Croton-on-Hudson, NY · Wednesday, November 18, 2026· Nov 18, 2026Independent, AI-assisted local reporting from public recordsSource-linked·Corrections welcomed
Planning Board Approves Two Accessory Cottages, Waiving $12,000 Parkland Fees
The Croton Planning Board unanimously approved accessory cottages at 43 Riverview Trail and 284 Grand Street on Jan. 27, waiving the village's $12,000 parkland fee both times and asking officials to press trustees for a middle ground. The board also granted final sign approval to Mirage Mirror & Glass and heard that a 49-unit building is expected at 425 South Riverside Avenue.
●Approved a 750-square-foot accessory cottage at 43 Riverview Trail, 5-0, waiving the $12,000 fee in lieu of parkland
●Approved a 499-square-foot garage-to-cottage conversion at 284 Grand Street, 5-0, again waiving the fee
●Issued final signage approval for Mirage Mirror & Glass at 425 South Riverside Avenue, 5-0
●Asked the building department to urge village trustees to review the all-or-nothing parkland fee
The Planning Board approved two accessory cottages Tuesday night, and in both cases struck the village's $12,000 parkland fee from the approvals — a charge board members say offers them no middle ground between the full fee and nothing at all.
Under Section 230-73 of the village code, the board can require a payment in lieu of parkland from new dwelling units, on the finding that they contribute to population growth. Members have chafed at the fixed amount each time an accessory-cottage application has come up, and Tuesday's meeting gave them two more chances to say so.
The first application came from Roseanne MacDonald, who is replacing a cottage at 43 Riverview Trail that, she said, "hasn't been used in thirty years" Read 6:26▶. Dean Borelli of Westchester Modular Homes told the board the new 750-square-foot unit follows variances already granted by the Zoning Board of Appeals — allowing the cottage to sit closer to the street than the main house, a height variance of three feet, three inches, and a front door facing the street. The modular building will be set in place by crane in two sections, is all-electric, and will use existing water and sewer connections, with a new gravel parking area alongside. Land disturbance stays under 5,000 square feet and no trees are being removed.
MacDonald will remain in the primary house while her daughter moves in. "I live in the primary house. My daughter's gonna move in. Being that I am older, my daughter's a nurse." Read 5:50▶ "If I should need the help, she'll be there." Read 5:50▶
Steve Krisky asked that the unit's exterior floodlights be shielded to throw light downward rather than scatter it outward.
When the parkland fee condition came up, Geoffrey Haynes said the board was following "a precedent that we've set in these past accessory cottages, not apartments, accessory cottages" Read 16:40▶, noting that the new resident is simply a daughter joining her mother and that the fee would be a large share of a modular home's cost.
"I don't necessarily agree, but I'm willing to go along with a herd on this one, particularly because we've done it in the past." Read 17:16▶ Krisky said. Krisky repeated a hope that the Board of Trustees will either give the Planning Board latitude or modify the fee themselves. Asked whether the board could simply set a lower amount, Village Engineer Vincent Salanitro said he would defer to the village attorney but did not believe it could.
Participants discuss the recreation fee at the January 27 Planning Board meeting. Watch this moment
Borelli said that in Connecticut, where he builds the units, many municipalities charge nothing when an accessory unit houses a family member, on the theory that towns want to keep the taxpayers who built them rather than force them out; rental units, he said, are sometimes treated differently. Chairman Rob Luntz acknowledged the catch from the board's side: a unit presented for a family member can become a rental a month later — not because anyone misled the board, but because circumstances change, and the board does not regulate that. In Luntz's words, "a $12,000 fee on a small building like this seems to be onerous to past applicants, and they voiced their concerns about it." Read 20:30▶
Haynes moved to approve with the fee condition struck, Eva Thaddeus seconded, and the vote was 5-0. The approval carries a three-year clock — a building permit must be issued and work diligently pursued — and a transfer condition: a new owner who wants to keep the cottage must notify the building department within 90 days of a change in ownership, or the approval is revoked.
The second application was a garage conversion at 284 Grand Street, where builder Bob Small is converting the existing structure for homeowner James Corbett's in-laws to use on summer visits. The footprint stays the same while the building is rebuilt to code; the unit is 499 square feet with one bedroom and a small office, finished to match the newly remodeled main house. Members found little to question.
The fee question returned. Luntz said the board has already sent the Village Board a memo asking for some latitude, since village attorneys have advised the board that "It's either 0 or $12,000." Read 30:30▶ The village encourages these projects, Luntz said, and accessory apartments carved out of existing homes carry no parkland fee at all — a mismatch, in the board's view. Krisky said asking new residents to contribute to parkland is reasonable, but "the amount as it is now is onerous." Read 31:58▶ Small suggested a fee based on construction cost; Krisky said square footage might work — some criteria fairer than all-or-nothing.
Krisky had made a direct request earlier in the evening, as the first application's fee discussion wound down. With more ADU applications expected, he said, "I would ask the building department to, nudge the board trustees to kinda at least review that for an answer as to whether we can have middle ground going forward." Read 19:04▶
John Ghegan moved to approve with the fee condition struck, Thaddeus seconded, and the vote was again 5-0, on the same three-year clock and ownership-notification condition.
In old business, the board gave final signage approval, 5-0, to Mirage Mirror & Glass at 425 South Riverside Avenue. The item was housekeeping: a January 2025 change-of-use approval required the business to obtain Advisory Board of the Visual Environment review of its sign and then return to the Planning Board. The visual environment board reviewed the sign in February 2025 and Sign Permit #20250002 was issued, but the return trip was missed through an oversight — which is why the item resurfaced Tuesday.
Two neighbors used the moment to ask about something bigger. Constancia Warren and Bruce Dollar of 1 Young Avenue, which overlooks the property, came to the microphone. Warren pointed to the resolution's environmental finding and asked, "Is that simply for the sign or does that cover any other environmental quality review?" Read 35:25▶
The answer, from board and staff: the sign only. Any redevelopment of the property would be a separate application with its own environmental review, mailed notice to neighbors about ten days in advance, and a public hearing. Warren said a development company has already spoken with adjoining property owners about plans for the site.
The scale of what may be coming became clearer in an engineering update later in the meeting. Salanitro said the property owner is expected back before the board: "They're coming in with a 49 unit building, so that's gonna be a big application." Read 49:55▶
Later, Barry Donaldson of 14 King Street asked whether the village has a comprehensive master plan — one that establishes where commercial and residential growth should go, makes room for the natural landscape, and addresses Main Street’s poor condition. Chairman Rob Luntz replied that the village has a comprehensive plan on file with the engineering department. Village Attorney Joshua Subin later confirmed that it is available under Public Documents and Comprehensive Plans on the village website.
Village Attorney Joshua Subin, who arrived late after having trouble joining by video, explained that public comment at planning meetings is tied to the agenda — public hearings and noticed items — rather than an open session.
Salanitro also reported that the applicant for 1360 Albany Post Road confirmed having been in touch with the state Department of Transportation, which is expected to contact village engineers. And Krisky, the board's liaison to the Conservation Advisory Council, said the CAC has begun reviewing dark-sky codes from Yorktown, Cortlandt and other municipalities for a recommendation to the trustees.
Both cottage approvals expire if permits are not issued and work started within three years. The parkland fee question, though, now sits with the trustees: whether the Planning Board keeps choosing between $12,000 and nothing, or finally gets an amount in between.
*Correction, October 19, 2026: The response about the comprehensive plan came from Chairman Rob Luntz, with online availability confirmed by Village Attorney Joshua Subin; it did not come from resident Barry Donaldson.*
Official minutes and final resolutions:Read the complete January 27 Planning Board record.
Share
Community Discussion
0 comments
One email per new comment on this story. You'll confirm by email first; unsubscribe any time. Your address is never shown publicly.
Be the first to comment on this story.
Sent to the editor for review
This is what you asked us to forward to the Village Board:
An editor reads it first. Once it goes, your comment here
will show a ✓ Forwarded to the Village Board mark —
that is your confirmation.
●The board will recommend that the trustees amend Local Law Introductory No. 3 to give the Planning Board authority to increase OR decrease parking requirements in all zoning districts; a parallel request to allow increased yard setbacks was dropped after the acting chairman objected
●Krisky separately asked the board to take up a review of the village's whole parking code, citing Maple Commons, where he said the approved lot is rarely more than 35 to 40% full
●The board asked the trustees to clarify whether Metro-North must seek village special permits, and for a count of existing special permits that will come up for renewal
●On Local Law Introductory No. 5, the board backed occupational preferences for emergency service, medical service and veteran applicants, asked that reservists be included, and asked for flexibility on part-time and independently employed home health aides
●The public hearing on Temple Israel of Northern Westchester's portico site plan at 31 Glengary Road was opened 3-0 and adjourned to the next meeting at the applicant's request; Steve Krisky recused himself, Rob Luntz was absent
Planning Board approves off-plan walls a week after neighbor's lawyers demanded a stop-work order
●Approved the Amended Minor Site Plan for Mark Franzoso at 23 Nordica Drive (Section 79.13, Block 4, Lot 64, RA-9 district), 5-0, on a motion by Geoffrey Haynes seconded by John Ghegan. Conditions: all conditions of the June 20, 2023 minor site plan resolution remain in effect, and an as-built survey must be submitted with the certificate of occupancy application.
●Classified the amended application a Type II action under SEQRA, requiring no negative declaration.
●Village Engineer Vincent Salanitro told the board the walls as built are zoning compliant, and his Dec. 2 memo says the north-side wall, though closer to the property line than approved, meets zoning requirements.
●A Dec. 2 Levin Law Group demand letter for neighbor Russell H. Davies of 27 Nordica Drive sought an inspection, a stop-work order, permit revocation, penalties and denial of the certificate of occupancy. According to the minutes, Village Attorney Dan Pozin advised that approving the amended plan addressed the letter's concerns.
●Steve Krisky disclosed an unsolicited conversation with Davies and declined to recuse himself.
●Adopted revised Planning Board Rules and Procedures, 5-0, on a motion by Steve Krisky seconded by John Ghegan: regular meetings on the second and fourth Tuesday of each month; the deputy chairperson serves as acting chairperson in the chairperson's absence; written communications due by noon the day before a meeting for inclusion in the backup material; no time limit for applicants to speak; standing agenda time for liaison and village engineer reports.
Planning Board Approves Temple Israel Security Upgrades and New Main Entrance on Glengary Road
●Approved the minor site plan, excavation and fill permit and stormwater pollution prevention plan for a new single-family house at 73 Melrose Avenue, 5-0, on a motion by Steve Krisky seconded by Geoff Haynes, with three added conditions: runoff calculations for the 100-year storm, a waiver of the off-street parking requirement, and the house height shown on the architectural plans.
●Approved final signage for The Grand at 130 Grand Street, 5-0, on a motion by Geoff Haynes seconded by Steve Krisky, after the board objected to advertising in the building's front flower beds.
●Approved final signage for Monday's Gift Shop at 125 Grand Street, 5-0, on a motion by Eva Thaddeus seconded by Steve Krisky, after clarifying the windows will carry white vinyl lettering on clear glass.
●Approved a building envelope modification at 8 Newton Court for Matthew and Ilana Robinson, 5-0, on a motion by John Ghegan seconded by Eva Thaddeus, conditioned on the applicants seeking a Zoning Board of Appeals variance for the gazebo.
●Told the Village Board of Trustees, on its referral of draft Local Law Introductory No. 14 of 2025, that the Planning Board does not see the need for an alternate member.
Planning Board asks for clearer sign rules, review deadlines and enforcement
●Continued review of Local Law Introductory No. 7 of 2026 and requested clearer definitions, size limits and approval procedures.
●Requested a 30-day response requirement for applications referred to the VEB.
●Proposed maintenance, temporary-sign and enforcement provisions.
●Recognized Eva Thaddeus’s resignation from the Planning Board and approved the April 14 minutes as amended, 5-0.
Experimental project: croton.news uses AI to generate articles from public records. Content may contain errors. Please report any inaccuracies and check our corrections log.AI-assisted experimental site — may contain errors. Corrections
Community Discussion
Be the first to comment on this story.
Sent to the editor for review
This is what you asked us to forward to the Village Board:
An editor reads it first. Once it goes, your comment here will show a ✓ Forwarded to the Village Board mark — that is your confirmation.