croton.news
Croton-on-Hudson, NY · Sunday, November 22, 2026· Nov 22, 2026 Independent, AI-assisted local reporting from public records Source-linked·Corrections welcomed
Full Transcript

CHUFSD Board of Education Work Session 11/19/26

Nov 19, 2026 — 10,744 words, 9 named speaker labels
· Automated meeting transcript · Watch Video ↗
Automatically transcribed from the meeting video and formatted for reading. Speaker names are identified where possible; "(sp)" marks a spelling not yet verified against official records. Click any timestamp to link to that moment.
Speaker 0 0:12 🎥

Okay.

Speaker 1 0:14 🎥

Have to find my thing that I'm speaking.

Anamika Bhatnagar 0:18 🎥

Okay. Good evening, and welcome to the members of our community in the audience watching the livestream and listening at a later date. I'd like to call to order the 11/19/2026 work session of the Croton-Harmon Union Free School District's Board of Education. Before addressing the community this evening, the board will first consider a resolution to approve tonight's agenda. Item 1.2,

Speaker 1 0:40 🎥

be it resolved that the Board of Education hereby approves the agenda as presented. Second.

Anamika Bhatnagar 0:46 🎥

On the question? All in favor?

Speaker 1 0:50 🎥

Aye. Opposed?

Anamika Bhatnagar 0:52 🎥

Abstaining? The motion carries. We'll move into item 2.1, president's report. Before delivering my president's report, I invite superintendent Stephen Walker to address the community.

Stephen Walker 1:05 🎥

This has obviously been a tremendously difficult week for our school district and for school districts and organizations throughout our region that have been impacted by the news that we learned on Monday regarding John Griffiths. All of us who have the opportunity to work with children know the responsibility that comes from being role models for students and the trust that comes with that important responsibility. When a person we know is alleged to have broken that trust, it feels like a betrayal to all of us. As a school district, we recognize how important the criminal investigation into this matter is, and we're committed to cooperating fully with law enforcement authorities conducting the investigation as we have been since we learned of this matter on Monday. Additionally, if and when those authorities share information with us that they indicate may be shared with our community, we commit that we will do so. We will also be conducting an internal investigation which will be coordinated with law enforcement authorities to ensure that we do not interfere with the criminal investigation and any prosecution

of criminal charges. Amidst the shock, anger, and betrayal that we all feel, we must also remember that our job is to ensure that our schools remain the places they have always been, spaces of curiosity, inquiry, learning, and joy for all students. There's a tremendous amount of amazing work happening in our schools every day, and so our other commitment is that we will remain focused on continuing to improve the experience of our students every day. Thank you to our staff members, families, and community for helping us to always stay true to that promise to our students.

Speaker 1 2:39 🎥

Thank you. Thank you, superintendent Walker. The board of education joins the Croton-Harmon School District in affirming our commitment to cooperating

Anamika Bhatnagar 2:47 🎥

with law enforcement authorities. Further, the board appreciates superintendent Walker's prompt and transparent communications to our school community this week and his commitment to maintaining the same. We also appreciate the dedication of the district's leadership team, our school building leaders, and our entire staff towards supporting our students and families. As superintendent Walker noted, it is the work of the district and board to ensure that our schools remain space of curiosity, inquiry, learning, and joy for all of our students. As such, our meeting is going to shift now to further discussion of that work. As always, we invite the community's feedback and engagement on all matters concerning our students, their well-being, and our schools. I'd like to just also add that while we do not typically schedule hearings of the public during our work sessions, there's no opportunity for the community to speak tonight,

but we welcome and invite your participation at our December 3 business meeting. Community members are also encouraged to come speak to us directly at our meet the BOE sessions, which are held immediately preceding our Thursday meetings, typically at 6PM in the CHHS Rotunda. I'm gonna move now into a preview of tonight's agenda. In addition to an update and discussion of the CET literacy curriculum review, the board will consider tonight ratifying a memorandum of agreement between the district and our local of the Amalgamated Transit Union. We will also review the award in response to an RFP, request for proposal, for architectural and engineering services for multiyear capital planning, upcoming building projects, and the state mandated building condition survey along with other business. Tonight's literacy curriculum update reflects our evolving approach to board of education work sessions.

This year, the board and district are working more closely together to review and report on initiatives related to our shared goals, our instructional programs, student achievement and experience, and other topics of community interest. We're no longer relegating these discussions to the meetings labeled as work sessions, which allows us to use each of our board meetings to communicate regularly about these efforts, essentially doubling the district's previous presentation schedule, and thank you for your support in that, but also providing the board and community with a much broader and in-depth view of the work. As a board, we're grateful to our administrators and building leaders for partnering with us in this way, and we're looking forward to another robust conversation this evening. Finally, I've shared previously that the board is using our public meetings to advance two of our ongoing operational goals, reflecting community values through our actions and ensuring that our students' needs are well served by the district's educational programs.

At our last meeting, we focused on a third operational goal, which is oversight of the work of the superintendent and district through our review of the annual superintendent's goals. Tonight, we're gonna continue to advance our fourth operational goal to ensure that the objectives of the district, which include continuous improvement, are effectively carried out. You will see this tonight in the curriculum review to follow as well as in the planning and resourcing decisions we'll be making this evening. And towards the end of this year, we'll be taking a look back to see how we've done with these board operational goals and report on that back to you, our community. Thank you.

Speaker 1 6:10 🎥

Didn't mean to turn off my mic. We'll, segue now to our formal superintendent's report. Over to you.

Stephen Walker 6:19 🎥

Thank you again, Anamika. I want to begin my my report this evening, where I like to begin every report, which is by highlighting, some outstanding recent performances by, so many of our students across the district, beginning with our outstanding fourth grade students at CET in their recent performance of Shrek junior, the musical. I had the opportunity to see this show along with several members of the board of education and administrative team and CET faculty, and I'm sure I can speak for the entire audience, when I can say that I was wowed by the confidence, the talent, the teamwork, and the commitment of the entire cast and crew. This is the second year that we've had expanded our musical theater program into CET, and it's exciting and thrilling to think about seeing these students continue to grow through our program at PVC and CHHS the Champ Boosters, and everyone who participated in the in the musical's pit band,

for providing our entire school district community with such a fun and energizing show. I also wanna make sure to mention that the CHHS fall drama performance of 12 angry men is taking place this weekend, tomorrow night and Saturday in the auditorium at CHHS.

Congratulations also to our Tiger Unified sports team who took on Hen Hood in last week's, Boccia match at CHHS. It was particularly beautiful, to see our community's support for our students at that event as the crowd include... Included supporters from some of our other sports teams, parents, staff members, administrators, family, and friends.

at their annual regional dinner and symposium at Tilly Foster Farm in Brewster. We had the chance to connect with leaders from school districts around the region and learn from a panel of speakers about the importance of special acts school districts and strategies to ensure that districts can successfully meet the varied needs of students of all ages. for putting on this regional event each year and for their support and advocacy of public education across our region. On Monday of this week, Laura and I had the chance to host parents here at CHHS for the first community conversations of the school year. We genuinely appreciated the the approximately 30 parents who gave up their time to attend the sessions and offer their perspective and questions on topics such as an update on curriculum work at CET, advanced placement and dual enrollment courses at CHHS, New York inspires, and budget priorities. We plan to host further community conversations related to curriculum and instruction in February,

so be on the lookout for further details about how to sign up for those opportunities soon. I wanna thank Laura very much for all the work she did in preparation for those conversations and presenting the information in such a detailed yet accessible fashion within... For our parent community. Last night, the counseling department hosted their annual college symposium event designed to help students and families receive information about a range of topics related to the college selection and application process. Every year that I've attended these sessions, I've left having learned more about the process,

Also, on a related note, we're working with our counseling team to arrange a time for them to attend a board meeting in February to present to the board and community on how they support students throughout their years at CHHS and to help prepare them for the next chapter after graduation. So I look forward to further details on that coming soon. And finally, I want to reference a couple of upcoming dates that align with new events in our school district this year. First, on December 11, residents should play... Please check their mailboxes for our first print newsletter of the school year. Reflections, this newsletter will focus on our specific progress toward accomplishing our district goals for this year and what comes next in our work with regard to each of those goals. We look forward to sharing this publication with our community and then to issuing a second edition in the spring for your work in putting together this exciting addition to our communications approach. The text was just finalized today, so, already moving forward very quickly toward that December 11 mailing date.

Additionally, we'll be inviting our community to come visit with us before the December 17 board meeting from five to 06:30PM here at CHHS in the Innovative Learning Center to discuss your priorities, ideas, and questions related to to to the two thousand twenty seven, twenty eight school district budget. This is a chance for our administrative team to engage with our community, and we invite you to stop in and ask a question, share an idea, and visit with us on the topic of the budget. Your questions and ideas will then help us to shape our budget considerations and conversations as those public board of education budget meetings begin in January. So please also be on the lookout for further information there, and we look forward to that discussion as we start our budget conversations in earnest. Thank you.

Anamika Bhatnagar 12:05 🎥

Oops. Didn't tie. Sorry about that. Thank you, Steve. Any comments from the board? K.

And we'll move now into item 2.3, our board reports. We'll start with,

Speaker 3 12:28 🎥

as always, in alphabetical order, the audit committee. Audit is not scheduled to meet till the New Year.

Anamika Bhatnagar 12:34 🎥

Perfect. Thank you so much. I will just briefly deliver a report on behalf of the board governance committee, which convened on Monday, of this week. It's been a long week. So we met to finalize board committee protocols, which we'll be presenting at the December 3 business meeting of the full board. We also drafted a timeline formally for the superintendent evaluation process, which includes our regular midyear check-in. We'll also be presenting that at the December 3 meeting for the full board. In the interim, the members of the board governance committee are going to be refining the midyear survey instrument that was developed last year to ensure that it's up to date and covers our needs for this year. We also debriefed on the board's fall retreat, we'll be reaching out to schedule a winter retreat, ideally jointly with administrative leadership. And our next meeting is Monday, January 11 at 07:30PM.

Moving on to, our next committee, which is, apologize, policy committee. Over to you, Ana.

Ana Teague 13:32 🎥

Policy met on, November 6, I believe.

engaged with NYSSBA to start to do the review. We've made a request of the eight week process to see if they could perhaps roll the policies out in like groups in the two thousands, three thousands and on. One of the concerns that they've expressed is that, you know, if if they roll us out the 2,000 and then they realize that it's cross referenced with something later on, that that might slow the work. But I do anticipate having a conversation with her just in order to break it down in in digestible pieces as a committee and in order to continue to roll those policies out for first reading and second reading. I'm going to suggest that we just take them as they are and, like, refrain or maybe if they are cross referenced with something, pause on advancing those. But I think that there are some that we can continue to advance. Interestingly enough, we did discuss the e scooter and the e bike policy

at the November 6 meeting. This week, actually, the New York State Department of Education came out with guidance that coincides more with New York State law regarding, like, who can actually use e scooters and e bikes. So there is a nuance to the development or looking at our policy and perhaps a guidance and... Rather than, you know, a shaping of a policy, but we'll continue to do that. We have to schedule our next meeting with administration since we don't have anything, like, really to present to administration at this point and we are trying to be much more considerate of your time, we are going to meet this Saturday at 9AM. That meeting has been noticed. The agenda is to follow. And I think that's what we have. We have decided how we're going to break up the work. One of the things that I'm going to be doing is looking at the 5 thousands to work with our student ex officio trustees and to have them take,

you know, a more in-depth look at the policies that affect the student body and perhaps have them bring that work here and have them bring that to student faculty congress as well. Jake is looking at our governance. Allison is looking at our technology that overlaps with some of the interests they have. And we anticipate also just having the results of the audit and having that work to go, moving forward. So we feel like we're in good shape. That's all I have to report on that.

Anamika Bhatnagar 16:05 🎥

Great. Thank you. Moving over to the community advisory committee on technology.

Omar Mayyasi 16:11 🎥

Committee, we're, drafting communication that's going to be sent out to community members that were nominated or actually voted onto the committee. We just need to finalize the communication and, hope to send it out next week before before everybody goes on break.

Theo Oshiro 16:36 🎥

as... Was our last meeting where we did sort of a final review of our tenure review process, which actually starting tonight in executive session. If folks remember, we, proposed a kind of a a more expanded process, right, over multiple days to review, the tenure class, for each, tenure class, as well as tenure candidates for each school building over more time and with some, information to review ahead of time. You know, I think today will be a a good sort of, like, test run, right, to see how how it goes. We're excited to get feedback as well as we, you know, continue to move past today and into future sessions to see what feedback trustees have around the the process and what tweaks to be made, if any, both to, the information presented, at the sessions and ahead of time. We also talked about our hiring process. One, I think, very tangible thing that we're gonna be proposing and bringing to this group,

and as well to the policy committee is some tweaks to the, policy ninety two thirty for, which is our recruiting and hiring policy, to make a little bit more specific what our hiring process is, specifically with a preamble, that's specific to, issues like, our practices and beliefs around hiring as well as our process for posting as well as exceptions potentially to a usual process in emergency situations. So we'll be presenting on that in a future meeting. We we have to, sort of refine the thinking at our next meeting in December. So the next meeting will be focused on, putting a finer point on that concept of adjusting that policy and bring forward forward to this, to the policy committee and then to the full board for consideration of that. So that's where we're at.

Anamika Bhatnagar 18:45 🎥

Great. Thank you so much, Theo. So to give Theo a break, we'll do liaison reports unless there's questions. Yep. Go ahead.

Allison? Omar? Alright. I can just report very quickly on, I'm, the the board's liaison to the bicycle pedestrian committee, which is meeting tonight, but I have some exciting news. So I wanna say thank you to the village's bicycle pedestrian committee for their advocacy and support in encouraging the village to install, my favorite thing, a rectangular rapid flashing beacon. I know everyone's like, what is wrong with you? RRFB. No. That's my second favorite. Stop arm cameras are my second favorite thing. My first favorite thing are RRFBs. These are rectangular rapid flashing beacons. So when you approach the crosswalk, you press the button and the lights start to flash. So there has been one installed as of last Thursday, at, the signed crosswalk at Van Cortlandt Place and Maple Avenue. This, as anyone who has had a student go to PVC or walk in this village, will know, this is a crucial thoroughfare for our PVC students walking to and from the middle school from the Wells Avenue neighborhood, and it's a major safety improvement. So I wanna just extend on thank...

Last week with Jake, I had a chance to attend CET's Veterans Day commemoration. I think that was last week. And like everyone, I'm looking forward to seeing 12 very angry men tomorrow at CHHS. Theo? Anything liaison report from you?

Theo Oshiro 22:00 🎥

No. No. No liaison report from me.

Speaker 1 22:04 🎥

So

Jacob Day 22:09 🎥

Not a liaison, but an update. I did attend the the community conversation, Monday evening with doctor Dubak, and there were, I think, about 10 parents there. I had to leave after two hours because it was it was it was just this really great engaged conversation. I know this is what we're gonna cover tonight, but it was an awesome presentation. I think everyone in the room appreciated the the transparency and the information and the dialogue. There was a really healthy dialogue about curriculum. I was there till 08:00. I was like, I'm late. I I have to go. So I hope that they didn't keep you there too late, but I think everyone there really appreciated it. And I know it's an ongoing series, but, we're gonna talk about it tonight. But it was a really great event. So thank you for doing that.

Ana Teague 22:50 🎥

Jake, I just wanna say, a trustee, I appreciated the note that you sent to everybody to recap that because for some of us who couldn't attend, that was really helpful. Yeah.

Anamika Bhatnagar 23:00 🎥

Thank you all. I think that just sort of harkens back actually to superintendent Walker's remarks about the increased community engagement. So it's exciting this year not only to... That that there's been an introduction of these community conversations to engage directly with members of our community, but as a person who likes pieces of paper still. I'm also excited for our print newsletters. I know. It's like rapid, rectangular rapid flashing beacons in paper. My three favorite things now. Everybody knows what to get me for Christmas. But, to see a paper newsletter, I think, come back is gonna be meaningful, especially during the year of our technology reset to have something tangible for folks to look at, hold on to is really important, and it's another way of reaching people. And we are very, very much looking forward to also the the budget conversation because I think, again, for us as a board, these decisions for us as a board and as district do need to be informed more directly by the community and this decision to have the conversation in early enough stage throughout the process that it actually can inform our thinking is, is a positive step. So we're looking forward to that.

And now for something something, completely not different, but equally exciting is, our Carrie E. Tompkins elementary school literacy curriculum update. So I will turn it over to,

Stephen Walker 24:15 🎥

when we think about improving student achievement at any level or across any program, we think about it through a couple of lenses that mostly we can describe as the what and the how. And so when we think about the what, we're talking about the curriculum itself and the resources associated with that. And then there's the how, which is how are teachers delivering the pedagogy within the classroom. And as the board knows, I think hopefully the community knows, over the past two or three years, CET spent a significant amount of time with support from the board and the community through resource allocation on the how side of it. Right? Thinking about things like the allocation of resource toward instructional coaches, toward a literacy coach, toward restructuring the AIS program at CET to allow for students to receive intervention based on their area of need and rather than their grade level.

Making sure that all of our k two classroom teachers, English as a new language faculty, interventionists, special educators are trained in a multisensory reading approach. All of those things address the how, the pedagogy continuing to improve our already outstanding classroom practices. Now the other side of that, of course, is what are we putting in front of students, the curriculum and the resources. And so I'm thrilled that that's one of our district goals for this year, that that's a priority from CET's end, and then we have Laura providing such outstanding leadership and oversight to that. So I'm happy to turn it over to her to to talk a little bit more about how this is, shaping up.

Laura Dubak 25:34 🎥

So as as Steve said, focusing on the k to eight ELA curriculum is one of our district goals, over a two year period. And so if we go to the next slide, we began with a focus on the grades three to four literacy curriculum which was identified as a prior... Priority area, and we began with reviewing current curriculum overviews. So I'll note that we're looking at ELA curriculum overall first from a k five perspective even though we're focusing on three to four first. We're really thinking about it as a k five experience, with a gradual rollout. So recentering in the data from our October presentation, grades three to four ELA proficiency scores have generally mirrored state proficiency trends. So we're always above the statewide averages as we shared in October, which is a good but a good data point for us is to look at the pattern. So do we go up when the state scores go up? Do we go down when the state scores go down? And we've been pretty steady in that regard.

So our ELA data is generally strong in grades three to four and has certainly recovered from the COVID, dips that happen statewide and nationwide. But this testing data is just one data point. There's also the data that comes from the focus on continuous improvement and what we're putting in front of our students, which means thinking about the curricular materials, experience, and alignment that we want. So step one was each grade level and content area completing their curriculum overviews which we've talked a little bit about also as part of our district goals. Each of those curriculum overviews have gone through a series of review and revision. We're still finishing up some of that process and identifying opportunities for additional common experiences. On this slide and the next slide, you'll see one example of a kindergarten reading map. So this is just for reading. There would be one for kindergarten writing, math, social studies, and science.

So based on feedback from our community last spring as well as from our faculty, we wanted to ensure that these overviews included information that families actually want and find useful. So we heard loud and clear last spring that families are not very interested in a long list of standards with EduSpeak tied into them. They're really interested in what is my child learning, what books are they reading, what assessments are they, engaged in, and what core experiences will they be experienced. So each map that we created has a timeline for the length of each unit, key topics and concepts, core resources and texts, assessments, and other common experiences. So for example, as a parent, if I know that in in unit one, for example, we're focusing on the primary sounds a to g, that tells me as a parent that when I'm reading at home with my child, that's what I can be focusing on during a read aloud.

I'll know how they're being assessed, and I'll know that they will be going on a... That all of the kindergarteners will be doing the print detective scavenger hunt, for example. So that's where this work starts. And then if we go to the next slide and get a sneak preview of our website. So our new curriculum website will be organized by building. And then on the next slide, you'll see, the opening of the first grade. So if you go to first grade, you would see all of the units and subjects and you're able to filter if you wanna just see the math... The units for a particular subject, if you wanna look at the entire first grade. And then on the next slide, you can look at just an example. If I wanna filter by science, I'll see the key... The five key science units. And then if you click on each one, you'll see a kind of, condensed version so that you're not looking at a screen full of text. So it's a more dynamic way to look at the curriculum

and identify some of the best most useful practices from those to inform how we set up our website.

really nice resource for our community. Okay. So then going back to the ELA curriculum work specifically in third and fourth grade. In terms of actions that have happened already to date, we've completed the curriculum review of grades three to four, the existing curriculum review. We have been engaged as, we shared at previous meetings in a pretty extensive resource search to identify potential resources,

Speaker 0 30:30 🎥

and we have landed on our front runner Arts & Letters by Great Minds.

Laura Dubak 30:35 🎥

We've been collaborating with CET and PVC administration and faculty, and that's involved grades three to five and coaches as well, regarding initial k to two conversations. So, again, while the primary focus is on three to four, we're not missing the opportunity to bring in the other grade level faculty instructional coaches so that we can, share the experience that we're going through initially with three and four with grades k to two and five. We've also engaged in an even more comprehensive data analysis. So looking at item analysis from, all of the... You see the aggregate data for three and four. We've looked at the item analysis. So what specific skills were students strong with? What were they weak with? We've engaged and are continuing to engage in professional learning for the... For pilot programs or for pilot units for arts and letters. And we have three school visits scheduled in December and January to districts that are in various stages of implementing arts and letters. We're going to

Irvington, White Plains, and Byram Hills. They're in years one, two, and three respectively of implementing the curriculum so we can really hear from teachers what year one is like, what changes in year two, and what sort of a more solid implementation in year three looks like. So our next steps, December, we're... We'll be going to the regional schools and debriefing. We're putting the final touches on the timing for each of the pilot units. Each... In grades three and four, every single teacher is piloting one unit. So, typically, when you pilot units, it'll be a couple of teachers in a grade level that will try out a unit with their students. But because this is a resource that we are really making a big investment in and really want to make sure is implemented fully and with fidelity. We offered the opportunity to all of our teachers, and they were excited and happy to choose units. And, actually, I put some sample unit materials out,

if you wanna look through anything just to get a sense of what our kids are going to be experiencing. So what you have in front of you are the, teacher curriculum guides for the units. You have... Allison's modeling there. And you have some... The student workbooks that go along with them and just some of the core texts that go along with each of the units. And, you probably see there are a lot of books, being passed around. So each unit has anywhere between four and six full class texts in addition to read alouds, book groups. And I think one of the things I really wanna highlight about this particular curriculum is that all of these books that are in front of you, they're copies for every single student. So it's not just the teacher with the read aloud book. Every student gets the experience of having their hands on every single book which from a teaching literacy perspective is the dream.

There are skills that come along with teacher read alouds and then there are significant skills that come along with reading along with somebody modeling reading out loud. So while it's a significant investment to get this number of texts, it's definitely well worth it, I think. And along with implementing the pilot units, there's significant professional learning that comes from great minds. So we get a half day coaching session in December, for example, just to teach us the basics of the pilot. So they'll go through each and every unit with, the administrative team, the instructional coaches, and all of the teachers. And then every teacher that's implementing a pilot unit also gets individualized coaching once a week throughout the entire pilot. So they really set it up so that you can be truly successful and implement with fidelity. So three and four between January and April, every third and fourth grader will get an experience with one of these units.

We'll be working on aligning our budgetary resources to curriculum purchasing, which you'll hear more about through the budget process. And while grades three and four are piloting, k to two and grade five teachers will be able to visit those classes while they're implementing the units. And instructional coaches and curriculum coordinators will also be participating in the professional learning to better be able to support colleagues through the implementation. So going to the next slide, I'm not gonna read through all of this. This is more a resource for our community and for all of you just to get a sense of the scope of arts and letters from a k eight perspective. So every grade level has four major modules or units in it. Every unit has somewhere between four and six core texts in addition to book groups, read alouds, art pieces. So here you can see kind of the topics and essential questions.

They're very high interest topics, so things like outer space, exploring the sea, the American revolution, artists making art, so forth. There's a really cool, integrated science ELA unit too in fourth grade. And then on the next slide, just an example of kind of the the scope of text access that kids are getting. And I think I had mentioned previously that one of the key features of arts and letters is not just the text. That's the that's one of the big selling point, the number and quality of the text, but also the complexity of the text. So all of these texts that are represented are at the average lexile level or well above which is really important in terms of exposure. And research shows that even students who are reading below grade level make much more significant gains when they're exposed to higher complexity text. So that's a really important feature of selecting a curricular program.

The other really important thing to keep in mind is early, returns on the investment in science of reading. So as we know, there's often the pendulum swing in education and so a lot of good has come from the implementation of the science of reading programs, the phonemic awareness and so forth in k to two, but an aspect that's already coming into play is the lack of exposure to full texts. So when you're focusing a lot or maybe sometimes too much on those foundational reading skills which are incredibly important. It's sometimes at the expense of full texts and so that was a really important aspect of choosing a new curriculum too. Then on the next slide, this is just again more of a resource a resource to take a look at just in terms of the instructional design behind arts and letters. What I really wanna highlight here is students writing about what they read. So the writing instruction is integrated into the curriculum. So we probably all have experience with our kids doing things like a personal narrative unit, a,

short story fiction unit in their separate writing block. What's different about this kind of curriculum is that you might be writing a personal narrative but it's embedded in the outer space unit taking on the knowledge and role of what you've learned in that unit. And so again from a literacy perspective, that's the ideal. Writing about what you read returns, and much stronger results than writing about unrelated topics. Then on the next page, just to get a sense of what does a day of arts and letters look like for students. So one of the aspects of this program is that the literacy block is longer than typical literacy blocks. So at full, when you're really comfortable with implementation, each literacy block is about fifty five minutes. What we've learned from schools that are implementing in year one is that's a little closer to sixty five in the first year as you're really getting used to implementation.

But each lesson follows kind of a predictable pattern and there's a lot of transition and movement for students which is also something that's really important because sitting in one place for sixty five minutes doesn't always go over very well in third grade. And as Steve mentioned, the how you teach is a key part of this equation. So one of the other things that really drew us to this program besides the the text and the complexity is the pedagogical approach. So the things that are listed as routines here are pedagogical strategies that are very familiar to us in the Croton schools and things that our instructional coaches and all of our teachers are experienced with, and know are good for kids. So there are some programs that you'll look at where there's a lot of call and repeat, a lot of multiple choice, a lot of worksheets and this program is not that. It focuses on in terms of pedagogy,

discussion, pair sharing, question corners, things that we believe are right for kids. And then finally, assessment is a key part of any curricular decision making. And one of the things that we were impressed with in terms of the assessment is that there is a summative end of module task that goes along with each of these units but there's also weekly listening reading comprehension assessments so they're quick. When I say assessment, don't picture like a test where kids are sitting for an hour taking a test. They can be quick one question spot assessments so that you're getting real time feedback about transfer.

goes. So we think that's also a nice option for the future for us. And then on the last side, for the community's benefit and for the board's benefit, I just put some overview documents in a link there, some of what we've talked about tonight if you ever wanna take an even deeper dive into looking at some of this. So happy to answer any questions.

Speaker 0 41:06 🎥

Or...

Anamika Bhatnagar 41:07 🎥

Yeah. Well, let's open it up for questions and, whoever would like to go first. Anyone? Sure. We'll do that side of the table and then we'll come around. How about that? So,

Allison Samuels 41:20 🎥

thank you. This is really great. I, have three questions, I think, at this point. The first one... Oh, just working backwards, it looks like there's some really, like you just said, it... This is the how, but it also has a lot of the pedagogical. I'm thinking about for our students with... Who have special education need, like IEPs and five o fours, to what extent are they being... Their needs being addressed as part of the piloting

Speaker 7 41:51 🎥

process and in terms of the, you know, that... And should I go through the rest of the question? Okay. I'm

Laura Dubak 41:59 🎥

glad you asked that question. I actually forgot to say it when I was talking. So, in all of those teacher, spiral books that you see, there are differentiated approaches throughout for every single lesson and unit. So those are kind of pre done. There's also an intervention program that comes along with our purchase and so that intervention program is if for example you have a special class or a self contained setting where you want to implement the full curriculum. It's almost like a companion curriculum that's differentiated for that profile of student. And then in terms of our multilingual learners, there's actually... In every, module, it comes with Spanish language text for specific texts, within each unit, which is nice.

Anamika Bhatnagar 42:44 🎥

Over to you, Jake, and then we'll come back around so that everyone has a round of questions.

Jacob Day 42:48 🎥

Yeah. So I just wanted to try to understand arts and letters a little bit more, and sort of kinda how that would look from, like, the comprehensive k through five or k through eight. So their website talks about how it's a knowledge building program, k through eight, and you're you're going to Byram Hills, right, I think in a couple weeks. And their website talks about they're using Great Minds Arts and Letters for k through four now and then k... And then five in 2027, 2028. So we're we're piloting it in in '3 to four, but it sounds like it's meant to be more of a,

Speaker 6 43:25 🎥

you know, k five, k three eight. So is that the goal, or is that gonna depend on the pilot? Or Yes. What's the thought there? So that's the goal. In in an ideal pilot situation, you'd start in kindergarten

Laura Dubak 43:35 🎥

and then work your way up one year at a time. The downside to doing it that way is that it takes a long time for the kids to get the benefit. So given some of the work of the literacy committee and some of the urgency around addressing the grades three and four curriculum, we knew that that was definitely a priority to start with this year. And then the plan would be to do fifth grade the following. So 2728, three to four full implementation. And then in, 2829, add fifth grade and then look at k two for, also '28, '29. K two,

Speaker 0 44:15 🎥

is a little bit more complex be... She's

Speaker 6 44:19 🎥

listening. I think Siri wants to learn too. Hey. Hey. Yes. We can.

Laura Dubak 44:26 🎥

K two is,

a reading and writing program, and that's brand new. So we're looking at kind of matching up the two programs so that the... So that it's a reasonable lift on the teachers. It's a lot of work to learn a whole new curriculum, so they just went through that whole training process. What we think will be a really good fit is to keep the Hegarty phonemic awareness piece. So that's the really, phonics based,

Speaker 6 45:05 🎥

early program for k two and then add that on top of the k two arts and letters curriculum, which is strong for the comprehension and writing. So it would be sort of a complimentary sort of package. Right? Just when I read about arts and letters, it just seems like it's designed for that. I know we're piloting it. I know we did a lot of work on Hegger. I just wanna make sure we kinda understand, like, the long term, making sure all this stuff works and is and is, like, sequential the way it should be. We should have a k five common experience. So that's the goal.

Laura Dubak 45:34 🎥

It's... You know, as we talked about, in previous conversations, the k five math work is an an an easier lift because we're already more aligned. The

Speaker 0 45:43 🎥

ELA lift is going to take two years to get to that alignment but the goal is k five. Great. Thank you.

Ana Teague 45:54 🎥

This looks amazing. I wanted to say that. The well roundedness of it, the component of the the the coaching even in piloting that. I know that we've heard from some of our teachers regarding, like, some of the online modules. They'd rather have, like, the in person coaching. So that I think is amazing. Even the the guides to have them all, you know, tactile in one place for everyone to handle. To piggyback on what Allison was saying regarding the differentiation, we're hearing from parents out of CET that they want, like, you know,

Speaker 4 46:29 🎥

students to be challenged. There are some students who need extra help. There are some students who need extra challenge. Does this program allow for that and how? Definitely.

Laura Dubak 46:38 🎥

So this... What we've heard from other districts implementing arts and letters is the first year can be really challenging for the students because it is such a jump in terms of what they're typically experiencing in terms of reading and writing. And so that's something we know and are going to expect. See it as potential... We don't want kids to struggle, but I I think it just... It's very confirming hearing from the other districts that that's a common experience that they're having. So I think naturally just the amount of text and the quality of the text is going to be a natural differentiation or enrichment. And the flip side of that is the challenge in differentiating even more for students who might struggle with reading. That's probably where we're going to, be needing to put more and more of our resources and we're thankful that we have such a strong AIS instructional coaching support already at CET. Something that we're hearing from other districts is, you know what? Now we're going to hire another AIS teacher for the elementary school. So we're fortunate that we actually already have that in place, so we'll have that

safety net.

Speaker 1 47:51 🎥

Yeah.

Speaker 5 47:53 🎥

I... Thanks for this. This is great. I was wondering just in terms of, like, the how teachers might bring kind of their unique skills and talents and interests to this and and sort of... If you could describe a little bit of, like, this seems great, very structured, but, like, how is is this all adaptable to sort of, like, fit into what those kind of teacher... What what the teacher brings to the experience? That's a really good question. And one of,

Laura Dubak 48:20 🎥

often one of the primary concerns when we're identifying curriculum is what about this reader lab that I love that I've done for the last ten years? So the way that the program's structured is there's four modules, but it doesn't take up every single calendar day of the school year. So there's plenty of room to add in. So for example, with the fifth grade team, we were talking about, we were looking at the curriculum and thinking about what that would look like to roll it out in fifth grade. And one of their favorite units that they do in fifth grade is Good Different. One of the fifth grade units is around, I forgot the exact title of it, but finding your community. So that book is a a perfect fit to put into that module in arts and letters. So there's plenty of space for that teacher creativity while still adhering to kind of the common curriculum.

Anamika Bhatnagar 49:13 🎥

I think for me, I just wanna say thank you again for all the time and effort that's gone into, to researching and and identifying this as the, curriculum that we're gonna be moving towards. It definitely speaks to what I'm seeing as a commonality of experience, which I think has been a question for us, also ensuring that, you know, while we have, like, our goals and our standards that we need to meet, now we actually have materials that are uniform with with still the latitude for individual instructors to sort of, like, deliver the material and reinforce those skills in the different ways that, that are sort of, you know, provided in the guidance. I think also from a... From the perspective of developing the capacity to read whole texts, this is one of the really, really important things about this curriculum. It's like you're seeing the books that are coming around. And if you looked at the list, that was a couple of slides before that. The,

the list of titles, and I say this, you know, based off of my my, professional background. The list of titles is really... It's contemporary. It's robust. It represents a broad, variety of authors and experiences. And the link to these specific knowledge building topics and the fact that we're we're gonna be now developing our writing against what we're reading, that is actually... I mean, like, it's like we we talk about the science of reading as relates to phonics, but the further science of reading as you get into older grades is that those skills are fundamentally developed, reinforced, and strengthened entirely by writing about what you read about and talking about what you read about. So I think, as a program, this looks very, very exciting. My only real question is just in terms of some of the material that we saw going around. So in terms of, like, the workbooks, are those types of things that we're gonna be sort of like... Are are we treating them as reproducibles? Are students going to have individual

Speaker 1 50:53 🎥

sort of, like, workbooks or materials, or how does that piece it of roll out? Because I know you mentioned the class sets for the reading material, but for the actual writing and exercises, what would that look like? Good question. So the the student books, are consumables,

Laura Dubak 51:06 🎥

so we'd be getting a new set of those every year. So the kids will have their own materials that they're writing on that align exactly with their curriculum. So that's kind of the... There's the initial implementation cost which is getting all the text, so it'll be a large number this year. And then there is the ongoing cost which will be a smaller investment on a year to year basis.

Anamika Bhatnagar 51:27 🎥

It's helpful. Omar? Yep.

Omar Mayyasi 51:30 🎥

Thank you for this. It's really, really very helpful and and exciting work that we have ahead of us. For the benefit of the board and and and the public, can you talk a little bit about, you know, why we're doing this now? Right? Why not last year? Why not next year?

Laura Dubak 51:46 🎥

Yeah. So last year, the district's literacy committee, unearthed that they... That there was a need to really look closely at the third and fourth grade curriculum. And as you saw from the data, our third and fourth grade ELA data from a state test score score perspective is steady and strong. It's certainly not the place where ELA scores are the lowest in the district by any means. But just looking at curriculum, so there's the literacy committee work and knowing that there was a need for more whole texts in those particular grades. And we had already invested a lot in addressing the needs in K two with the Haggerty bridges to reading and writing. So that all came out of the urgent work around the science of reading where most districts really had to hone in on k two. So we had already done that prior and not paid as much attention that was due to three and four. And so the literacy committee got together, looked at grades three and four, had conversations around that, and that's how the year ended last year with the commitment that we were going to implement something different in three and four.

Stephen Walker 52:57 🎥

I would just add on that topic. I think what we see a lot of districts do is rotate through curricular resources every few years, not see the student experience change dramatically, blame it on the resource, and then just bring in a new one. And so I think the reason for that is they haven't addressed the how side of it. Right? And, again, the work has been done with support from the board and the community over the past three or four years in ensuring there's consistent training, the instructional coaching, the literacy coaching, the structuring, the AIS program. All of those things are now in place so that there's readiness for the resource as opposed to applying a great resource but not having all of the other things in place.

Laura Dubak 53:35 🎥

I think too sometimes districts will spend an entire year with a literacy committee just spending hours going over different curricular resources and that can often slow the process down. So that... So in terms of why not next year, for example, we could have spent this entire year, with a big committee looking at a variety of, you know, 10 different resources doing program reviews and then that would push off the pilot year until 2728 and full implementation into 2829. So I think, you know, you have to balance the urgency, the need to get the curriculum in front of kids with the process. And I think that this was a place where there's so much good research and other high performing districts that are implementing this resource that we didn't need to spend an entire year doing that.

Anamika Bhatnagar 54:28 🎥

Couple more questions. Thank you.

Speaker 7 54:33 🎥

So echo everybody's appreciation so far. And, also, I I do love the fact that students will have their own workbook for executive functioning and all those good things. So that's great. Happy to spend money on that. So, although it's not really only up to me, but but I think that... Lovely idea of that. Can you speak a little bit... Like, get into the weeds about the pilot? And, you know, when you do an assessment of a pilot, like, what are the... Like, who's involved with it? You spoke a little bit about that, but also, like, what are kind of the questions that you're looking at it? You know? And, like, sometimes I've participated in a pilot where the assumption is, like, we're not sure if we're gonna do this. Continue with this. And, you know, so we need... We're also... Maybe there's a predetermined metric or some criteria you're using to say, like, yeah. This is worth pursuing. And other times, it's like, no. We're we're probably gonna do it. Let's let's see what we need to do the best we can with it. You know? So wanted to just get a sense if you have an opinion about that. But then, you know, also,

it... You know, I appreciate, like, we've... You mentioned several times as we've talked about this over multiple meetings about that that kind of tension between, you know, looking at at student learn... Learning and how that translates into their achievement results, you know, and that there probably will be a dip. So I'm just curious what what what would you feel is, like, acceptable or how are you... Like, there's, like, measuring the the teacher experience and the how of it, but there's also the student experience with it and the... But also the the... What they learn. Mhmm. And, you know, the other thing just to throw out, there's, you know, you talked about, like, people struggling, and there is that tension of, like, struggle can... Is sometimes necessarily and good in order to push forward, you know, even though it could be hard and sometimes awful toxic. So anyway.

Laura Dubak 56:28 🎥

Yeah. I'll start with kind of the end because I think you're you're spot on there that we would not determine a pilot is unsuccessful if the student said, wow. This is this is hard. That actually digging into it might actually be a really good thing. And so in terms of this particular pilot, pilot's the term that we use, but I think I see this more as, like, unit training because we're pretty sure that we're doing this. And so this pilot's really designed to be about learning how to do it with fidelity, answering the questions that are going to come up naturally so that we're prepared to fully implement it with hopefully very few questions, very few issues, in the 2728 school year. And so we also very strategically chose multiple units for each grade. So rather than having the entire third grade team do the same unit, the third grade team split it up into pairs. So there's two teachers doing one unit, two teachers doing another, two teachers doing another so that you get broader experience with the whole curriculum but still have a partner to bounce ideas off and share with.

So in terms of evaluating, there's going to be the assessments that actually come with the program. The kids are going to be doing those assessments. It's obviously only of one unit. And then there's also some kind of structured student feedback forms that students fill out as do teachers. And they actually work... The the professional development coach from the company actually works with us to go through those results and make tweaks based on the student and teacher experience. And we haven't really talked about it much, but there might be an opportunity for, some parent involvement as well based on what they're hearing from their kids.

Speaker 1 58:19 🎥

You said you had a third question. So what... You you got it in there? It was both questions. Oh, okay. Great. Great. Are there other questions,

Anamika Bhatnagar 58:25 🎥

that folks have for Laura or about the process? Anyone? Okay. Well, I wanna say thank you again. I know, Laura, this has been, like, a significant initiative with the support of the CET, literacy committee and the the, reading specialists and the curriculum coordinators and the CET leadership team as well. To land in this place, I think, feels really good and feels really exciting. And I know our community, when they see books,

Speaker 1 58:52 🎥

they get very excited like we all do. Ana? I just... I I do have actually one follow-up question. I I also just wanna thank,

Ana Teague 58:59 🎥

you know, obviously, superintendent Walker and, assistant superintendent, Harrington Cohen for just giving the financial resources needed for, like, the implementation of a program like that and making that work in a budget. But my my question is, are we as a board going to hear about the outcome of the pilots at some point?

Laura Dubak 59:20 🎥

We can definitely do that. Yeah. We can figure out if we do it in meeting or in a week. Before we move forward with, like, you know, implementing it, I think we'd like to to check-in.

Anamika Bhatnagar 59:29 🎥

Yeah. I mean, I think that... I think what I'm hearing is that we are... That that that the the evidence... Part of our decision making is based off of evidence that that there's years of research on sort of, like, the success of the program. Am I right in articulating that? As well as the fact that it is being used in other districts. But I think the value of looking from that... Looking at that immediate feedback is gonna be to inform a little bit of what Laura talked about, right, which is, like, how things can be tweaked and shifted for us. And in terms of what other supports, I think that's what you're identifying also is, like, what other supports would we need within our system to make sure that the implementation takes place. Does that sound like what we're talking about things like budgeting for summer professional development work. We might have to think about looking at that a little differently and where we're putting our resources in because there's work that'll go along with rolling out something this significant.

Laura Dubak 60:16 🎥

And I also... I was remiss in not saying earlier, just

They were ready ready to go, willing, excited to dive into it, and I think that's a testament to all of the prep work that went into, getting to this point. So since I'm standing there, thank you.

Anamika Bhatnagar 60:40 🎥

Yeah. But I think that the... I think that that's actually really an important point because I think one of the benefits of these these curricula that are sort of assembled in this way is that if you are a person who loves reading and loves loves to read, it it delivers actually all of that. It delivers those resources. So I think, you know, for me, I'm thinking about, like, if this was an opportunity for me in the classroom would be just really exciting to be like, these are things that I'm gonna love to share with my students, and I'm gonna love that they each get to have their own copy to hold. I'm not gonna let go of that. I'm gonna say that every time. So I I think it's really, it is, it's... It is exciting. And on behalf of the board, thank you again to the CET leadership team, all the teachers who are involved in reviewing, and to both of you. And, of course,

Speaker 1 61:18 🎥

you know, the budget is the most important piece of it because that's how we pay for it. So thank you for keeping us on track, Denise. Well, luckily, we're just we're just beginning on our process for next year, so we'll cover we'll cover all of it. And thank you also, Ana, for highlighting that. It is it's, it's part of, I think, what makes these conversations so helpful is because everyone is looking at it from a different perspective. And I, for one, I really appreciate hearing what everyone's thinking about, both our folks who have students at CET and then for those of us who had our students there, you know, many, many years ago, it's just... This feels really good to be talking about it in this space and to be able to share it with our community. So thank you. Thank you very much. If there's nothing else on this, we're gonna move into the next item of our agenda,

Anamika Bhatnagar 61:56 🎥

which is new business. Item 4.1, a memorandum agreement with the ATU. So be it resolved that the board of education hereby approves the memorandum... Did I skip something? No. Okay. Hereby approves memorandum of agreement between the Croton-Harmon Union Free School District and local eleven eighty one to ten sixty one Amalgamated Transit Union, effective 07/01/2026 through 06/30/2029 as presented. On the question?

Speaker 8 62:29 🎥

Can I just add that I am very pleased to present this for approval this evening? This agreement reflects a very collaborative process with, the ATU unit. Our drivers, dispatchers, and monitors get our children to school safely every day and, this contract reflects the value that they bring to the district. So I'm happy to bring it for approval.

Anamika Bhatnagar 62:55 🎥

Any questions from the board?

Speaker 1 62:58 🎥

And I'll call for a vote. All in favor? Aye.

Anamika Bhatnagar 63:03 🎥

Opposed? Abstain? The motion carries. Thank you very much. Congratulations. And we will look forward to seeing members of our transportation unit tomorrow at their, transportation... Annual transportation luncheon, which is the highlight, across the district. We're really looking forward to saying thank you in person, to our colleagues over at the transportation office. K. Moving into item 5.1, our consent agenda. Be it resolved that the board of education hereby approves the consent agenda items as presented.

Speaker 6 63:35 🎥

Second.

Speaker 1 63:37 🎥

On the question?

Ana Teague 63:40 🎥

I don't have a question. I just want to,

That's one of those things, you know, to get the boosters to support them and to participate in, a wrestling tournament tournament like that. It's one of those, like, quintessential high school experiences, I think. And to be able to, to chaperone them, to have them travel as a team, just think is a really worthy event. So I commend them for taking that on. It's not every coaching team that would do something like that.

Anamika Bhatnagar 64:18 🎥

Denise, if I could ask you just to comment quickly on the, the RFP award for us.

Denise Harrington-Cohen 64:25 🎥

Sure. After a very thorough review process and RFP, our committee, had proposals from seven different architectural firms and we met with multiple firms, met with three other firms to evaluate the proposal and KG and D came out as the clear choice for the entire committee. Their partnership has delivered multiple projects on time, under budget. They have we can avoid any learning curve and really hit the ground running looking at our five year plan, building condition survey and upcoming capital projects. So we're really glad to to partner with them again.

Anamika Bhatnagar 65:11 🎥

Yeah. I would say I think, the familiarity and, like, their dedication and just the good working relationship is really positive. So thank you for that, additional background.

Speaker 1 65:20 🎥

If are no other questions from the board, call for a vote. All in favor? Aye.

Anamika Bhatnagar 65:25 🎥

Opposed? Abstaining? The motion carries. Thank you. We'll move into the closing of our meeting, item 6.1, the polling of the board. If anyone has comments or questions at this time. Okay. 6.2, our next board of education meeting will be held on Thursday, December 3 at 06:30PM here in the library. And our last work session of the year will be December 17, 06:30PM also at the library. At this time, the board is going to enter executive session. I'm gonna, read the, resolution, be it resolved that the board of education hereby enters executive session to discuss the employment of a particular person or persons as well as details of proposed, current, or pending litigation.

Speaker 4 66:09 🎥

So moved. Second.

Anamika Bhatnagar 66:11 🎥

On the question?

Speaker 1 66:13 🎥

All in favor? Aye.

Anamika Bhatnagar 66:15 🎥

Opposed? Abstaining? The motion carries. For the benefit of the public, please know that after we exit executive session, we will properly adjourn the meeting. Thank you to everyone in the community who attended. We'll see you in two weeks at our next meeting. Have a good evening. Thank you.

Experimental project: croton.news uses AI to generate articles from public records. Content may contain errors. Please report any inaccuracies and check our corrections log.