresidential?

Speaker 1 43:56 🎥

I mean, it would be Right. It would be o one, 02, C one, C two, LI.

Speaker 4 44:03 🎥

You're not gonna put the parks in. Right. Right? I mean, I So if you No. Yes. No. A few parks. If you wouldn't mind I don't think there's a real protect for that. Okay. For us, who will take... They'll take us a little longer to remember what what those numbers and letters mean. So if you could just go over those again. It's 01 and 02, which is office. Right? Those are both office.

Speaker 1 44:24 🎥

C 1 and C 2. C 1 is the Upper Village. C 2 is Municipal Place in South Riverside. Light Industrial is the train station area up to the 0.5 Moon Bay Warehouse.

Yeah. Those are the those are the nonresidential.

Speaker 0 44:53 🎥

At the risk of delivering the point attorney, is there anything to prevent someone in those zones right now from up... Coming forward with a tower application? No. Exactly. So... Or for that matter, in a residential zone. No. Yeah. And... And... So the status quo And... Is you can build in a residential zone. Right. What I am proposing is a prohibition on residential zones. However...

Speaker 2 45:14 🎥

Except for colocation. Your... Yeah. Your multifamily Mhmm. Larger multifamily buildings or commercial buildings that happen to be in residential zones have rooftops that are Yeah. Appropriate to cover gaps in coverage, you wouldn't wanna prohibit them from exploring that. That would a great location.

Speaker 0 45:34 🎥

And they would also have the right to colocate.

Speaker 4 45:36 🎥

Yeah. Because they're zone they're zone residential. Mayor, do you want... Do you wanna do all but residential, or do we wanna limit some of some of the all buts? In other words, that list is...

Speaker 0 45:49 🎥

I mean, is there any nonresidential zone that people would not want to authorize towers?

Speaker 4 46:01 🎥

If if we're talking about, you know, this... These four... It can't go in a residential property

Speaker 6 46:08 🎥

without the resident's

Speaker 1 46:10 🎥

permission. Right? No. No. Yeah. I mean, it can't... Well, it wouldn't it wouldn't be allowed on any... Right. It wouldn't be a permitted use in a residential zone. And we're we're specifically talking about tower based wireless communications facilities.

Speaker 2 46:23 🎥

That's it's different It's cell tower. Right. Yeah. As the mayor has pointed out a couple of times, that does not mean you're prohibiting colocations on rooftops in, you know, they would have to seek permission and could proceed. But you're talking about tower based.

Speaker 6 46:48 🎥

I guess the question is, like, where is it desperately needed and what zone is what, you know... I think

Speaker 1 46:56 🎥

I think you get at least three different answers to that, right, based off of what carriers people have, unfortunately. Because I mean, like, I hear from people on Grand Street who say they have zero service in their house and they have one carrier. You heard the chief who says he's got zero service up at his house and he's got a different carrier. Yep. Right? I mean, it's just... I think he said... I see. In the household there... There's people with two separate carriers. There

Speaker 4 47:21 🎥

are divided households in terms of in terms of carriers. I've I've heard that through. So O o one zero two office c one c two Commercial. Commercial. Allied. Could you just define the South Riverside up... Dimensions in terms of, you know, where?

Speaker 1 47:38 🎥

It's it's literally the the corridor. Okay. Right? It's the it's the it's the parcels that face South Riverside. Right. Yeah. Is that C 1? That's C 2. C 2? Yes. C 1 is the Upper Village. Mhmm. So if we allowed it anywhere but in residential,

Speaker 5 47:55 🎥

but if the if the village determined that they wanted to put a cell tower in a residential location, then we could? Well, on a municipal property. Yes. Municipal owned. And then what what is the purpose of

Speaker 4 48:07 🎥

this... Of of this... A lot of this is for... To to guide the the developers or the carriers that are interested in seeking to locate a tower, nonpublic.

Speaker 0 48:23 🎥

Which

Speaker 2 48:24 🎥

is... Just trying to limit it from going Right. All over the place. Right. Narrow. Right. I understand. Yeah. Like, in much the same way you issued an RFP for the best facilities, That's the Yeah. You know, on all the public properties. This is the same... An analogous procedure.

Speaker 6 48:42 🎥

So we already have one in LI. Could that be grandfathered in and we restrict more in LI? I mean, it's it's unlikely.

Speaker 1 48:53 🎥

It's on our property. So, I mean, it... Well,

Speaker 0 48:56 🎥

I mean, is there a reason to restrict it to LI? I mean, we we're we're okay with, you know, thousand

Speaker 6 49:04 🎥

homes. That's why, you know, they're already living behind the train track and deal with with that.

Speaker 4 49:16 🎥

Well, probably not likely. You'd want a second one. Right. Same Yeah. Area.

Speaker 1 49:24 🎥

I don't I don't think... And I'm sure people will correct me if I'm wrong. I don't think there are are issues along the river in terms of self-service. Are are there? No. You're getting... Not money.... Across the river. Yeah. Yeah. And and the fact that there's one at the train... That there's power at the train station. So... Line of sight. Yeah. That's... You're good. So I don't think I don't think there would... Like, you know, carriers are not going around just putting up towers willy nilly. Right? I mean, they need to be able to make a financial benefit off of it. So they're not gonna put one where the service is is working. So I I don't I don't think there would really be a compelling case for another one in the ally, at least at the... At least at this point in time. Seems

Speaker 2 50:12 🎥

Yeah. Incongruent.

Speaker 0 50:16 🎥

Okay. Just it just seems a little at odds with the... What is actually allowed in the LI. Like, theoretically, you could have an Amazon house with... A warehouse with twenty four seven transport logistical operations, and that, I assume, would be a lot more disruptive than a tower. So we're saying that that would be permissible under the zoning, but a tower, which would be providing a direct benefit to the community, would be prohibited. I mean, again, here's the other thing, right, is this code wasn't amended for a long time. It probably won't get amended again. And so I would really think carefully about making it overly restrictive. Even in areas where service is good, there is the potential for it to degrade over time with increased demand by customers. And that goes back to the kind of the micro grid stuff that we've talked about before is primarily a way to address capacity rather than actual coverage. But anyway, I digress. The point is that it could change, the technology could get better or the demands could get more acute. It's really hard to say and we're not gonna revisit this again probably in, hopefully, any of our times on the board. And so, I would just Will. Be cautious and emphasize the status quo, which is you can build anywhere

Speaker 4 51:39 🎥

in the village, residential included right now. Right. And that's that's why I that's why I think, mayor, you you make a good point on the on the residential thing. I think just for the purposes of of eliminating the TBD for now, you know, I think that's what we should do is eliminate the residential, put in the four zones that the manager articulated.

Speaker 0 52:02 🎥

And I think, you know, we'll we'll have an opportunity to to discuss those a little further, but... That's an excellent point, Len. As the former counsel said, right, is changes to an application or project or proposal or law, that's secret work. And we haven't started the secret process. So we need to have a draft law that we circulate to the relevant agencies and also put out eventually for a public hearing. And, you know, there may be some some something that we're missing right now and we'll we'll amend it. You know, we're not we're not bound by it Yep. Until... Right. You know, I think the important... What what you said exactly,

Speaker 4 52:41 🎥

I completely agree. And and, you know, the key point is I want people to understand and at least at least hear that we're eliminating...

Speaker 6 52:48 🎥

We're we're intending to eliminate the, the residential zones. And I would I would I would prefer to eliminate LI, anything new, because that is residential even though it's not zone residential. There are thousands of people living there. So, you know, even though it's unlikely

Speaker 0 53:07 🎥

But knows? We'll see. Go ahead. Sorry.

Speaker 1 53:10 🎥

We have four minutes. Yeah. So we really need to move on. So let us put together a draft, and we'll put this on the next work session.

Speaker 0 53:21 🎥

I I I am against that.

Speaker 1 53:24 🎥

We need to reach... I'm sorry, manager. We need to reach a conclusion.... Fine. It doesn't sound like we're there yet. So... But if we are...

Speaker 0 53:31 🎥

We we need to reach some... A tentative decision here. That's not a binding decision. It's not the final law, but I think we gotta put this out to secret in some form or another. Yeah. I I support

Speaker 6 53:43 🎥

saying no residential, and I would love to add in NLI. Know where, you know, that community doesn't need a future tower. Are There enough issues with Metro North.

Speaker 0 54:05 🎥

I mean, are we gonna ban a future tower from an an additional tower from this municipal building? I don't know if there there are any other carriers that aren't currently represented, but.

Speaker 4 54:14 🎥

Well, the the the concern I would have on on that with respect is is that all towers have to be replaced at some point. So the future tower would more than likely just be a replacement of the tower that's there.

Speaker 6 54:29 🎥

You could grant father in close off there? That opportunity. You could grandfather They in would

Speaker 2 54:35 🎥

would they would, classify as a preexisting nonconformity. So it doesn't need grandfathering per se unless you also include in here a sundown, but I don't see that that's... I mean, but the...

Speaker 1 54:49 🎥

You could have a future board that decides not to renew the lease. I don't know. Maybe maybe there's, you know, there could be a multitude of things where it's... It ends up not being in the parking lot.

Speaker 0 55:05 🎥

So... I mean, in this particular scenario, trustee Nachtaler, it sounds like you're speaking very specifically of one 0.5 Moon Bay, which would be the, I think, the closest private parcel to the 0.5 Moon Bay condo community. But, I mean, I'm trying to... And maybe this is a failure of imagination on my part or a lack of familiarity, but there's a bridge between that parcel and the condo community in addition to the train tracks. Right? I'm just trying...... Bridge. Yeah. I'm just trying to understand the impact. What what negative impact a tower could possibly have, especially... Radio radio

Speaker 6 55:43 🎥

activity. I I think it's why residents oppose have... It's why Briarcliffe Manor doesn't have cell towers in many locations,

Speaker 2 55:56 🎥

you know. I mean, if... We're concerned about... That ship sailed, unfortunately, with the FCC regulations and the upgrades. It's it's not a valid basis to deny an application anymore, especially because you're gonna require The test... RF analysis, which you will hire an independent reviewer to be sure it's tight.

Speaker 0 56:19 🎥

But the analysis just confirms it's FCC compliant. We can't make a decision beyond No. Say... No? You cannot make a decision. Yeah. So, obviously, if the RF analysis said this is gonna, you know, exceed

Speaker 2 56:32 🎥

Right.

Speaker 0 56:33 🎥

The FCC standards, that would be one thing.

Speaker 6 56:36 🎥

Is there a known reason why the met by the train tower would be moving?

Speaker 2 56:42 🎥

No. You just...

Speaker 1 56:44 🎥

I'm just saying...... Maybe down the road. Yeah. I'm just saying hypothetically. Right? I mean, it's cause it's a lease. Right? It has to come to this board. Yes. There could be... In twenty years from now, there could be people that say, no, we want... You know, we really want to have more of a park down at the at the train station because nobody commutes anymore. I don't know. It just... There could be a multitude of reasons for why it

Speaker 6 57:05 🎥

may not... Well, I'm not... My preference is where residents live and that is... I don't know why there's... Well, we all... Why do feel so strongly about it? Be... Because this entire neighborhood lives next to a tower already.

Speaker 0 57:20 🎥

That... This neighborhood that includes me. And the majority of residents in the survey, going back now a few years, said that they would support... They would even support a tower in their neighborhood if there was appropriate screening. I mean, it's... And there's a public safety issue here. Again, I'm not trying... There's no application. I just... It does not make sense to me. Then at that point, if you start saying, well, this non residential zone is next to a residential zone. That's every nonresidential zone, and then we're back I mean, not back to because the current status quo is Wild West, but then the opposite is no new towers anywhere.

Speaker 4 58:00 🎥

Given, you know, where we started, which is the existing statute, which has no restrictions Mhmm. Just on on block removing all of our residential districts, I think, is is a pretty significant

Speaker 1 58:14 🎥

Mhmm.

Speaker 4 58:15 🎥

And I I think, you know, if if folks were looking at that and say, oh, well, you removed your residential districts, therefore, you're you're going for, like, light industrial, office, commercial. That's that's that's how those things tend to go. And so I I think we'd be okay. Not not increasing any any exposure, folks that live, say, adjacent.

Speaker 6 58:48 🎥

So what would be the next steps if we just did residential?

Speaker 1 58:52 🎥

This goes into the law, and then do we have a public hearing on that? Like, with every local law, we would. And we have to sue. But not not not immediately. Right? You're gonna go through the whole... You're gonna do the... Send it out for seeker. Right. Right. You're gonna refer it to the planning Right. In the You're gonna refer it to the WAC. I I don't know actually if it doesn't need to be referred to the planning board. Okay. It's not it's not going into the zoning. That is true. Yeah. But it would go to the WAC because it's... It would need an LWRP determination.

Speaker 0 59:20 🎥

I mean, that... We would deal with that at... When we're declaring lead agency. Yeah. I mean, the referrals. So we don't have to figure out the referrals tonight.... Public coming forward and... Yeah. It will be on multiple...... With LI, they'll speak.

Speaker 1 59:34 🎥

It will be on multiple agendas. Yeah. Okay.

Speaker 7 59:40 🎥

Okay. Can I ask a question about the appeal? It's a quick question. Yeah. Sure. It's two days. Is that standard? Is that seems short, the ability to appeal.

Speaker 1 59:51 🎥

That's Do you have a section number? Yeah. The adjustment.

Speaker 7 59:54 🎥

Is it... That's what I was asking. Is just... It's a two zero six d. Talked about this. Okay. Sorry. I just I just see... Yeah. That was the only other question I had. Sorry. It seems quick. It just feels like that's a very short time. For... It wasn't for... I remember we talked about this. It wasn't for the public. It was for the applicant. Okay. Yeah. Yeah. So then they would... Yes. Yeah. Thank you. That's all I have. Okay. So

Speaker 1 60:13 🎥

just to be clear, we're gonna make that into this lot to allow the towers in nonresidential zoning districts.

Speaker 4 60:25 🎥

And could you repeat those again?

Speaker 1 60:27 🎥

01, 02. Office. Yep. Office. Those are both office. C 1 and C 2, which is commercial. Yep. And the LI, light industrial.

Speaker 2 60:40 🎥

And, again, this is for tower based installation. Yes. Yes. Like I said, the collocations, the rooftops, the small cells, There's no such prohibition. Those three. Okay.

Speaker 6 60:57 🎥

Alright, very good. I'm sorry, just want to go back to what Trustee Slippen said. I just, on section 2,068, page 29, it it should... We can make that more clear, you know, if it is the applicant, which is... Sorry. Which... I... Did you say page 29? Page 29.

Speaker 1 61:20 🎥

I don't have a page 20. Have 27. Page 25

Speaker 0 61:23 🎥

of the law. Oh, okay. Thank

Speaker 6 61:25 🎥

you. B. And I guess if you start with a, any person or entity adversely affected by the decision of the planning board, You know? And then it says, b, all appeals must be filed within two days. That was why I had the question. Yeah. It's the way it's worded. Because I re... I remember that you all said applicant, and when I read this, I thought I saw applicant. So I'm I'm sorry.

Speaker 1 61:52 🎥

I'll talk to her. Think it needs to be moved the air. Yeah. I would like to clarify. Yeah. I'll talk to them about that. Thank you. Yep.

Speaker 2 61:59 🎥

Definitely. Good point.

Speaker 0 62:02 🎥

And in fact, that... That's a good flag because elsewhere in the draft, uses WCF applicant, repeatedly to identify the applicant. So the fact that it... And it actually defined it, in the definition section. So We should use the defined term. Yeah. For consistency and clarity, we should do that. Yeah. Okay. That's fine.

Speaker 7 62:24 🎥

Or or extend the the time of appeal. It just seems like it's a... I I don't care how you do it.

Speaker 1 62:31 🎥

I'll I'll talk to him and find out find out what the... Where that two days came from. Perfect. Yeah.

Speaker 0 62:37 🎥

Okay. Alright. I'm glad we got it done even if it took a little longer than perhaps we were hoping. Alright. Valerie is with us. We're proceeding to item two.

Speaker 2 62:54 🎥

Good evening. Good evening. So

Speaker 1 62:59 🎥

She's not here. Alright. So we've asked Valerie to join us tonight to go through. Can do that. It's basically... We've we've already reviewed this in... Over the summer. These were the changes that we agreed to for... These are uses that are currently... That currently require a special permit, and they would be moved to permitted uses. So they would not have to go through the special permit process. Right. Depending on depending on what specific use you're looking at, they could still have to go to the planning board for site plan or change of use,

Speaker 2 63:36 🎥

but they wouldn't have to go for a special permit. Right. And they still would be subject to the building permit and building standards requirements and code compliance. And again, just so we're clear, we, Valerie and I, incorporated what you instructed us to and we have no pride of authorship and if there are changes, we'll do whatever needs to be done.

Speaker 8 64:00 🎥

Right. And most likely based on the village's regulations in terms of site plan, I would assume almost all of these uses would be before the planning board for site plan approval.

Speaker 2 64:14 🎥

So I think that helps you to understand what level of review The local law. Is still going to be required for these permitted uses.

Speaker 6 64:27 🎥

For day cares, is day care a special permit going to the planning board or it's just a permitted use that gets approved by the engineering office? It's current. It's it's currently...

Speaker 1 64:39 🎥

Sorry, Valerie. Do you wanna answer? No. No. Go ahead. Oh, okay. It's currently a special permit use that goes to the planning board. What's being proposed is that in some districts, it gets reduced to a permitted use. Because, like, for example, under the code, right, in a in a commercial zone, it's... It requires a special permit. You know, you have at least four day cares, I think, in commercial zones right now. Maybe maybe three because the one in Asbury closed. So you have the two happy hearts and you have holy name. So, yeah, the board had already made a decision a couple of years ago to... The permit used to be termed. They used to have, like, they'd have to be renewed every five years, and the board made a decision a couple of years ago to grant those day care special... Special permits. So they don't have to come back and get renewed every every so often. You know, I don't I don't necessarily think that there are...

You know, their their use is consistent with the other uses in that zone. So, you know, the attorney and and the planner can correct me if I'm wrong, but that's one of the reasons why it would no longer need a Right.

Speaker 8 66:09 🎥

There... It's not recommended to keep the special permit. Right. And I think... And the... But keep in mind, this... Moving it from special permit to, just more or less site plan, you're not necessarily taking away any of the requirements that are associated with the day care centers. Right? You're still requiring any sort of other additional regulations in terms of parking, lighting, whatever. That's all staying. It's just the process itself. So instead of having almost like a two step process or a more in-depth process for that. It's just allowing for the... In the, in the commercial districts to allow that just to proceed, like, no different than if you had a theater or a restaurant. Right? So technically, in your commercial district, a theater or restaurant is considered a permitted use. This would have the same review and approval process as something like that.

Speaker 6 67:01 🎥

Okay. So just so I'm clear, if a new daycare would like to open in the 01 District.

Speaker 8 67:12 🎥

They would most likely need to see the planning board for approval because there's gonna be certain parking regulations. There's gonna be certain site conditions that are required, so they wouldn't need to seek site plan approval. And then At the very least Yeah. And they were a place that had a different use. A change of use. It would be a change of use. Which also... Which goes to the planning board. Right. But even so, there are certain parking regulations and stuff like that associated with that. So most likely, it would trigger that site plan review.

Speaker 6 67:43 🎥

Because I I guess what, I mean, I appreciate the desire to wanna expedite and not create a lot of hoops and

Speaker 1 67:53 🎥

It's a streamlining, yeah. Streamlining. But

Speaker 6 67:56 🎥

at the same time, if it's a business that has a high degree of traffic, dropping kids off, picking kids up, you know, I just wanna make sure that we're looking at traffic impact studies and and parking implications.

Speaker 1 68:15 🎥

Mhmm. Then we we just add... We just added that, right, as part of that most recent local law? Right. Well, and all the... Again, if you look at the regulations,

Speaker 8 68:26 🎥

there are still requirements for day care centers. Right? It does talk about there should be no more than one day care center per lot. There should be limits of outdoor play space. They have to comply with all conditions limitations, New York State Office of Children and Family Services. And then also as part of, like, a site plan approval, they would also need to look at parking and loading and unloading and drop offs and stuff like that. That is part and parcel. It's not just automatically go ahead and get a building permit and just do whatever Yeah. You prefer to do in terms of operations.

Speaker 6 68:58 🎥

And we we didn't mention site plan approval in this law, did we?

Speaker 8 69:03 🎥

Because it's not... These these are just the sections that are being modified. For social permits. Right. You are... You have another whole section, for site plan purposes that specifically says the thresholds of any particular application or use throughout the village would require a site plan approval. And this is the fourth

Speaker 2 69:22 🎥

change specifically to special permits. You did a general overhaul, then you went back and addressed some additional revisions, you did the cannabis ones. These are just the sections as it exists in your code today that address what you had asked to have addressed, the last time you discussed the adoption of the earlier iteration.

Speaker 6 69:55 🎥

Okay. Because permitted use, to me special permit takes me directly to the planning board with a lot of requirements versus a permitted use doesn't necessarily stipulate all of those requirements. But if you're saying that I have to triangulate this document that I read with another law to look at that day care has parking and traffic and...

Speaker 2 70:22 🎥

Because I don't see any... This is the zoning code. So it's just these provisions in the zoning code right now, but the entirety of the zoning code which includes a definition and the things that are required for the site plan review and the change of use plan. So these are just the last of the changes in the special permit area. Right. And when they're incorporated, it's the whole zoning code will apply to a permitted use of any kind.

Speaker 6 70:53 🎥

Yes. But I need to go back and crisscross and do all that. There's not... It's not necessarily crisscrossing.

Speaker 8 70:59 🎥

It's just looking at... If you look at the article that's for site plan review. Right? And then it just discusses what requires site plan review and the standards for site plan review. Great. That wasn't in here. Right? Well, no. It won't be because we're not making any changes to that. So, you know, I just wanna be clear in that. So thank you. Right. So any any bulk requirements, any parking regulations, any lighting standards, any landscaping standards, any all site plan review in terms of what's required. We already did some of those edits in terms of like traffic, those types of things. All of that is not being proposed to be changed. No. This is really just simply more or less, I would say, I consider it more of a process change in terms of you're moving it from special permit use to a permitted use, meaning you can just move forward with the planning board. Right. Thank you. And I also think just as a... Keep in mind, at some point in time, the special permits were in front of the village board. Yeah. Right? So at this point, since everything's moved over to the planning board, it's still the same board. So it would almost Right. It's almost like the same board would be reviewing

Speaker 1 72:17 🎥

the the application for the... Right. It's not... That was the genesis for reviewing this. Right. Exactly. We were looking to see, do we really need to put some of these uses through both processes before the same board? Right. Yeah.

Speaker 6 72:33 🎥

And is schedule d...

Speaker 1 72:36 🎥

Schedule d is being... It's gone now. Right? Well, we're recommending it to be deleted because the purpose of the schedule was to say, alright. These permits go to the village board. These permits go to the zoning board, but now all the permits go to the planning board. Right. So there's no reason to have a schedule. Right. Yeah.

Speaker 6 72:53 🎥

But it was a little confusing because it was attached in this law and it had different color codes. Oh, that's b. No. No. She's talking about the backup from July. That was... Oh, yeah. That was backup from June. It's on the agenda in June. Yeah. We build on talking about building it.

Speaker 2 73:10 🎥

Setting this. Right. Because now all the special permits...

Speaker 6 73:14 🎥

I I understood that. I think it was just a little... That showed

Speaker 2 73:17 🎥

which special permits went to which board. So Okay. We just...

Speaker 6 73:22 🎥

It's no longer applicable. And what is applicable is attachment B, schedule of uses. Yes. Okay. Can you please explain what is occasional retail that we're adding in the light industrial? What... Like, what does that mean? And why are we adding it?

Speaker 1 73:44 🎥

Is there a vision for We were asked to Mike to be there included? Well, I think the question is what does occasional retail mean? Because it's it's in the code right now. It's a special permit use. Right. It's being proposed to move to a permitted use. You know, I think the one good example of that might be the dessertist used to be located in the building with the green growler. Right? So... But she was really a commercial operation. You know, it was like a commercial kitchen that then made stuff to go other places. So, like, if she wanted to have a one day sale where it was like, come and buy all my cupcakes. Right? You know, like, that would be an occasional retail

Speaker 6 74:25 🎥

sale. Okay. Yeah. But that's that's

Speaker 1 74:29 🎥

not LI though. But that's a good example. It is LI. The Green Occasional retail is an LI right now. Yeah. The Green Growler Building is zoned LI.

Speaker 6 74:38 🎥

Okay. Yeah. I thought it was Croton Point Avenue a different, well, transit oriented development. Well, that that that's a... Yeah. That's a... Okay. Hudson overlay. Yeah. Okay. Are there any other plans that... Examples or...

Speaker 1 74:59 🎥

Well, there's very... I mean, the LI is very small to begin with. Right? I mean, there's only six parcels, maybe seven in it. Yeah. So you have... One is one is vacant. It's the Croton North Train Station. One is a tire warehouse. I don't really think that they're gonna have, like, a factory sale, but they could in theory. Right? Yeah. Right. Yeah. 0.25 Point Avenue is is zoned LI, but that's gonna be residential. You have the green Growler, and you have the the Harmon Yards and the train station. So, I mean, that's that's pretty much... That's your LI. So... Okay. Yeah.

Speaker 2 75:45 🎥

It just made no sense to put it in as a special permit use.

Speaker 6 75:49 🎥

Right. Okay. And under accessory uses in LI, it says adult entertainment use.

Speaker 1 75:58 🎥

That's existing. Yeah. That's not being proposed to change. No change.

Speaker 6 76:02 🎥

What... Okay. The major changes are

Speaker 2 76:08 🎥

the one care Yeah. The ones retail. Yeah. And the ones that are underlined in this, it... And they're also... You're also, you know, taking out the extra level of requirements in districts for social clubs, organizations, non for profit organizations, and you're you're also looking at animal related uses. Mhmm. And we've we've defined that. We added a definition. So it's clear where those

Speaker 6 76:43 🎥

would be. It was hard to tell what's new in the schedule. I I realized, unfortunately, this No is no underlining.

Speaker 1 76:51 🎥

No. Nothing. It happens by accident sometimes because when you when you convert a Word document to PDF, unless you print it and then you have to you have to print it.... Happened to me. Yeah. So it got uploaded with... I I apologize for that. It got uploaded without the without the red line. I actually have the red line in front of me.

Speaker 8 77:13 🎥

So I can just kind of highlight. Oh, thank you. So just... So... Because there's really not that many changes. Yeah. So in the o one, the change was to move daycare centers to permitted. Mhmm. And then special permit uses with the special permit... Special uses permitted in RA 60 districts. And then it has with the exception of day care centers. That's the new That same thing what I just described is the same thing for o two Was the addition for day care centers and then the little caveat with the exception of day care centers for for the special permit uses. Then in the commercial districts, the changes there were for the permitted prison... Principal uses. For c one, it included social clubs or other not for profit organizations that are being moved from special permit to permitted and day care centers. And those are the only changes for that. For c one r, the only change was to add animal related uses general as a permitted use. And then in c two, the changes there were to allow for animal related uses general. And then the decision was to remove day care centers in entirety.

Speaker 2 78:49 🎥

So it's just reflective of the text that you've just reviewed? Right. It's just to incorporate that into a table in the back. Yeah. The text of the law governs. Right. But it's a quick way, for reference to Yeah. To... It's... Some people are visual learners.

Speaker 8 79:07 🎥

Yeah. No. I am a model. I just had no idea what, you know, if somebody... If I was... And the last change in that table was the occasional retail sales incidental to the conduct of permitted uses. It was moved from special permit to permit. Other than that, nothing else has changed from what's existing. Thank you. You're welcome. Thank you, Valerie. And I'm sorry for the confusion.

Speaker 2 79:27 🎥

No. Not... Okay. We we will

Speaker 1 79:32 🎥

put it in the right format when We all just need to look at... We're all guilty of it. We really need to look and just make sure that everything is the way we want it to be. Yeah. So Okay. Thank you. Is everybody comfortable with this that we can... Yeah. I am. Yep. Yep. Okay. Great. Thank you.

3. Review of electric bike & scooter legislation adopted by Westchester County Board of Legislators.
Speaker 0 79:52 🎥

Alright. Alright. Item number three, review of electric bike and scooter legislation adopted by the county board of legislators.

Speaker 1 79:59 🎥

Okay. So this is not this is not really for discussion tonight. We just would like to get consensus so that we can refer this to the bike pet committee and to the planner

Speaker 4 80:10 🎥

to to review and come up with some topics for the board to review. Consider. Exactly. And I I would just add that... To that manager. I've talked with with chairman Arnold of the bicycle and pedestrian committee. The committee actually happens to be meeting tomorrow night. He's he's looked at this already, and it's it's on the agenda for for tomorrow evening. So... That's a pretty fast action. This is the fastest action we've had. The impetus

Speaker 2 80:35 🎥

for this is that the vehicle and traffic law of New York State indicated that local jurisdictions could not regulate beyond the VTL provisions until each county, in this case we were waiting for Westchester County, Suffolk took it up first Yep. To adopt enabling legislation. That's what this is. So it's now giving you permission to look deeper into safety precautions and info... Code enforcement beyond that they just have to follow the VTL provisions.

Speaker 4 81:08 🎥

It was it was fascinating to actually look at the state legislation and and see where it says, for Westchester County Yes. This is what you have to do. It had. Yep. So

Speaker 6 81:18 🎥

thank you for bringing it to the bike pad and also bringing it to Valerie's organization because I I would love to see some best practices around ebikes, pedestrian, traffic, scooters, e scooters,

Speaker 2 81:36 🎥

and This is the first time you're allowed to look at that. Helmets. Yeah. Helmets

Speaker 6 81:40 🎥

belts. Reflective. You know? Yes. Everything. Yeah. Speed limits, whatever. You know? Yes. Lots of good stuff. Up to this point, you could only regulate

Speaker 2 81:49 🎥

where it's e bikes and e scooters are used. That's all you could do. Now you have the ability to dig a little deeper to do what's best for your

Speaker 6 81:58 🎥

community. Could I just

Speaker 7 82:01 🎥

suggest that as we move forward with this, we coordinate with Ossining and Cortlandt so that, and maybe Yorktown or wherever people might be Coming from? Yeah. So that, like, whatever we're doing is consistent with the surrounding neighbor... The surrounding municipalities. They don't have to be exactly consistent, but I don't want... And I don't even know, you know, I I I don't know if it would be, but I don't want our rules to be drastically different or at least like to be aware of what the surrounding communities are doing Yeah. So that we can help the people who are using these vehicles be able to... I don't want... You know, I wanna make sure that our laws are are... Make sense with the surrounding laws. I guess everybody's at the beginning of this process as well. They're

Speaker 6 82:46 🎥

not. In Westchester County, they are. No. Mount Pleasant has their unanimous vote of a board on 09/22/2026 Without the authority. Regulated. Okay. But still So now you unanimous board approval, September 22, regulated e bikes and scooters. Mhmm. We follow the law broke the law. They did. They did. What law... Our attorney just tried. For doing it. They did happen. They cannot enforce that law unless Yeah. That was right. County enabled them to regulate. So... Yes. Well, just so the public is aware, they have a pretty darn good law on the books, and I think we should look at it. That's fine. That's fine. We can. I mean, the law the law was adopted by the county last week, and we put it on the agenda for this week. You. Just to...... On the bicycle. And... Yeah. And I just I

Speaker 2 83:34 🎥

just had been monitoring this because we didn't want to adopt or look at adopting regulations before we were actually legally allowed to do that.

Speaker 7 83:45 🎥

I just don't want somebody to go over the cross and hang and have a No. That makes set of rules. Makes sense. Perfect. But there's a lot more conversation around this to be had. Sure. Yep. So... Yeah. The extra reflective,

Speaker 2 83:56 🎥

the, you know, that... For example, at this point, the VTL requires a parent to be present if there's an underage rider on one of these vehicles. Underage rider, the parent had to be present in order to be able to issue a ticket. So there are a lot of roadblocks from local police departments being able to enforce provisions, helmet laws, etcetera, etcetera, because it's it's now enabled so you can look at this comprehensively.

Speaker 0 84:31 🎥

I think we can... We've had a lot of pedestrian services.... Session. Oh, thank you. I'll let you know how that turns out. Put a... Put a pin in it. We'll let we'll let you know how. Do we do we wanna, take a brief pause before we go to the regular meeting, or do we wanna head straight in? I'm happy to move straight in. We're going straight in.

Experimental project: croton.news uses AI to generate articles from public records. Content may contain errors. Please report any inaccuracies and check our corrections log.