⚖️ Zoning Board of Appeals
ZBA seeks clarification on alternate-member proposal without taking a position
Oct 28, 2025 · 3750 words · 8 speakers
Meeting Agenda 4 items ▼
-
▶CALL TO ORDER at 7:00 p.m.
-
▶NEW BUSINESS
-
•Referral from the Village Board of Trustees to review draft Local Law Introductory No. 14 of 2025 to permit the Village Board of Trustees to appoint an alternate member to the Zoning Board of Appeals and Planning Board for the term of one official year.
-
•Discussion regarding the rescheduling of regular Zoning Board of Appeals meetings to either the first or third Tuesday of each month.
-
-
▶APPROVAL OF MINUTES
-
•Minutes of August 26, 2025
-
•Minutes of September 30, 2025
-
-
▶ADJOURNMENT
Key Actions & Decisions
- ◆ Agreed to send a memorandum requesting clarification of the proposed alternate-member law, without taking a position for or against it.
- ◆ Agreed to move regular meetings to the third Tuesday beginning December 16, 2025.
- ◆ Approved the August 26 minutes and the September 30 minutes with edits.
The Zoning Board of Appeals agreed on October 28, 2025, to send the village trustees questions about a proposed alternate-member law without taking a formal position for or against it. Members wanted clearer rules about participation, preparation and the length of an alternate’s term.
The meeting had no property applications. The board welcomed new member William Goldsmith, reviewed the referral from the trustees, discussed its meeting schedule and approved two sets of earlier minutes.
Draft Local Law Introductory No. 14 of 2025 would allow an alternate to serve when a regular Planning Board or ZBA member was absent, recused or otherwise unable to participate. The draft called for a one-year appointment and limited voting and quorum participation to occasions when the alternate was substituting for a member. It had been referred for review; the October 28 discussion did not enact it.
Chair Christine Wagner asked whether the proposal meant one alternate shared by the two boards or a separate alternate for each. She also questioned whether an alternate would participate in every hearing or sit with the board only when replacing a member. The discussion extended to how an alternate would follow continuing cases, attend site visits and prepare for an absence announced at short notice.
Members questioned whether a one-year term would provide enough time to gain experience. Some saw unnecessary complexity in a system they felt was functioning adequately; others saw value in avoiding delays when the board lacked its full membership. They sought an explanation of the problem the trustees intended to solve, along with the proposal’s advantages and disadvantages.
During public comment, Ed Riely of Truesdale Drive opposed the proposal, calling it unnecessary and arguing that an alternate could dilute the work of the existing boards. His view that an alternate would participate fully was disputed during the discussion. Another participant described an understanding from the Planning Board review that an alternate would join deliberations only when serving in a member’s place. The uncertainty reinforced the request for clearer wording.
The board settled on a memorandum summarizing those practical concerns rather than recommending adoption or rejection. The decision about whether to pass the law remained with the Board of Trustees.
On scheduling, members agreed to move regular ZBA meetings to the third Tuesday of the month beginning December 16, 2025. The official minutes connect the change to the Planning Board’s move to the second and fourth Tuesdays. This was an agreement on scheduling, rather than a recorded roll-call vote.
The board approved its August 26 minutes and approved its September 30 minutes with edits. James Tuman moved approval of the August minutes. Wagner moved approval of the September minutes after reviewing wording about the findings for the North Riverside Avenue addition and an Irving Avenue carport. Those edits concerned the record of the earlier meeting; they did not constitute new votes on those applications.
People
Official meeting record
Open the original record for this meeting.
Meeting Documents (8)
Attachments from the meeting packet, grouped by agenda item — each links to a searchable text page and the village's original PDF. Full meeting record with summaries →
APPROVAL OF MINUTES — Minutes of August 26, 2025
APPROVAL OF MINUTES — Minutes of September 30, 2025
NEW BUSINESS — Referral from the Village Board of Trustees to review draft Local Law Introductory No. 14 of 2025 to permit the Village Board of Trustees to appoint an alternate member to the Zoning Board of Appeals and Planning Board for the term of one official year.
More from Zoning Board of Appeals